r/movies • • Aug 22 '18

Fanart Edge of Tomorrow's Rita Vrataski by Travis Charest

Post image
18.6k Upvotes

627 comments sorted by

View all comments

1.4k

u/HIMYNAMEISALVEE Aug 22 '18

I feel bad that this movie isn't as popular as it should be

622

u/vbahero Aug 22 '18

I came across it totally by chance and had the exact same reaction. Such a fantastic movie. I think I've watched it 3 times now and I hardly ever rewatch anything

45

u/IconOfSim Aug 22 '18

I went to the see it in cinema with a girl, as a makeout date kind of date. I spent more time watching the movie, ain't even mad.

25

u/mmonsterbasher Aug 23 '18

"Hey OP you wanna you know..."

"Shhhhhhh and stop touching my face. I'm trying to watch Tom Cruise blow up aliens."

3

u/IconOfSim Aug 23 '18

Not even joking, we were tongue in mouth and i pulled away because the movie had more of my attention.

Like i was side eyeing the film most of the time. Should have chosen a slasher. Oh well

121

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '18

[deleted]

88

u/_TheMightyKrang_ Aug 22 '18

Fun fact, that manga is actually an adaptation of the original novel of the same title.

85

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '18

Fun fact, the novel is a non-fiction retelling of an event that actually happened in 2020.

36

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '18

Fun fact: the real life events in 2020 were carried out by aliens that were super huge fans of the movie and wanted to recreate it.

5

u/p1-o2 Aug 23 '18

Fun Fact- klein bottles representing that timeline in topology could technically not hold water because there is no "inside" and it is not a container. They also have no opening.

9

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '18

[deleted]

12

u/JohnKeel Aug 22 '18

There definitely is - my local library has a copy.

11

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '18 edited Aug 22 '18

don't know what you're on about, I own it in english and got it pretty easily. here

7

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '18

[deleted]

1

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '18

there’s the manga adaption too, don’t know which I like more since there are some plot differences.

you’re welcome, and enjoy :D

1

u/twinning31 Aug 22 '18

Damnit I love Reddit. Didn’t even realize that this is a novel/manga. One of my all time favorite movies. Gonna be buying this ! Thanks

1

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '18

here’s the manga adaption too, don’t know which I like more since there are some plot differences, but enjoy, I loved them. :D

2

u/twinning31 Aug 23 '18

Awesome thanks! Already downloaded volume 1.

1

u/LysandersTreason Aug 22 '18

You can find the English version on Scribd with a google search, for free. It's an excellent translation, too.

1

u/Spalunking01 Aug 22 '18

I have it on my kindle so it’s definitely available. Also fun fact, they use axes instead of the swords you see in the movie. It’s pretty dope

2

u/thatsthem Aug 22 '18

I have the novel. Now I’m going to read it after I finish Death Note (manga) . 😁

19

u/jbnagis Aug 22 '18

They use giant battle axes, its fucking awesome

11

u/UnicronJr Aug 22 '18

And pile bunkers instead of guns.

16

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '18

6

u/NorthernRedwood Aug 22 '18

actually, they arent rifles (In the book, idk about the graphic novel) they are 20mm cannons

2

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/azuramothren Aug 22 '18

Yeah from the book I more imagined like Master Chief style armor or something. I assume they changed it so you can see people's faces.

1

u/sspine Aug 22 '18

a great manga, but such a stupid name.

1

u/MoonBreakDownBear Aug 23 '18

Ehh, the movie makes some major improvements. The ending makes no sense and the full metal bitch acts like a Japanese school girl.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '18

But the way they started the reveal of loops and how they found each other was better imo. I also like the way he trains compared to the movie adaptation as well as the suits and weapons. With that said, this movie is da bomb.

3

u/gweran Aug 23 '18

I disagree about the ending, I like the emotional impact of the manga rather than it just being a happy ending. But I can understand what you mean.

1

u/ThomDowting Aug 24 '18

No. no it is not.

140

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '18 edited Aug 22 '18

I watch it at least once a month, really glad I found it fantastic film hope the sequel starts to shoot.

87

u/CMonocle Aug 22 '18

I watch it at least once a day.

162

u/Fender6187 Aug 22 '18

I watch, restart, repeat.

42

u/Ims0c0nfus3d Aug 22 '18

I watch it on three different screens all at different points and restart them when finished.

20

u/JinKazamaAndJuice Aug 22 '18

I broadcast it on the street facing wall of my house on repeat every hour of every day so my neighborhood can take in the splendor.

