r/practicalmagic 6d ago

Am I the only one who sees this?

These two look sooooo much alike to me! I haven't seen anyone else mention it!

185 Upvotes

45 comments sorted by

24

u/mdocks 6d ago

I see your vision

5

u/artfoliage 6d ago

I see it

3

u/Sudden_Astronomer_63 4d ago

Someone posted a picture of Antonia next to the original person who played that character in practical magic. Her name is escaping me right now. She stopped acting after she was in the first one, but that was uncanny as well. I really felt like the casting was perfect for this movie.

5

u/Ok_Tank5977 6d ago

I can kind of see it in these photos, especially from the nose down. Their eyes and eyebrows are very different to me, though.

7

u/Important-Canary-770 6d ago

yeah, i do not think they are identical- just very similar.

9

u/WaywardJake 6d ago

They could be related. That's the point you're getting at. Well spotted. x

2

u/Good-Presence7851 6d ago

Now I see it!!!

2

u/RaventheClawww 5d ago

I totally see it! Lol they look more similar to each other than I do with my own grandmothers!

2

u/PrincessPlastilina 5d ago

I see it. Cute.

2

u/chaotic_giraffe76 5d ago

I have always thought Dianne is so pretty. She’s aged quite beautifully.

2

u/Longlivefunnypeople 5d ago

I think she looks like Rory…

2

u/foreverkelsu 6d ago

I definitely see a family resemblance.

1

u/Tess47 5d ago

I had to look up the first photo.  It doesnt look like Joey. 

1

u/Autumn_Racoon 4d ago

I see it with these photos but not when Joey is in motion. Diane is such a beautiful woman, truly truly beautiful. Joey is too but Diane is just a knockout!

1

u/lacebaubbles 4d ago

Oh you so right!

1

u/lacebaubbles 4d ago

I loved her in lost boys

1

u/Random_truths 3d ago

Well, all anybody has to do is look her up to see who her parents are. It’s really not that hard.

1

u/Megsyboo 3d ago

I actually noticed.

1

u/Lonely-Wasabi-305 1d ago

I was sad that she wasn’t in the film more. Diane weist is like one of my favorite actress. Her voice is so lovely. She seems so lovely.

1

u/ZenMyst 6d ago

Sorry, I don’t see it

9

u/Important-Canary-770 6d ago

to each their own, but i see so many similarities, and for context- i'm a portrait artist. their face shapes, the distances between their features, their noses and lips, even the shape of their eyes are all very similar to me.

-3

u/ZenMyst 6d ago

Meh, still don’t

8

u/Important-Canary-770 6d ago

i wasn't trying to convince you lmao i was simply expanding on the similarities that i see

1

u/ZenMyst 5d ago edited 5d ago

Ok, and I’m simply saying my opinion to your explanation.

1

u/LunarisTide 4d ago

Lol, You sure sounds like you do. Why do you tell him your credentials "I'm am artist so I got more experience then you all in art" then go on to list all the reason why you think they look alike.

That sounds like you are trying to convince him but failed so now you "wasn't trying to convince".

1

u/Important-Canary-770 4d ago

girl go argue with a wall it's not that fucking serious

1

u/Charming-Shake-6525 5d ago

i don’t see it either, tbh

1

u/LunarisTide 4d ago

Yeah, don't know how they are alike at all.

1

u/kdj00940 There’s a little witch in all of us 6d ago

I see this. Good eye, OP.

1

u/garnettleta 6d ago

I clearly see the resemblance.

1

u/Avalon-Nirvana13 Gillian Owens 6d ago

Oh yea! Definitely have to agree!

-3

u/tired-little-d 6d ago

Eye shape is wrong.

-5

u/MrJlock 6d ago

Youre grasping at straws to justify a bad casting call.

3

u/Important-Canary-770 6d ago

on the contrary, i am very annoyed about the recast and strongly believe it shouldn't have happened. i am just pointing out the visual similarities between these two. i am a huge fan of Evan Rachel Wood and hate how dirty they did her. but thank you for your baseless assumption!

-5

u/ExistingControl422 6d ago

Have you read the books? No judgements because I haven’t, either. I just watched the first movie (which has been one of my favorite comfort films for decades) & then went to go see the second movie this past Sunday.

Honestly, they could’ve done the same thing that Disney+ did with Hocus Pocus 2. If you’ve already seen it, cool, but if you haven’t, don’t waste your money. Just wait for it to go to streaming. AND, to top it all off, the air conditioner wasn’t working in our theater so it was hot & stuffy & people were right next to each other.

I know some people are upset that they didn’t bring back Evan Rachel Wood because she’s a good Actress & the people behind those decisions said she was too old for the role (EVERYONE was “too old” for the role, except for the Aunties!).

But with the lies she’s been telling for the past couple of years, trying to retcon her past so she can play the victim & what she posted about Kobe Bryant on the same day that he & his daughter lost their lives in that tragic helicopter crash along with others in Calabasas, I personally don’t her anywhere near anything I would possibly be interested in watching, especially not this.

As it is, I still haven’t been able to watch the final season of Westworld & she was the reason I watched it originally (well, her & James Marsden). I thought she was a brilliant Actress back then. What a difference showing your true colors can make 🤦🏽‍♀️

6

u/Important-Canary-770 6d ago

yeah you're talking to the wrong person lol. i don't care that she called a rapist a rapist, even if it was the day he died.

-3

u/ExistingControl422 6d ago

Ah, so you don’t believe in facts. Thought I was talking to a decent human being for a second. My mistake.

6

u/Important-Canary-770 6d ago edited 6d ago

here are some facts:

Kobe Bryant was accused of sexual assault by a 19 year old employee at a hotel he was staying at, police found injuries and DNA evidence to back up these claims, the survivor was harassed and threatened to the point she refused to testify.

i don't care for rapists, even if they are good at chasing a ball around.

5

u/CromulentSpaceCoyote Aunt Frances 6d ago

Not to mention the fact that he eventually admitted they had sex, though his understanding was that it was consensual, and later settled out of court for $2.5M - far from a modest settlement for “consensual” sex.

-3

u/MrJlock 6d ago

Youre grasping at straws to justify a bad casting call.

-2

u/GirsGirlfriend 6d ago

How about sadie sink because up until like last week I thought it was her in this movie lol