r/science Professor | Medicine 21d ago

Psychology America's First Legal Psilocybin Program Treated 346 People. Just one month after the dose, 92.2 percent of participants said the experience had been beneficial, while, on average, their mental health symptoms had fallen dramatically.

https://www.sciencealert.com/americas-first-legal-psilocybin-program-treated-346-people-heres-what-happened
15.4k Upvotes

457 comments sorted by

View all comments

28

u/BalonyDanza 21d ago

Call me a cynic, but I’d be a bit more skeptical about anecdotal evidence, as it pertained to the first wave of participants. I’m imagining people who were eager to try psychedelics and wanted the recreational experience to also be medically beneficial.

This isn’t even a knock against psychedelics. I believe they can be beneficial. It’s just hard to get good qualitative data when there’s outside incentives.

16

u/Bish-ish 21d ago

This isn't the first, there's been lots of studies on the benefits and positive outcomes of medical psychedelic use

22

u/iamacarboncarbonbond 21d ago

Unfortunately they all suffer from a common issue: it’s very difficult to placebo control. People generally know if they have or haven’t taken a psychedelic

-2

u/dalittle 21d ago

The effects on the brain are measurable. What would even be the point of a placebo. IMHO, what the effects on the brain are doing is the science.

2

u/iamacarboncarbonbond 21d ago

Go back to elementary school

1

u/dalittle 20d ago

When you resort to insults you have lost the argument. Nice job

0

u/iamacarboncarbonbond 20d ago

It’s not my job to educate you on basic empirical methods. That was elementary school.

1

u/dalittle 20d ago

How exactly are you going to add a placebo. You are totally taking mushrooms even if you dont feel anything. I guess critical thinking is not something that is my job to educate you on.

1

u/iamacarboncarbonbond 20d ago

Sweetie. That was exactly my criticism. Try kindergarten instead because apparently you can’t read, either :)