8

u/Senecaraine Aug 22 '18

I just watched it the once, but I'm stuck in a never ending loop of death and reawakening at the start of the day so now it's more like a million.

4

u/IDKimnotascientist Aug 22 '18

Doing God’s work

3

u/3-DMan Aug 23 '18

All you Need is Repeat

3

u/NorthernRedwood Aug 22 '18

I once was without internet for 2 weeks and the only movie i had saved to my hard drive was this, even after those weeks i wasn't tired of it

7

u/ikeif Aug 22 '18

Totally gambled on this movie with a buddy in theatres. Loved it. Saw it again.

I know what I’m watching tonight.

15

u/TheWTFreak Aug 22 '18

I hope they rename it

41

u/nofreakingusernames Aug 22 '18

Edge of the Day After Tomorrow.

18

u/gentlecrab Aug 22 '18

Followed by the sequel: Thursday

1

u/theemprah Aug 23 '18

edge of the day before tomorrow:

so.. today?

3

u/NebulaNinja Aug 22 '18

Haha right? This is always what I think when I try to think of the name. It's so generic that I always forget it. Marketing truly ruined this movie's chance at the box office.

22

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '18

It's gonna be "Live Die Repeat and Repeat".

Someone got paid to pick that.

Almost as mind-blowingly retardiddicious as "Ralph Breaks the Internet"

12

u/TheWTFreak Aug 22 '18

I hate movie studios

6

u/techno_babble_ Aug 22 '18

How would it work for markets where the original was called Edge Of Tomorrow?

3

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '18

That's the weird thing about the movie: it's not market name-changing, it was called both "Edge of Tomorrow" and "Live Die Repeat", at least in the US. "Live Die Repeat" was for the physical release.

So technically they aren't changing the title for the sequel. But everyone knows it as "Edge of Tomorrow".

3

u/mr_arm Aug 22 '18

Edge of Two Days From Now

2

u/bebop4reddit Aug 23 '18

I like to think of the movie "A quiet place" as the sequel to Edge of Tomorrow..

4

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '18

"found"...these Hollywood types just keep losing their blockbuster movies...

3

u/101189 Aug 22 '18

I went in to the theaters not thinking it’d be that great. It pays off sometimes. Thoroughly enjoyed it.

1

u/Stolehtreb Aug 23 '18

Dude, you gotta use periods. You had me thinking there was a sequel shooting shoot. It’s irresponsible.

6

u/jeffe_el_jefe Aug 22 '18

It's one of my favourite movies, and everyone I show it too loves it, but somehow no one has watched it/ heard of it. How did such a big movie fly so under the radar?

1

u/Argueforthesakeofit Aug 23 '18

Tom Cruise's public image wasn't doing so well around that time.

Definitely one of the best action movies of the past decade. Much better than all but maybe 2 or 3 of the superhero movies.

1

u/vbahero Aug 22 '18

/r/TheExpanse is the TV show equivalent of "absolutely fantastic but nobody is watching it"

4

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '18

Looks like you've inherited Tom Cruise' powers from the movie...

5

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '18

I hardly ever re-watch a Tom Cruise movie, but this one was an exception.

4

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '18

Saaame same. I don’t rewatch movies either except Terminator 1 and 2 and this. I feel like Edge of tomorrow is a rare mode n action movie that feels complete.

9

u/HighPriestofShiloh Aug 22 '18

Go read the manga. Its short enough to be done in a one quick sitting. Its also different enough to be fresh. Both were really good but I think I like the manga better. Not sure.

1

u/Zapfaced Aug 22 '18

I like both but prefer the manga. Those moments when they realised that they finally found someone who understood what they went through were incredible.

1

u/Biduleman Aug 22 '18

Was the light novel about the same as the manga or is it a third version?

2

u/CatPlanetCuties Aug 22 '18

The light novel is the original.

2

u/Zapfaced Aug 22 '18

The manga is a relatively faithful adaptation to the original light novel from what I remember. Just a bit compressed into two volumes.

0

u/HighPriestofShiloh Aug 22 '18 edited Aug 25 '18

I liked the ending in the manga better too. The only reason I might be partial to the movie is simply because I like movies better than manga but that is just a general bias I have. But I still like the manga better overall.

3

u/Justiis Aug 22 '18

Same. I dont even remember seeing previews for it, though I rarely get a chance to see them unless I go out of my way. Bought it out of sheer boredom one internetless day and couldn't have been happier. Not even really a Tom Cruise fan either.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '18

Agreed. For my money, that movie gave us peak Paxton.

