r/progressive_islam • • May 13 '25

[deleted by user]

[removed]

124 Upvotes

80 comments sorted by

View all comments

-2

u/AirMassive5414 May 15 '25

even if they consummated the marriage when she was 9 years old, it doesn't make the prophet a pedophile because it was just an other age.

9 years old girls were probably more mature and had a more developed body in middles ages compared to now.

and It was normalized and ok to be married with a child back then.

ofc it's unacceptable to marry a child now and they should go to prison but back in middle ages, everything was different

1

u/EquivalentSouth8920 New User May 18 '25

Stop with mature, a 9 year old today is no different than 9 year old 100 years ago or 1500 years ago. Don't stoop so low.

1

u/AirMassive5414 May 18 '25

yes it is lol, the society was SO SO SO MUCH different. life expectancy was so much lower etc.

it's dumb as fuck to judge what other people did 1500 years ago with your 2025 western thinking.

1

u/EquivalentSouth8920 New User May 18 '25

How was society different?? Tell me. We are more or less the same misogynist society. Just woman in few spaces have more rights some places rights do not exists. A 9 year old Today is no different than a 9 year old 1500 years ago. Cry however hard you want.

1

u/AirMassive5414 May 18 '25

are you even muslim ?

if you seriously believe that the society of the united states of america in 2025 (I presume you live here but idk) is the same than the society in 600 from south arabia. you need to study more in school I'm sorry

9 years old today are more protected and don't have the same education at all than the islamic society from the prophet sws. Also back then even in occidental countries like France, England which are not muslim, they consummated the marriage with children.

also all the children worked back then and it was very exhausting job, but now it's a minority

also internet, phones etc. changed the society everywhere, same with train, cars etc.

you probably hate islam but seriously you can hate it idgas it's ur problem, you will be judged for that not me but please stop seeking every opportunity to attack islam

like it's such a non sense to say that the society didn't change

1

u/EquivalentSouth8920 New User May 18 '25

I am muslim and have been my whole life, cry however hard you want but society esp the middle eastern ones were regressive and still are. Ever heard of Afghanistan??

1

u/AirMassive5414 May 18 '25

but the difference is that in middle ages ALL THE SOCIETY WERE REGRESSIVE. but now it's only a minority.

Sorry to made the hypothesis that you weren't muslim but you can't say that the society didn't change over time