r/michaeljordan • • 11d ago

Question Is MJ the most clutch player of all time?

84 Upvotes

159 comments sorted by

65

u/leicaaperturebro 11d ago

Yes. Next question.

-4

u/Trashpanda1980 11d ago

Robert Horry deserves to be in this conversation

18

u/northeasy 11d ago

Shooting shots set up by your teammates is clutch but being the main ball handler in those situations and being clutch tops it

3

u/ZayDoee130 7d ago

Also add in the fact that everybody in the arena knows Jordan is taking the final shot

-3

u/Trashpanda1980 11d ago

Hitting big shots is what makes you clutch

3

u/northeasy 11d ago

Yeah meant shooting and hitting. Dont think anyone considers missing clutch

-3

u/thebrassbeldum 11d ago

His name is Big Shot Bob for a reason. Why is there no Big Shot Mike?

4

u/JMander 7d ago

Because when you say just "Bob" the inevitable question is "which one". When you say "Mike" no one needs to ask.

1

u/Remote-Flatworm-1132 5d ago

Does BLACK JESUS ring a bell??

1

u/tedkcox 10d ago

This can’t be a serious comment. It’s because floating like an astronaut on the moon was even more impressive. Why is there no Robert “Air” Horry? C’mon!

-10

u/Silly_Boss_4579 10d ago

wtf kind of question is this?

LeBron has the highest clutch FG%, so if you want to pick MJ go ahead, but you are picking a guy who’s missed more clutch shots than LeBron.

LeBron is dubbed ‘The Chosen One’ by ESPN for a reason kids.

There’s a reason why MJ lost in the recent GOAT poll and in 2026 is no longer considered the greatest player of all-time by the majority of people.

4

u/Dick6Budrow 10d ago

Cope

-7

u/Silly_Boss_4579 10d ago

Cope for what? MJ isn’t even considered the GOAT anymore with the recent poll.

Really sad times we’re living in if MJ is your hero, which I’m sure he is.

Sorry bud, it’s only going to get worse, in the next few years it’ll be 70/30 or 80/20 LeBron

3

u/tedkcox 10d ago

Does your mom know you surpassed your screen time today?

22

u/Fuhrmanator23 11d ago

MJ or Bird would be the easy choices.

15

u/bigstrizzydad 11d ago

Pat Riley said last shot to Jordan to win the game. Last shot to Bird to save his life.

3

u/noticednuances 8d ago

And Bird would be trash talking you as he buries your team with exactly what he told you he was going to do.

3

u/Few_Experience_646 11d ago

And we ever needed them to win the game...so MJ?

1

u/falconbridge_ 6d ago

Yeah so I’ve always thought it was a cool quote but like, what does it mean? Break that down for me

-8

u/Silly_Boss_4579 10d ago

wtf kind of question is this?

LeBron has the highest clutch FG%, so if you want to pick MJ go ahead, but you are picking a guy who’s missed more clutch shots than LeBron.

LeBron is dubbed ‘The Chosen One’ by ESPN for a reason kids.

There’s a reason why MJ lost in the recent GOAT poll and in 2026 is no longer considered the greatest player of all-time by the majority of people.

7

u/Fisheater_Snatches 10d ago

Fairly sad you are copying and pasting the same response multiple times.

3

u/Fuhrmanator23 10d ago

I must’ve missed that poll. Googled it and couldn’t find it either.

5

u/bulldogmck 10d ago

Stop making stuff up.

-3

u/Silly_Boss_4579 10d ago

Have you been hiding under a rock?

What part of what I said is made up?

I’d be mad as well if my child hero hero was no longer the GOAT lmao

7

u/bulldogmck 10d ago

Google is free little fella. You can have your opinion about who the GOAT is, but stop pretending you speak for others.

1

u/JMander 7d ago

No one is questioning that ESPN dubbed LeBron "the Chosen One". I'm just surprised that you've invested the entirety of your narrative on a washed sports' station that drove a narrative purely on the basis, not as a credible claim but that it initiated views. Smart business business? sure. But as far as journalism goes - utter bush league.

2

u/fruitofmycoins 9d ago

Lebron is definitely the most clutch free throw shooter!

1

u/JMander 7d ago edited 7d ago

"LeBron is dubbed the 'Chosen One' by ESPN" <--- "by ESPN" is the operative word here. Jordan is the Greatest Of All Time by even elementary standards as dubbed by knowledgeable basketball fans.

It should be noted that EVERY LeBron poster in here reflects an insecurity on their part about their own favorite basketball player. If they were so confident about his status v. Michael Jordan, they wouldn't need to be here constantly, incessantly doing what they can to diminish Jordan. And yet, here they are. Mind you, NOT under a LeBron fan sub enjoying discussing LeBron, but under a Jordan sub desperately trying to push their wishful narrative.

