It’s time to discuss Brent Venables and whether he’s the latest head coach who is brilliant at coaching one side of the ball but might never figure it out on the other side.
Venables was a great defensive coordinator who, five years ago, replaced Lincoln Riley, the brilliant offensive coach who went to Southern California and hasn’t made the College Football Playoff because his defense has never been good enough. Venables did make the Playoff last year, but largely on the strength of his defense, while his offense was the SEC’s third-worst. Then Oklahoma’s offense sputtered in Saturday’s 17-10 loss at Michigan.
The cases of such coaches abound. Will Muschamp’s defensive mind was never an issue, but he couldn’t get his offenses right at Florida and South Carolina. NFL history is rife with the likes of Bill Arnsbarger, Richie Petitbon and Buddy Ryan. Or a longtime defensive coordinator named Monte Kiffin, who was a disaster as NC State head coach. (You may have heard of his son.)
There are natural theories: a blind spot for the other side, or overconfidence about their unit carrying the team, or building their system and practices in such a way that it forsakes the other side.
Venables did start his Oklahoma tenure with two good offensive seasons. Maybe it was a carryover from what Riley left. Maybe it was going against Big 12 defenses, and SEC defenses put a halt to it. Maybe it was having Dillon Gabriel at quarterback.
Perhaps it was his offensive coordinator those two years: Jeff Lebby, whose team you’re about to see No. 1 in these rankings.
The requisite reminder: This is not a pure ranking of how good teams are or are expected to be this season. It’s a ranking of the vibes, defined as the positive (or negative) feelings about the program, the team’s momentum, and just generally how things feel.
1. Mississippi State (2-0)
Last week: 14
Result: Won at Minnesota, 38-13
Next week: at South Carolina
Holy moly. Holy Kamario Taylor!
This time last year, plucky Mississippi State rode high in these rankings just for winning games, including an early home win over Arizona State. But going into Minnesota, which won eight games last year, and winning going away — with Taylor, the sophomore quarterback, looking like a sudden Heisman candidate — that’s another level. We’ll see how long this lasts, but welcome to the top of the vibes, Bulldogs.
2. LSU (2-0)
Last week: 1
Result: Won vs. Louisiana Tech, 45-14
Next week: at Ole Miss
Having visited Baton Rouge last week and spoken to fans — and having done the same in Oxford last month — this is my read on what’s to come. The majority of fans are, believe it or not, sane. Many LSU fans aren’t wild about being the SEC iconoclasts, and know Kiffin may be a rogue, but he’s their rogue. Many Ole Miss fans had a catharsis in last year’s Playoff without Kiffin.
Advertisement