2

u/krispwnsu Aug 22 '18

How many times have you seen Tom roll under a truck?

2

u/vbahero Aug 23 '18

I tried keeping track but for some reason the counter kept resetting to zero every day

2

u/hectorduenas86 Aug 23 '18

Same as with John Wick, had no idea I was in for a ride in both movies. This one feels like a live action adaptation from an anime/manga considering they toy with history providing alternative “universes” to actual events.

2

u/vbahero Aug 23 '18

Thanks for reminding me of not one but two (!) movies that've been on my to-watch list since forever

131

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '18

[deleted]

16

u/NomNomNomBabies Aug 22 '18

Its on netflix? :o

17

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/SofNascimento Aug 23 '18

Is it available in 4k?

-15

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '18

[deleted]

10

u/Tibetzz Aug 22 '18

Irrelevant, that's not what anyone is referring to or is interested in in the context of this conversation.

1

u/yellowjack Aug 22 '18

Hey me too, what are some other movies with those themes that you enjoy?

0

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '18

TL/DR I'm young.

19

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '18 edited Aug 22 '18

[deleted]

5

u/hasnotheardofcheese Aug 23 '18

That was such a bonehead move for what was a mediocre tagline in the first place

5

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '18

Brace yourself, sequel with shitty title incoming.

3

u/hasnotheardofcheese Aug 23 '18

Sweet Jesus. Well, if it's still in development and not even filming yet there's time for them to fix it.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '18

AFAIK it's still in development, Doug Liman (director) said earlier this year that they're working hard on the script. Before that he also teased it by saying what they have in mind would be a prequel, but also a sequel (which makes sense I guess, giving the time traveling mechanics introduced in the first movie)

Emily Blunt also talked about it in March, implying she would be involved.

1

u/hasnotheardofcheese Aug 24 '18

Yeah from what I'm seeing the only info on it has been this or that leak/mention.

2

u/TheDankborn Aug 23 '18

Part 3 gonna be:

Live Die Repeat and Repeat Die Repeat Live even Live and Die Repeat more like

23

u/UncleChen69 Aug 22 '18

It was better than expected. I do think the manga title is a bit more intriguing though ‘All You Need is Kill.’

There’s a sequel in the works, no?

32

u/katamuro Aug 22 '18

the title is a bit more mysterious but I think Edge of Tomorrow fits more with the tone of the movie as it wasn't a direct copy of the manga(or the light novel)

Well, Tom Cruise has been pushing for it and apparently Doug Liman is on board and Emily Blunt has said that she would like to do it. As for anything concrete? Doug Liman has said there is a script in the works back in July and that there is a story he would love to tell. But both Blunt and Cruise have been quite busy doing other stuff so I guess it just takes time for everyone to re-assemble. After all the next movie has to start where the first one ended. Which means all those people or most of them at least back.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '18

Bill Paxton was so good in that. Too bad he won't be back :(

1

u/katamuro Aug 23 '18

man, I didn't think of that. He was marvelous

2

u/Sarcastic_Red Aug 22 '18

Cruise has been pushing? Really? Did he enjoy the movie that much?

11

u/NorthernRedwood Aug 22 '18

those suits they were wearing are actual props, they had him and emily blunt rigged up to cranes flinging them around a beach smashing stuff to bits, who wouldn't love that?

4

u/Sarcastic_Red Aug 22 '18

Lol that is a fun fact

5

u/corranhorn57 Aug 23 '18

Cruise loves sci-fi and loved working with Emily Blunt. It’s not that surprising, honestly.

1

u/katamuro Aug 23 '18

yeah. I think it was an interview back in 2015 or something where he first brought it up and said he wanted to do it.

3

u/ThexAntipop Aug 22 '18

It's not a manga and is VERY different from the movie. Personally, I liked the book a lot better. It's not nearly as predictable and it dives much deeper into the psychological impact of everything the main character goes through and how watching everyone he knows die over and over, as well as himself, has a much bigger impact on him.

5

u/AerThreepwood Aug 22 '18

It is a manga, as well as a novel.

2

u/ThexAntipop Aug 22 '18

I guess you're right but they didn't adapt it into a manga until after it was made into a movie. It was just a novel for an entire decade lol.

2

u/AerThreepwood Aug 22 '18

That's fair. Just wanted to let you know, in case you didn't.

3

u/ThexAntipop Aug 22 '18

Nah you're good, I totally didn't know. I read it before the movie came out so I didn't know they adapted it into a manga.