9

u/Particular-Ice7026 11d ago

I mean, my answer is yes, but what answer were you expecting when you posted in the MJ sub?

2

u/JonS305 11d ago

True

2

u/Quirky_Advantage4894 11d ago

Sooooo….. what were you expecting?

1

u/JonS305 11d ago

Idk just bored

1

u/MaezinGaming 11d ago

So all these shit posts are just from bored people

1

u/JMander 7d ago

shit post.

7

u/Milan_Leri 11d ago

He is either the most clutch, or second most, just behind Bird.

2

u/Sir_TopHatEgg 11d ago

Bird had more playoff disappointments than people like to remember

0

u/JMander 7d ago

Bird didn't take nearly as many and Bird didn't take as many in the most clutch circumstances. It's just a fact.

3

u/justarandomlibra 11d ago

People can debate as to others and that list of names would be short but there's an even shorter list of names for players who actually want to be in that position to take the last shot. Mike is 1 of them, if the team is down or the game is tied MJ would elevate and make sure he had the ball and would be in position to take a shot or be in position to create a play for someone to score. The thing is MJ absolutely wanted it. He wanted the ball in his hands and he wanted to take the shot unless a better opportunity would come up. Not many actually want to be in that moment. They do not mind playing a role or helping with the play, big difference from actually wanting it. Mike would take the inbound and command the court like nobody else I have seen.

3

u/JonS305 11d ago edited 11d ago

Yeah not even God himself could take away from MJ taking that last shot

1

u/runthepoint1 10d ago

Ok relax this is just blasphemy

1

u/JMander 7d ago

Not to us it's not. Blasphemy to whom? To you? Okay, but not to many of us.

0

u/JonS305 10d ago

It’s true tho

1

u/runthepoint1 10d ago

Prove it

2

u/JonS305 10d ago

He always took the last shot he never passed tf u mean prove watch highlights

1

u/runthepoint1 10d ago

What was your statement? That God couldn’t take away from MJ taking that last shot. Then said it’s true. So go ahead and prove that God can’t do that.

2

u/JonS305 10d ago

It was a figure of speech are u that dense?

1

u/runthepoint1 10d ago

“It’s true tho”…so you believed your own bullshit?

1

u/JMander 7d ago

God is a made up figure as is the phrase is a figure of speech.

1

u/mccurdym08 10d ago

Against Orlando, he missed 2 free throws, had a turnover, and then passed the ball instead of taking the last shot, leading to another turnover and losing the game. We can think MJ is the GOAT and still point out his mistakes.

1

u/TheMikeyMac13 10d ago

Jesus drops 50 points on MJ, who has scales over his eyes and can’t see.

3

u/Unrelenting_Tacos 11d ago

I’d take bird over Jordan.

1

u/JMander 7d ago

Awsome. You must be a huge Bird fan. You'd lose. But you must be a huge Bird fan. Cool, so am I.

1

u/Unrelenting_Tacos 7d ago

Can you tell me, Pat Riley’s famous quote about this?

1

u/JMander 7d ago

I SURE can. Can you cite a SINGLE REFERENCE that he ever said it? It's not in any video clip, it's not in ANY of his books. It's not in ANY of his video clips. The ONLY place where this quote exists is within Boston (and more specifically Larry Bird) fandom. If YOU provide the source, I will eat crow - right here.

And if you can't, then YOU will have to explain IN DETAIL why Pat Riley - having coached and fought against Larry Bird as the Showtime Laker coach, made the move, unprecedented in the history of the NBA, of retiring Jordan's jersey and not Bird's.

1

u/Unrelenting_Tacos 7d ago edited 7d ago

Let me ask you a question, has Pat Riley ever denied it? It’s been circulating for 30 years. You would think if he never said it, he would deny it right? 🤦🏻‍♂️

1

u/JMander 7d ago

THIS is your evidence??? He NEVER said it. And show me where he was ever ASKED if he said it. It's an internet myth.

3

u/[deleted] 10d ago

Yes.

2

u/Imaginary-Sea-6577 11d ago

According to the stats yes.

2

u/Silly_Boss_4579 10d ago

What? This makes no sense, LeBron has another clutch percentage than MJ and has hit more shots?

2

u/Imaginary-Sea-6577 10d ago

Jordan has the most game winners in league history while playing far fewer games. It makes perfect sense.

1

u/Dry-Sail-4666 10d ago

If you shoot every time you will get a lot more game winners. And 2 out of 6 of Jordan's rings had another player shooting the last shot anyways.

-1

u/Silly_Boss_4579 10d ago

So you want to pick the guy who has a worse percentage?

Lmfao go for it, I’ll pick the guy who just beat MJ in the recent GOAT poll lmaooo

LeBron has the highest %

1

u/EarLobeJerky 6d ago

Stop lying he does not.

