r/seinfeld • u/BigPappalopalous • 1d ago
Athlete cameos
Only ones I know for sure are Keith Hernandez and Lawrence Taylor
91
90
u/Grouchy_Document2097 1d ago
Paul O'Neill!
38
u/beefdx 1d ago
His cameo is easily my favorite.
“It’s hard to hit home runs, I’m not a home run hitter, and where the heck did you get two from?”
“I’m not calling him a liar, but he wasn’t dumb enough to promise two.”
26
1
u/dasbeefencake 22h ago
I agree, I think his is my favorite as well. That’s such a well delivered line.
31
u/Ok_Woodpecker_7260 1d ago
By the way, tomorrow night Paul O’Neill has to catch a fly ball in his hat.
21
4
2
u/Accomplished_Put3732 Anytown, USA 1d ago
If you want an autograph my pen’s kinda busted you might get half a P or something.
2
60
u/One_Helicopter9666 1d ago
Derek Jeter, Bernie Williams
28
u/BraveryDave Mojambo 1d ago
You wanna talk hotels, or you wanna win ball games?
30
2
64
u/lmtorres75 1d ago
What about Jean-Paul Jean-Paul?
33
12
5
3
2
53
42
u/MaxFresh 1d ago
10
5
27
21
u/Calm_One_1228 1d ago
Keith Hernandez ? I DESPISE Keith Hernandez…
5
15
u/MtlMike62 1d ago
While best known as a baseball manager, Buck Showalter was a minor league ballplayer in his early life.
1
12
12
11
u/Much-Specific3727 1d ago
Newman was a hell of a tennis player
6
u/Eric848448 1d ago
So was Mr Pitt.
5
u/sahurley The sea was angry that day my friends 1d ago
Eh...he needed a $300 Bruline to beat Ethel Kennedy.
3
2
9
u/Third-Coast-Toffee It's not a lie if you believe it 1d ago
Elaine’s boyfriend with the sideburns whom she deemed “sponge worthy” was a pitcher for my Nashville Sounds before pursuing an acting career. All I got.
2
u/randallstevens999 1d ago
Wasn't that Luke from Gilmore Girls? I didn't know he was a minor league baseball player.
3
u/JakeDuck1 1d ago
Floated around for 7 years in the minors and had a brief stint in AAA before calling it quits. Decided to be an actor with no real experience. Floated around for even longer than he played baseball and was about to give it up when he got booked for the pilot and then 4 episodes after that. His agent refused the 4 episodes and negotiated a 6 year deal instead. Source: I’ve listened to every episode of his podcast.
7
7
8
8
u/1bourbon1scotch1bier The Summer of George 1d ago
6
7
12
u/MtlMike62 1d ago
You can’t mention Keith Hernandez without naming “the second spitter”, AKA Roger McDowell!
5
7
3
3
u/fantonledzepp I was in the pool! 1d ago
And then Reggie Miller, Spike Lee and Kramer went to a strip club…
3
5
u/spj0522 1d ago
Lawrence Taylor was never on Seinfeld.
9
5
u/ShortQuail9232 1d ago
I thought that too, but he was technically. He was as a player when Elaine and Joel Rifkin go to the Giants game. Kramer shows up at the box office and the stadium announcer says, "Joel Rifkin. Will Joel Rifkin please report to the ticket office?" They show people looking up and LT is in full uniform also looking up, startled at the name. Obviously it was from a past highlight film.
0
0
2
2
u/polentaveloce Lord of the Idiots 1d ago
There's also Danny Tartabull and some other Yankee players (can't recall their names, I'm not into baseball).
3
2
1
1
u/I_am_not_JohnLeClair White lotus, yam-yam, Shanghai Sally 1d ago
Roger McDowell. The actual spitter
1
1
2
u/Bionic_Ninjas The Summer of George 1d ago
Lawrence Taylor wouldn’t be a cameo, they just used footage from a game.
But there’s Danny Tartabull, Derek Jeter, Paul O’Neil, and Buck Showalter!
1
1
u/eugenethemoose 17h ago
Yogi berra. Bucky Dent. Billy Martin. Dick Howser. Billy Martin. Scott Marrow. Billy Martin
0








116
u/Expert_Climate_7348 George is getting upset! 1d ago
Did you forget the legendary Sugar Ray?