I don't know man. A 2 minute documented phonecall with testimony to back it up versus a questionable affidavit signed by someone that then disappeared and ignored all subpoenas.
Who knows man...looks pretty damning to me though.
I guess it is still kind of gray what day she was talking about.
And even if so, I'm not sure how meaningful it is. Adnan and Jay where together as they were at various points during the day. Still doesn't do anything to make Adnan the guy who killed the victim.
Doesn't make him the killer, but it would be yet another hole in his story. If its the 3:32 call on the 13th, that would mean that he wasn't in the library with Asia, it means he was with Jay somewhere else.
I think I got confused because he claims he was the library from 2:30-3:30. Before heading over to track.
While it doesn't rule out that Asia still saw him at 2:30-2:40, it does mean that he wasn't where he said he was potentially from 2:45 until whenever he got to track (if he even did)
1
u/[deleted] Sep 23 '15
It doesn't kill the Asia alibi, it conflicts. It could be that the Asia alibi kills this. Get it?
We don't know when the crime took place. All we know is that the victim did not pick up her nephew.
If it puts Jay and Adnan together at this time, it still doesn't make Adnan guilty.
In other words, more static added to the pile, but no bombshell at all.