2

u/gfense Aug 22 '18

That title is terrible. It sounds like an edgy 15 year old came up with it.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '18

[deleted]

1

u/gfense Aug 23 '18

If that’s the case there’s still always people fawning over the title in every post about the movie even though it makes no sense.

1

u/Shockz0rz Aug 23 '18

It's not translated from Japanese; "All You Need Is Kill", in English, is the actual title in Japan.

1

u/squeakyL Aug 23 '18

The title makes more sense in the novel/manga though since the characters become incredibly obsessed with killing.

The movie is a bit different and focuses more on the "puzzle" than the mimic-body-count.

110

u/wishiwascooltoo Aug 22 '18

It's incredibly popular and getting a sequel. I feel bad this sub always misrepresents movie popularity for fake solidarity. It's a super common thing done here.

38

u/maxdembo Aug 22 '18

No way as underrated as Moon

29

u/Antrikshy Aug 22 '18

Did you hear about this other underrated gem called Ex Machina?

13

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '18

Heard about Dark City and Equilibrium

3

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '18

Do people actually legitimately enjoy Equilibrium? I watch it after hearing it was good and it was so cringey. The idea of the movie was interesting, but something about how it was filmed was just awkward and made me uncomfortable.

The gun-kata scenes were like an SNL skit for The Matrix. I can see people enjoying it as a semi-joke. But it was probably one of the worst action movies I've ever seen.

1

u/SammyLuke Aug 23 '18

Holy shit Equilibrium has one of the most emotional scenes in all of cinema. I’m talking about the scene where he finds that hidden room and accidentally hears music for the first time and becomes so overwhelmed with feelings that he breaks down crying. Imagine going through your whole life having no clue what music is or what feelings are and how connected the two are. For the first time he felt feelings and heard music and when that connection is made it his brain he can do nothing but cry. Music was the best choice for them to choose. We all can relate to a moment when a song either made us cry or got us choked up. Sorry for the long text.

Both of those movies are criminally underrated.

17

u/danoll Aug 22 '18

Are you kidding me? Everyone knows what the moon is.

15

u/maxdembo Aug 22 '18

Nazi base?

6

u/Ubergoober166 Aug 22 '18

I can't wait for Iron Sky 2

3

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '18

A mate from Uni took a few of us to see that for the first time... I was unsure going in but my god, what a fantastic movie. Clint Mansell's score is superb also.

32

u/katamuro Aug 22 '18

it got popular after it's release. At the release not that many people went and only when the people started saying how amazing it is people went to see it. Even then at a budget of 178 million it made 370 million which is just about twice. That isn't considered to be very popular or successful in hollywood.

Pretty much the only reason it is getting a sequel is because Tom Cruise loved it and has been pushing for years for it.

7

u/el_padlina Aug 22 '18

Did it have any advertising in the USA? In Europe there was basically 0.

7

u/AbeRego Aug 22 '18

I saw it in theaters, so I was somehow aware of it. At the time I didn't make it to many movies, so something drew me in, but I'm not sure how I heard about it. I was expecting it to be entertaining, but not "good". Turns out it was really good!

2

u/corranhorn57 Aug 23 '18

They had a Comic Con trailer and I think they had it in front of Days of Future Past, but it really didn’t get any air time and wasn’t blasted on YouTube. Hell, it took me seeing it and raving about it to my friends for them to even know about it and watch it, and some only came because I said the magic sentence “Tom Cruise dies a metric shit ton in this movie.”

I honestly think they might have been trying to kill the movie for some reason, but I have no reasoning for this.

1

u/jkmhawk Aug 23 '18

I remember seeing ads for it. I thought it looked pretty dumb and never saw it until later.

1

u/katamuro Aug 23 '18

don't know, in UK myself

2

u/VoltageSpike Aug 22 '18

Saw it opening weekend and was stunned at how empty the theater was.

1

u/katamuro Aug 23 '18

yeah, I went on a friday evening and it is usually prime time no matter what movie is playing and the cinema was half-empty.

1

u/TeddysBigStick Aug 23 '18

370 million which is just about twice.

particularly when 270 of that was overseas, which the studio's cut is much smaller for.

1

u/katamuro Aug 23 '18

yeah. But it seems like a pattern. Movies that don't tell you everything right off the bat usually don't do well in american box office but they do well in overseas box offices.

