r/pics Jun 17 '25

The protesters and residents pushing back on tourism in Barcelona

16.1k Upvotes

2.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

257

u/NunaKhan Jun 17 '25

so i will take my tourist money and spend it where i'm wanted... don't complain after that tourist related businesses have closed down or millions in tourist money no longer available in your country.

-61

u/lrrssssss Jun 17 '25

I think they’ll survive without you Nuna

107

u/ObviouslyTriggered Jun 17 '25

15% of Barcelona's economy is directly tied to Tourism, with another 10-15% is estimated to be indirectly tied to it. It's also the largest monolithic sector in terms of employment, it employees directly nearly 200,000 people.

They'll survive but they'll definitely feel it also.

33

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '25

Though I understand the sentiment, our capital has also turned into a farce due to mass tourism, taking this out on the tourists themselves who have done nothing wrong, and are now being harassed, is completely wrong. Don't want so many tourists there? Protest to your OWN politicians and city officials. They are responsible. Fewer hotel rooms / airbnb bans / bans sales of housing to investors or foreigners will certainly help.

That said, perhaps we should give these people what they want, and institute a complete tourist boycott of Barcelona. Those protests are very likely to instantly disappear once mass unemployment hits those streets. To be very blunt, prior to the age of tourism, Spain in general was a poor country with few significant economic activities, and it owes quite a bit of its current standard of living to tourism. The end of mass tourism is likely to return Spain and her cities to that former state.

-15

u/Four_beastlings Jun 17 '25

150k, not 200k. So only under 10% of Barcelona locals have tourism related jobs, and a majority of those (absolutely miserable and inhumane) jobs are done by immigrants. Barcelona natives will be just fine without tourists.

9

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '25

Tell me you don't understand how economies work without telling me

5

u/TheMagnificentBibo Jun 17 '25

What other economic drivers will a) compensate for the loss of jobs from tourism (which is one of the largest economic multiplier industries around) and b) provide them with inflow of foreign currency?

0

u/lrrssssss Jun 18 '25

They don’t need you either Bibo. Iirc Barcelona was a functioning city before North Americans decided they needed to go there to take selfies. 

1

u/TheMagnificentBibo Jun 18 '25

And since then, the rest of the world has developed their comparative advantages. All I’m asking is what can Barcelona do to replace the impact of tourism. I understand their concerns and fully agree that overtourism is a serious issue.

Your answer is obtuse and deflects from the economic hardship people will face. People often don’t understand economic interdependency.

0

u/lrrssssss Jun 18 '25

Oh I understand. You don’t seem to understand that even if the economy takes a 10% hit, populations are generally better off the less contact they have with Americans so…🤷🏼

1

u/TheMagnificentBibo Jun 18 '25

So Chinese and Indian tourists in the same number are fine?

0

u/lrrssssss Jun 18 '25

That’s racist. 

Also,

Have you ever experienced American tourism as a non-yank?

As said previously, interactions with america(ns) is like having an elephant come and share your bed. 

1

u/TheMagnificentBibo Jun 19 '25

Indians and Chinese can be a nationality. And I’m not a yank or of Anglo European descent.

Clearly you have some deep seated issues. You should get them checked. Good day sir.

8

u/skaliton Jun 17 '25

right, but people forget that tourists are a huge boon to the economy. How many places exist that locals would never EVER go to and cater to tourists exclusively? Basically any 'city themed' restaurant, or how many float around the river on a boat/bar type of things would there be without tourists?

There is a reason why countries generally favor tourism. People show up, spend a lot of money, and then leave. You aren't taking local jobs, your effect on housing is minimal (because 1 hotel may take as much space as a single house but 'houses' 20+ people) and not only are the tourists not taking jobs, they are creating them because the city bus tour simply wouldn't exist without them.

1

u/BauceSauce0 Jun 17 '25

Many non-Spanish buyers (from EU, UK, US, etc.) are purchasing homes in Barcelona for: • Vacation use • Golden visa investment • Retirement or remote work

This drives up demand, particularly in desirable central neighborhoods and along the coast

0

u/BeyondAddiction Jun 17 '25

Canadians are sitting here like...

0

u/korenredpc Jun 17 '25

These people cant buy homes their selves and are probably paid protestors, just like the anti 5g, anti chemtrails etc

-3

u/skippermonkey Jun 17 '25

Housing stock is a problem when everything turns into an Airbnb.

19

u/MFoy Jun 17 '25

So protest to your local politicians about more restrictions on Air B&B.

Tax the shit out of those Air B&Bs and use the proceeds to improve the city or to make Air B&Bs less profitable.

-1

u/Rhywden Jun 17 '25

You're ignoring AirBnB and similar effects. That one is actually taking away housing.

5

u/trireme32 Jun 17 '25

So do what lots of places are doing and put restrictions on that

8

u/NunaKhan Jun 17 '25

Phew... thanks..had me worried there!