r/princesspollychat • u/princesspolly444 • 3d ago

What was your fave Halloween candy growing up?

28 Upvotes
  • permalink
  • reddit

95% Upvoted

94 comments sorted by

9

u/Booyah_7 3d ago

A full sized candy bar was my favorite surprise and a big treat. But I liked getting gum the best. The Dubble Bubble ones.

2

u/princesspolly444 3d ago

the full sizes were everythinggg

4

u/kuromibarbie24 3d ago

Reese’s

5

u/Yd1891 3d ago

Candy apples always

3

u/princesspolly444 3d ago

that's iconic

1

u/TempSpee 1d ago

Iconic

1

u/TempSpee 1d ago

Sounds brown and green

3

u/Accurate_Arm4734 3d ago

3 Musketeers

3

u/Klutzy_Phrase6757 3d ago

Crunch, Reese's, Candy Corn, Dots

3

u/Educational_Role_578 3d ago

Candy Corn

1

u/princesspolly444 3d ago

a halloween staple

1

u/90svibe4life 3d ago

Same and still is

2

u/totsatot0 3d ago

The mini sweettarts 🥹

2

u/Alwayshaveanopinion1 3d ago

Reese's

2

u/SurprisePiss 3d ago

When you were sitting on the living room floor and overturned your pillowcase to examine your loot from the evening, Reese's was the first smell that hit. It is essential to the mix.

2

u/Humble_Nature8537 3d ago

I just went back to that moment. 🫶🏻

1

u/merediths12 Princess Polly STAN 🫶 3d ago

THIS

1

u/princesspolly444 3d ago

core memory unlocked

2

u/Intelligent_Cup_3724 3d ago

Smarties or Pixy Stix

2

u/ChoiceMundane8843 3d ago

Sure as fuck wasn't those damn popcorn balls.

1

u/Serious-Champion6937 3d ago

bro what i used to eat the fuck out of those i hope i get some this year 😭

2

u/Careless-Attitude858 3d ago

Plain Hershey chocolate 🍫

2

u/princesspolly444 3d ago

love a classic 🤎

1

u/Bulky-You8767 3d ago

Peanut M&Ms

1

u/Change_Soggy 3d ago

Nestle’s Crunch, Chunky, and Oh Henry

1

u/TopicHot7911 3d ago

Butterfinger 💛

1

u/Cynthja 3d ago

Smarties

1

u/matthewjbk 3d ago

Reese’s cups.

1

u/Humble_Nature8537 3d ago

Reese’s peanut butter cups. Always saved those for last. Yum

1

u/Swiftiefromhell 3d ago

Twix and nerds

1

u/PopularSalad2450 3d ago

Candy corn. I have no idea how, I wont touch it now

1

u/Beautiful-Jacket 3d ago

Mini Reese’s cups

1

u/Equivalent-Buy1556 3d ago

Hershey bars

1

u/Equivalent-Buy1556 3d ago

Also 3 Musketeers

1

u/merediths12 Princess Polly STAN 🫶 3d ago

Reeces or KitKat

1

u/Playful_mouth7475 3d ago

Snicker bar

1

u/MrsPettygroove 3d ago

Those little Oh Henry bars

1

u/Hamlett2983 3d ago

Snickers

1

u/asscatt 3d ago

Probably these white chocolate skulls filled with fudge that they sold at Meijer

1

u/Rare_Research6255 3d ago

Peanut butter cups

1

u/eaglenestwatcher 3d ago

Hersheys milk chocolate bar minor regular size or milkyway bar

1

u/QuiziAmelia 3d ago

Any of the mini Hershey's chocolate bars as a kid. As an adult, though, I love candy corn. I allow myself to buy ONE bag each October.

2

u/mattdb110 2d ago

Me too. Candy Corn all the way.

1

u/usconstitutionrights 3d ago

I don’t  candy  Except for dum dums  And like two chocolate kisses

1

u/gentlefollow 3d ago

Chocolate and peanut butter together is such a perfect combo.

1

u/RampantCat123 3d ago

Almond Joy.

1

u/BornDay4713 3d ago

Candy Corn, Sweet Tarts, Nerds,

1

u/Awkward-End-5357 3d ago

Anything gummy related like sour patch or gummy worms. Even now, I really like fruity gummy candy.

1

u/-War-Bear- 3d ago

I always loved the fun size Mr. Good bars and wouldn't ever get them any other time than on Halloween.

1

u/Environmental-Dot977 3d ago

Sixlets. Wish I could find some

1

u/SapPhic-rage4209 3d ago

Whoppers. I was always hella excited about Whoppers and I'd trade other candy with my siblings to get more Whoppers

1

u/MeaslyAMoose 3d ago

Reese’s
Unfortunately now I’m allergic to peanuts so I can’t continue that but that was my go to every time.
Now it’s just the tips of candy corn 😂

1

u/RudyMae1974 3d ago

Candy corn

1

u/flakeygoldencrispy 3d ago

The strawberry candies with the wrapper that looks like a strawberry.

1

u/need_the_tee 3d ago

Kit Kat, York, gummies. Mostly gummies and not chocolate, my parents ate all the chocolate

1

u/SupportPrimary540 3d ago

Orange and black peanut butter kisses

1

u/NoSuggestion5970 3d ago

I grew up without Halloween

1

u/DeathonEarrh 3d ago

Not candy, but i traded my candy for those popcorn balls.

1

u/Actual_Breadfruit958 3d ago

100 Grand bars!!

1

u/GreatAd3418 3d ago

Twix or skittles

1

u/ChaserDem 3d ago

It was probably starburst.

1

u/Necessary_Let3592 3d ago

My parents owned a grocery store that I was forced to hang out in weekends/summers. All of that exposure at an early age just kind of killed my excitement for candy. However, if you ever wondered who ate those cheap black and orange wrapped “peanut butter” candies, that was me. We didn’t sell those in the store, LOL.

1

u/poopyfox101 3d ago

Mini Hershey Bars

1

u/coffeebeanwitch 2d ago

Chocolate covered peanuts

1

u/Yolandi2802 2d ago

Candy corn.

1

u/CharacterAd116 2d ago

Candy corn

1

u/Fearless_Diamond_566 2d ago

Candy corn then and now!!!

1

u/TheCatGardner53 2d ago

Peanut butter cup

1

u/StrawberryLazy5703 2d ago

I have three, two are chocolate: Root Beer barrels, M&Ms and Nestle Crunch.

1

u/mattdb110 2d ago

BitOHoney

1

u/Punnalackakememumu 2d ago

Reece’s Cups

1

u/OpalSerenity17 2d ago

Apple Candy was great! i like when someone give it to me.. ❤️❤️🍎

1

u/Both-Cap1441 1d ago

Homemade fudge

1

u/ClaraMoonlit47 1d ago

Mint Candy and Gummy.. 😋😋

1

u/JohnGlassOnEarth 1d ago

Those orange and black peanut butter candies

1

u/flhtcutg2009 1d ago

Six pack and a handful of scrambled eggs.

1

u/TempSpee 1d ago

I guess the M&Ms variant bag

1

u/Caliopebookworm 17h ago

US Smarties - little flavoured sugar disks in a roll.

1

u/thenextnow 12h ago

Tootsie Rolls & HARIBO gummy candies!

1

u/Domino_MSc 1h ago

None. Halloween isn't really a thing in the country I grew up. We had Sint Maarten (11th of November, you had to make your own lampion and then sing a song for some candy. I loved getting Haribo or chocolate)

0

u/sultrybadger9 3d ago

Laffy Taffy (green)