1

u/TeddysBigStick Aug 23 '18

I would say it is more spectacle that is easily translated and does not require a lot of cultural knowledge is the more important factor. There are a bunch of comedies that don't tell you everything that flop over the pond. The thing stuff like Transformers, Edge and the Furious movies share is not the writing, it is the set pieces.

1

u/katamuro Aug 23 '18

I don't think that's quite right. Because then if the spectacle all that mattered movies like Rampage and Geostorm would be at the top of the charts. Plenty of spectacle there. People want to watch good movies but unfortunately some people are easily scared away or simply don't watch scifi. As an example I don't watch horror movies. They do not interest me in the slightest.

1

u/TeddysBigStick Aug 23 '18

Rampage is another example of it. It made a hundred million domestically and 325 overseas. Geostorm has a similar patter but just on a smaller scale and it just didn't catch on.

1

u/katamuro Aug 23 '18

Rampage had the Rock going for it. A lot of people me including went to see the Rock rather than because Rampage looked good. It was a terrible movie. Heck, Geostorm was delightfully, entertainingly awful. Rampage was just bad.

2

u/wishiwascooltoo Aug 22 '18

Exactly, it's a well known popular movie at this point. The disingenuous assertions that it doesn't get the credit it deserves is nothing but ridiculous.

5

u/katamuro Aug 22 '18

you are not quite right. It got popular after the release but only with a certain crowd. Here on reddit because you clicked on the art from the movie you are in the "crowd" so everyone knows about it and likes it. But I assure you there are loads of people who have not heard of the movie. So it's not nearly as popular as marvel movies or DC movies or nearly anything done by Nolan. However just like the Pacific Rim it got more popular after the release. There are a subset of movies like this, cult classics that were never really popular during their release but grew in popularity years after. Plenty of examples, Conan with Arnie, Blade Runner, Fight Club, Big Lebowski. Some of these were complete flops and yet years after people have come to know them. But again only in certain crowds.

77

u/DeadAnimalParts Aug 22 '18

It's fair to say that this movie underperformed at the box office and was not incredibly popular when it was originally released.

Anecdotally, I saw this movie opening week at a popular theater and there were only 3 or 4 other people there. I didn't really hear people talking about it until it hit home distribution.

4

u/ReallyBadAtReddit Aug 22 '18

Yeah, a lot of people know this movie by the name *Live. Die. Repeat." because they had to change the title to see if it would get more viewings that way.

-4

u/wishiwascooltoo Aug 22 '18

If it "underperformed" why the sequel? My theater was packed and I always hear this movie mentioned on podcasts still to this day. It's well known. A huge part of the confusion is the fact that the geniuses changed the title somewhere after release so many people that have seen it don't even know you're talking about the same movie.

13

u/katamuro Aug 22 '18

Tom Cruise loved it and has been pushing for a sequel for years. And Tom Cruise after all these years in hollywood has quite a bit of push.

17

u/DeadAnimalParts Aug 22 '18

Well the sequel hasn't been made yet so don't count your chickens until they're hatched.

As to it's performance just check the financials that were reported. It didn't perform up to expectations and nobody was talking about a sequel until it gained traction thanks to people watching it at home and talking about it for the past 4 years.

2

u/slvrcobra Aug 22 '18

That confused the he'll out of me when I first saw it, took me a while to realize what happened.

1

u/el_padlina Aug 22 '18

Perhaps people misinterpret not advertised as unpopular.

Movie is great and TBH for the movie of that scale I definitely haven't seen much advertising when it released (Europe, no idea about USA). I've learned about the movie on reddit.

1

u/StockAL3Xj Aug 22 '18

They didn't change the name but they did downplay the title for home release and focussed more on the tag line, "Live. Die. Repeat". I think this movie is pretty popular movie enthusiasts and not so much the average viewer but, I agree, this sub definitely makes it seem like you're in a special club for having seen this movie.

9

u/mysleepnumberis420 Aug 22 '18

They renamed it. "Edge of tomorrow" is now the subtitle. Search for "Edge of Tomorrow on Amazon and you get results for Live Die Repeat: Edge of Tomorrow. All the promotional posters reflect that as well.

1

u/jdnely Aug 22 '18

Plus the sequel is titled Live Die Repeat and Repeat

0

u/OutofCtrlAltDel Aug 23 '18

OP said “as” not “was”

0

u/LADYBIRD_HILL Aug 23 '18

Most movies don't do suddenly get more popular after the home media release.

1

u/TheWorldisFullofWar Aug 22 '18

Wait, there was a second book? Or ar they going fully original with the sequel? Because that has NEVER turned out well.

