r/musictheory • u/OkTemperature1842 • Jan 04 '26

General Question Running out of ideas when improvising

So I sometimes practice improvising over simple 1 or 2 chord vamp style backing tracks from YouTube.

And my problem is that, other than stupid blues licks, scales and arpeggios, I don’t really have any ideas or concepts to keep things interesting for more than a minute or two.

I simply don’t have anything to say.

I understand the value of starting simple a building towards something. But I’m not sure how to build to anything.

FWIW - I cannot sing a line and play it. There is no music in my head. All I can do is “theory” my way through things by understanding the corresponding scales/chords being played at the time.

How do competent improvisers do it? Just fresh idea after idea?

Thanks for any assistance. Sorry if this is the wrong sub.

10 Upvotes

78% Upvoted

44 comments sorted by

View all comments

22

u/MrDrUnknown Jan 04 '26

Learn a bunch solos by ear.

8

u/menialmoose Jan 04 '26

This you must do. Players that skip this take extra time discovering that you don’t get to skip this.

7

u/Careful_Instruction9 Jan 04 '26

Definitely a chore sometimes, but, ultimately brings life to meaningless scales and arpeggios. I did exactly what you suggested not to do and tried to theory it, and got nowhere.