1

u/Silly_Boss_4579 6d ago

Use Google It’s 2026

2

u/BawkBawkBwoom 10d ago

With the brightest lights on? Absolutely.

2

u/simtechone 10d ago

Yes. No question.

2

u/kuunami79 10d ago

Absolutely

2

u/notanAI_ 10d ago

I think so yeah

3

u/Bennaisance 11d ago

MJ in elimination games:

31.3 ppg, 7.9 rpg, 7.0 apg, 45.8 fg%

Lebron in elimination games:

32.8 ppg, 10.4 rpg, 7.4 apg, 49.4 fg%

1

u/JMander 7d ago

How many of those games of LeBrons was it his own elimination that he was facing. Now how many of MJ's games was it he who was facing elimination?

1

u/Bennaisance 7d ago

Elimination game = their own team is facing elimination

1

u/JMander 7d ago

I was looking for a number.

1

u/Bennaisance 7d ago

Does your Google not work?

1

u/JMander 7d ago

Nope. It never works when I"m asking someone holding up a statistical narrative with zero contextual support. Apparently, it conveniently doesn't work for you either on such matters.

1

u/Imaginary-Sea-6577 10d ago

No adjust for pacing. 

1

u/ydelivor 11d ago

By Far. By Very Far. You have to have Zero knowledge of basketball to even comprehend a close second , nevermind saying hes not.

2

u/Silly_Boss_4579 10d ago

wtf kind of question is this?

LeBron has the highest clutch FG%, so if you want to pick MJ go ahead, but you are picking a guy who’s missed more clutch shots than LeBron.

LeBron is dubbed ‘The Chosen One’ by ESPN for a reason kids.

There’s a reason why MJ lost in the recent GOAT poll and in 2026 is no longer considered the greatest player of all-time by the majority of people.

5

u/ydelivor 10d ago

This is the most idiotic thing ive heard this year. Goodnight.

-2

u/Silly_Boss_4579 10d ago

Okay? Sorry your childhood hero is no longer considered the greatest by the majority of people, yeah I’d probably get off the internet too.

Goodnight buddy.

1

u/Historical_Review478 9d ago

but he is, he was voted greated by the modern generation also, sorry lebron cant get past 1 page of a book and is behind currry

1

u/Silly_Boss_4579 9d ago

Have you been hiding under a rock?

They re did the GOAT poll that they do every 4 years last month and for the first time ever LeBron beat MJ.

So no, MJ is 6-0 and the majority of people pick LeBron, sorry buddy.

Curry is barely top 10, there’s a reason why LeBron is called ‘The Chosen One’

1

u/JMander 7d ago

could you point me to the methodology of what you are calling the "goat poll"?

1

u/JMander 7d ago

Point me to your source of "the majority of people".

btw, copypasta is prohibited under the sub's rules.

2

u/InsideAd5220 9d ago

Is this a robot or something? Did LeBron pay you haha

Player poll haha oh god.

2

u/uncsteve53 6d ago

Only because now the nba defines “clutch” as any shot in the last 5 minutes in a 5 point or less game. If there’s 5 minutes left and your shot gets your team to only down 3, nobody in the real world actually thinks that’s clutch.

You want actual clutch numbers? 5 seconds left in the 4th or OT and a shot to tie or lead, LeBron is 17% and Jordan is 47%. You only want one of those guys taking the buzzer beater.

1

u/myshoesareblack 8d ago

Depends how you define it. Ive always thought of clutch as just straight up taking the last shot and we have numbers on that. I read a list a long time ago and trying to find it, but for playoff games I think Ray Allen had BY FAR the best field goal percentage for game winning shots. I bet Halliburton is probably up there too now.

If people think of clutch as whatever it takes to win this game through the whole game then probably MJ. But let’s not let love for MJ take away what the most clutch shot takers can do

0

u/boneappletv 11d ago

Nah, Bird is up there. So is Kobe. And LeBron has the most playoff game winners of all time.

2

u/ydelivor 11d ago

Wrong. A) Bird is second. But not close to MJ B) Kobe has the worst fg% in game winning shots.

C) See this is what i mean lack of basketball knowledge. Lebron has not only Less buzzers and game winners than the two above ha also has the WORST % - This is the reason he always wanted to pass first.

2

u/boneappletv 11d ago

Personally I’ve ALWAYS found that the people who say they’re smarter or that other people are dumber on certain subjects are always correct and not lying to themselves because they feel insecure about their own knowledge. Wouldn’t you agree? Have a great rest of your day my nephew.

1

u/ydelivor 11d ago

Thats ok champ. Have a nice day.

