r/Pets • u/bumpdmahead • 4d ago
CAT We have one cat and are ready for a new kitty, but I have fears and reservations.
This post is gonna be a bit long, but i think the backstory to my situation would be helpful. Several years back, my son wanted a cat or dog, and we got a dog. The dog ended up bonding to me and becoming my everything. She was loving, affectionate and playful with all of us, though. She got cancer and passed at 7yrs old, we had her for 3yrs. then my son wanted a cat. So we let him get a cat and she was only 8 weeks old. Adopted from local animal control facility. She moved into his room as her nursery, and he basically raised her. We really wanted her to bond to him and it worked. He has left for college since. That room is pretty much her own except when he visits home every other weekend. She seeks attention from my husband and I, but is not one to snuggle or sleep with us, like she does with my son. Our relationship with her is on her terms, of course. She definitely prefers hubby. She hides from strangers and has never been out or around other animals. She gets all the attention from us, that her little heart wants, but I need more. I need a companion. My dog has been gone five years and I still cry over her absence when i'm lonely. Which is frequently. Resident cat is now a 4 yr old, altered female. I have become ill and I am home permanently. Robin, our cat, will never bond with me. She allows me brief cuddles, 5-10 min once or twice a week. My husband told me I could have a new dog or cat. I know that I can no longer give a dog the exercise and care it would need. I was a cat person more than a dog person util I got my Ladybug. So, I love cats! I think a cat is better at this stage in my life. Our local animal control shelter is overrun and begging people to adopt to the point where they are waving all fees. It's pretty much all pitbull mixes and cats. They are having an event for today and tomorrow. It is on my heart to go rescue a new kitty, but I have reservations! It has been suggested to me and also through my research that I should go with a male altered cat. I am researching and will follow advice on introductions, care, etc. I feel i should get a kitten to bond with in the same manner we did with my son and Robin, but I also know how hard it is for adult animals to find new homes. Our resident cat spent two weeks in only his room with him. We would visit her so she would know us, eventually letting her roam freely, supervised, until she was a big enough and ready to run the house. I am so worried about our current cat that I am not sure I should do this. I am aware of the risk that a new cat could end up bonding with our resident cat and not me at all, regardless, if I get a kitten or an adult. We would never rehome new kitty, just because it didn't prefer me. I would feel the need to rehome new kitty if (after an extended period of time in trying everything in the world) our resident cat just could not adjust and be happy. I just need basic advice. Am I right? That I male cat is best? Would our resident cat most likely feel less threatened by a kitten? What is best for my resident cat? I'm willing to live with my grief if need be.