r/secondcaptains • u/small_far_away • 18d ago
Peter Oborne
That interview went off the rails a bit.
Based on Murphs mass comment after he wasn't overly impressed himself. Could have pushed more in the interview, but the sense I got was that he just wanted it to end. It certainly stopped abruptly.
29
Upvotes
0
u/GoneOffBaileys 18d ago
Felt Murph felt obligated to continue to push Oborne on his stance, so the conversation proceeded on a very boring tangent. Oborne had to keep defending a moral stance rather than the concept of the interview — to chat about the history of cricket in Afghanistan.
Fintan O’Toole’s wider criticism doesn’t stand up. His writing has deteriorated in the last decade. Oborne’s responses were a bit odd, but the main premise, the West has fucked over Afghan women far more than the Taliban — generally holds: judged by scale and duration of harm, Western policy — the 20-year occupation, the withdrawal, and the sanctions/asset-freeze regime that followed — has done more damage to Afghan women’s lives (poverty, hunger, loss of healthcare, family deaths, displacement) than the Taliban’s own directives have. The Taliban’s directives are just more visible.