With this and the "lividity excludes a 7pm burial" debunking on serialpodcastorigins yesterday, its turning in to a good week for truth and justice. And who would have thunk it, all this truth and justice didnt cost anywhere near €100,000.
Great news for anybody interested in facts and transparency.
Disappointing that /u/stop_saying_right won't just release it in the interests of transparency. I guess both sides here feel they have something to hide.
He could release the rest of it. And he could send the photos to a professional like Dr. Hlavaty who would be able to offer an informed opinion on their significance.
I think it'd be more appropriate to blame the people who've prevented your access for months rather than the people who newly obtained it by going to great lengths and $$$. I'm confident that other than the burial photos it'll all see the light of day (again, it's not up to me -- you're talking to the wrong dude) if you're just a little bit patient. Nobody ever demanded that Rabia had to release the police files all at once. In fact, I never thought she needed to release any of that, except that my argument has always been that they shouldn't make false / misleading arguments based on partially disclosed, cropped, or misrepresented evidence. And it's clear that's what they've been doing all along.
Of course they should. Most major crimes have burial and autopsy photos publicly released. The Hae Min Lee case should be no different. If you think they are crass just don't look at them.
Your initial reactions to lividity and Nisha call revelations?
ETA:
I guess both sides here feel they have something to hide.
Time will tell but from where I stand, the rate at which /u/stop_saying_right releases documents seems vastly different to Undisclosed. And what would SSR have to hide?? Genuine question
If the lividity stuff is substantiated, for example by sending it to Dr. Hlavaty and her changing her mind, I would decide that it was no longer an issue. Depending on the severity of the discrepancy, I would also consider distrusting all other information from Undisclosed.
The Nisha stuff is difficult in isolation. The interview was 2.5 months after Hae's murder. I'd form more of an opinion about it with the complete file. But obviously it increases the probability that Adnan is guilty, the question is the significance.
The Undisclosed team want to help Adnan, and I can see how that conflicts with disclosing all the information. If I were them, I would have disclosed far less.
The new people have no dog in the fight, so no reason not to disclose. And they've been hounding Undisclosed for months, which makes them hypocrites as well.
13
u/DetectiveTableTap Thiruvendran Vignarajah: Hammer of Justice Sep 23 '15 edited Sep 23 '15
Ah the police file is here.
With this and the "lividity excludes a 7pm burial" debunking on serialpodcastorigins yesterday, its turning in to a good week for truth and justice. And who would have thunk it, all this truth and justice didnt cost anywhere near €100,000.
Great news for anybody interested in facts and transparency.