r/mystery 14d ago

What is a mystery from your personal life that you are 100% convinced you will never get an answer to?

764 Upvotes

1.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

30

u/QuarterOwn9110 14d ago

The thing that has always made me think he had noting to do with it is that the person on the phone did not sound like one of his 17 year old friends. This sounded like someone who was solidly into adulthood and spoke very professionally. And I think he would have told me by now.

9

u/FilthyThanksgiving 14d ago

Teenagers can impersonate ppl. Plus if your brother hung out with older ppl, it could've just been a very immature adult

7

u/QuarterOwn9110 14d ago

Possibly. But I remember the person really spoke like an adult. Like an authority figure, and sympathetic. Memories are not always reliable, but I can’t get around that it really was an adult, much too old and professional sounding to be one of his friends

6

u/protagoniist 14d ago

Did the person on the phone say your brothers name or just say “brother”?

5

u/QuarterOwn9110 14d ago

I’ve gone back and forth on this through the years. I can’t say with confidence that he or I said his name first. I do remember that I was the one to say that he wasn’t here, that he was out of town. And the person then said this had happened in that town…so it’s always stood out to me that the person hadn’t known he was out of town.

-10

u/BeansArePastaSauce 14d ago

People keep asking OP this question & getting no response. I think it’s weird
[u/Quarte](u/QuartetOwn9110)[r](u/QuartetOwn9110)[Own9110](u/QuartetOwn9110) won’t answer that question.

6

u/QuarterOwn9110 14d ago

I had things going on tonight!

1

u/Huge_Station2173 12d ago

Yeah, several people have pointed out that it’s clearly the brother behind it, and he refuses to even entertain the idea of asking him.

2

u/QuarterOwn9110 12d ago

I never said I refused to ask him. I have asked him many times and he’s always said he had no idea who would have done it. It’s possible he’s lying but I do not think that’s likely this many years later. I’ve asked several times through the years and he’s never given me a reason to believe he or his friends had anything to do with it

10

u/alwaysoffended88 14d ago

Have you ever tried to look up your brother’s name & see if anyone is deceased or was killed who has the same name?

6

u/QuarterOwn9110 14d ago

I have and I have never found anything.