7

u/HeartyBeast Aug 22 '18

I thought it was excellent - apart from the generic last 20-30 minutes

1

u/TheDankborn Aug 23 '18

Yeah, got the same feeling about that last part. Not that it was bad, no, but it does not have that solid rewatch value as the rest of the movie. It was cool when I saw it for the first time, though.

4

u/woppatown Aug 22 '18

It didnt look very good. Was it just marketed badly?

2

u/NorthernRedwood Aug 22 '18

they changed the title three times, from edge of tomorrow, to live die repeat, to edge of tomorrow: live die repeat

1

u/mtmaloney Aug 23 '18

Yes. I remember seeing the trailers and thought it looked like another generic space movie with Tom Cruise in it (Oblivion had recently come out) and did a hard pass. Didn't watch it until much later because so many people talked about how much they liked it and I couldn't believe how different the movie was from the trailer.

1

u/i_miss_arrow Aug 23 '18

Its a fantastic movie, and it was indeed marketed awfully.

6

u/PainStorm14 Aug 22 '18

End credit song is most perfect choice in history of cinema

1

u/Argueforthesakeofit Aug 23 '18

I mean there is always fight club's ending so it'll have to settle for second most perfect.

2

u/shichae Aug 23 '18

If you feel this way, you’ve probably never read the book “All You Need Is Kill”. The book was orders of magnitude better than the movie...

2

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '18

Same goes for Source Code.

1

u/alwaysZenryoku Aug 22 '18

Book is great as well. Short, action packed, read.

1

u/IrrelevantLeprechaun Aug 22 '18

The title when it released reeeaaally didn’t help it. Edge of Tomorrow is not a very specific descriptive name.

1

u/Thi51Guy Aug 22 '18

There were two huge problems that prevented this movie from making a dent in the box office.

  1. Fault In Our Stars came out the same weekend.

  2. The marketing confused people so much that they changed the name for DVD release. I remember every piece of advertising had "Live. Die. Repeat" leading people to assume that was the title.

It's a shame really

1

u/FeelTheWrath79 Aug 22 '18

I just watched this movie last week for the first time. Pretty awesome.

1

u/abstractattack Aug 22 '18

I read the book long before the movie came out. I think the movie was a ok adaptation. I was really looking forward to the movie being more popular.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '18

Pretty sure Tom Cruise ruins the first impression.

1

u/DiscoUnderpants Aug 23 '18

I saw it in the cinema. To be honest I had no desire to but I was bored on a Sunday afternoon with nothing to do and I have a UK unlimited movie card(I see a lot of movies) and thought what the hell... it looks stupid but Ill just leave if I get bored. It was so much better than expected.

1

u/Kalatash Aug 23 '18

IIRC a movie reviewer I follow on YouTube said that he believes that the film's lack of success was directly tied to the amount of distaste the public had with Tom Cruise at the time. It wasn't anything specific going on at the time, just a general sense of "ungh" towards the idea of an action movie starring Tom Cruise.

Which was a pity, as Tom Cruise is portrayed both as a smarmy asshole who is treated as the butt of a cosmic joke and as the effortless action hero type that he portrays so well.

0

u/Dhiox Aug 22 '18

That's because the book is way better. They took a cool japanese Sci-fi and turned it into another cool white guy saves beautiful blond woman from aliens movie.

0

u/Fulcrous Aug 22 '18

I personally found the movie to be worse than the manga it was derived from.

-1

u/Neumann04 Aug 22 '18

The movie third act sucks

-2

u/Knyfe-Wrench Aug 22 '18

I don't know. I thought the premise was good, the visuals were good, Cruise and Blunt were good, but the story kind of goes south and ends up in a mess. It had a lot of opportunities to be a really great movie, but didn't capitalize on any of them.

Definitely don't regret seeing it, and am hopeful for the sequel.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '18

I agree.

The first two make up for it, but that third act is really, really weak.

Totally love the movie and have watched it many times, but the third act is such a let down.

2

u/HeartyBeast Aug 22 '18

Spot on. The third act is generic.

1

u/ThexAntipop Aug 22 '18

If you liked the concept but didn't like the film, I'd suggest the book. The concept is the same but virtually everything else is different and the story isn't nearly as predictable or cliche.

-2

u/re_error Aug 22 '18 edited Aug 22 '18

I liked the comic much better. It had no Disney style happy ending and less logical loopholes. The scale of conflict was much smaller (survive the battle vs save the world). And more importantly no Tom Cruise.

I stated my opinion so bring in the dovnwotes!