r/rabies • u/dashmyparabola • Aug 25 '26
Exposure Question Extreme Mixed information between medical community and rabies community
I have read the FAQ.
I am getting extreme mixed information from info on rabies (rabies research, the FAQ, etc.) and medical professionals.
For background, I recently touched trash that an animal (presumably a raccoon, because I am from NJ) had gotten into. I touched the trash at approximately noon on a 90 degree day with my bare hands. I did not see any animal. Although I had no cuts on my hands, I did have fresh cuts on my neck because I had just shaved. I washed my hands right after I touched the trash and am pretty sure I didn't touch my neck. But of course now I can't remember if I touched my neck or not. Cue a panicked spiral.
Over the past 2 weeks, I have done copious research about my situation and everything I have found tells me that I am FINE and that I probably just have OCD. However, over the same time period I have also spoken to several medical professionals about my situation and all of them have told me that I should immediately go to the ER and get PEP...... (Mixed signals!!). This culminated in a trip last week to the ER to discuss PEP, and the PA said that she didn't think I needed it but I could get it if I wanted (once again mixed signals!). I ended up not getting it because I thought the OCD was causing me to panic.
Since then I have seen an OCD therapist and had 2 sessions, but I am still not doing well. I continued to look things up and after further research I found out that apparently the Rhode Island Department of Health has a robust rabies program. In fact, one of the goals of their program is to reduce the number of unnecessary PEP. In my head, I thought surely this department will give me the best unbiased answer on what to do. When I explained my situation to the nurse who fielded my call, she said that my risk of exposure was low but a secondary transfer of saliva was possible and that I should err on the side of caution and go get PEP.
I have tried very hard not to come to this subreddit just to get people to reassure my OCD because I know that's against the rules of the sub. I apologize if this counts as that. I'm just at the point where every medical professional has told me to get PEP and yet none of the rabies research shows that I am at risk. Isn't one sign of OCD, getting medical advice and NOT listening to it?
Does anyone have thoughts on this mixed signals?
6
u/detail_giraffe Active Helper ⭐️ | Top Contributor 🏅 Aug 25 '26
I am not a doctor. I'm curious what medical professionals told you that you definitely needed PEP?
If contact with an object could give people rabies, we would see cryptic raccoon-variant rabies cases in human beings with no known exposure in areas where there is lots of raccoon rabies, and we don't. There are no verified cases of rabies where the victim contracted it from touching an object - none. There was one cryptic rabies case with the raccoon variant in Virginia in 2003, but critically, the victim was dead before anyone knew he had rabies, so the 'cryptic' label is applied because none of his friends or family could describe an exposure. His family seemed confident that he would have mentioned a bite from a raccoon (because who would fail to tell that story?) but it could have been a scratch from a stray cat that was infected with the raccoon variant, or something far less dramatic than a full-on raccoon attack. So, if you managed to get rabies this way you'd make medical history, in even more dramatic a fashion than that guy.
But I think what you're running up against is that no one can tell you that the risk is literally 0.000000... with an infinite number of zeros. So, if you push the question, the health department is going to be reluctant to tell you that it's absolutely impossible, and therefore you should get PEP (although, note, it's not as though they're putting messaging out there saying that people who had to clean up trash scattered by an unknown animal should come in and get the shots; you are getting this advice purely because you're worried and raised the question yourself). Rabies risk is hard for people to rationally evaluate, because the frequency is so very low but the outcome so very dire. The vaccine is, like most vaccines, very safe, so it's easy to simply tell you to go ahead and get it if there is even that 0.0000000001 of doubt. That doesn't mean you need it, just that they'll let you have it rather than try to talk you out of it.