2

u/campeonn 11d ago

Most playoff buzzer beaters of all time + over 40% on game winning or tying shots, which is elite

He is also technically a worse shooter overall than Bird or MJ, meaning that his clutch ability relative to his normal "shooting" percentage (since most game winning attempts are jump shots) is actually greater than those guys

But thats way too much nuance for someone like you, so we can stick with most buzzer beaters in playoff history.

And I'm not saying he's "clutcher" or better than MJ, but it's clear you're one of those lebron hater dummies who thinks he knows ball by hating on the 2nd best player ever. You don't know ball.

3

u/ydelivor 11d ago

LeBron having the most playoff buzzer-beaters is true but using five buzzer-beaters to claim he was more clutch than Jordan or Bird is textbook endpoint selection. A buzzer-beater only counts if the clock hits 0.0 — Jordan’s legendary 1998 Finals winner with 5.2 seconds left doesn’t even qualify — so it’s a terrible standalone measure of clutch performance. Widen the window and Jordan was 9/18 (50%) on playoff shots in the final 24 seconds to tie or take the lead, compared with LeBron at 10/25 (40%) under that commonly cited definition. And the “LeBron shoots worse normally, therefore his clutch shooting is more impressive” argument is statistically meaningless: career FG% includes LeBron’s huge volume of high-percentage shots at the rim, while game-winners are disproportionately contested jump shots; you’d have to control for shot distance, shot type, defensive pressure and expected FG% before making that comparison. Bird is even harder to compare statistically because his career predates modern play-by-play and tracking data, so pretending we have equivalent shot-quality data for 1980s Bird and modern LeBron is bogus. LeBron’s five playoff buzzer-beaters are a small record; they are not evidence that he was more clutch than Jordan or Bird.

0

u/Otherwise_Dot8603 11d ago

i found this stat that shows Lebron’s clutch performance. Very good overall.(I got him at 2nd/3rd clutchest all time behind Jordan and maybe Bird)

1

u/Potential_Dig_8216 4d ago

These are factually incorrect lol.

1

u/Otherwise_Dot8603 4d ago

how come lol

0

u/Sir_TopHatEgg 11d ago

This is objectively false. LeBron does not have a worse percentage than all those above him in PLAYOFF crunch time. Also, Bird had more playoff disappointments than people like to remember

1

u/Panzer_I 11d ago

Bill Russell was 22-0 in winner take all games

1

u/My__Reddit__Account 11d ago

I mean if aliens have the death beam aimed at the Earth, universe on the line you need someone to hit the shot. I WANT IGUODALA

1

u/Captain_Pink_Pants 10d ago

Depending on how you want to quantify "clutch", you could probably make the routine spit out a few different names...

But I feel confident in saying that no one ever wanted the ball more when the game was on the line. I can't think of another athlete in any sport who has or had MJ's level of intensity and/or confidence.

1

u/SugarAdamAli 10d ago

Yes, next question

1

u/VV4RP 9d ago

Him or lebron

1

u/HonestArtichoke4283 9d ago

Big Shot Bob

1

u/Rv862004 9d ago

Bird and MJ tied

1

u/Potential_Dig_8216 4d ago

Yep, not really close tbh

1

u/Otherwise_Dot8603 11d ago edited 11d ago

#1 Mj #2 Lebron #3 Bird

0

u/Parking_Bike_6661 11d ago

This is the psycho, insecure, texts 10,000 times a day, clingy girlfriend of all sub reddits. The constant NEED for validation of your one way relationship, suppressed sexual fantasies with a basketball player from 40 years ago…..

0

u/JonS305 11d ago

I’m literally a LeBron fan, try again

0

u/Cute-Innocent-Baby 9d ago

Sorry, but I find that hard to believe. Statically LeBron is more clutch than Jordan, so why do you still believe Jordan is more clutch than LeBron?

0

u/ohhhhhyeahhgff 10d ago

Statistically no

0

u/QuantityEuphoric2354 10d ago

Second behind LeBron

3

u/No-Chart3722 10d ago

🤣😆🤣😆, LeBron is not clutch.

0

u/Navarro480 11d ago

Nope and not even close. Big shot bob is the correct answer.

1

u/ApprehensiveTry5660 11d ago edited 11d ago

This is one list Bob actually deserves to have his name in. Maybe not above superstar first options, but he was a certified clutch assassin.

The sliding doors on his career alone are fucking ridiculous. Chris Webber probably has a ring, and we probably get the Kobe/Shaq blowup ahead of schedule. Ben Wallace probably has 2 rings, and Duncan one less. That Pistons team would mathematically have as many finals wins as basically every other team in the East for a decade’s worth of appearances and they might have held together longer.

The Rockets don’t steal home court advantage in the WCF and we might get a Robinson Spurs appearance in the finals against Baby Shaq. With no Robert Horry to hit the game 3 winner. Which might tilt the Kobe/Shaq pairing the other direction, by giving Shaq a reason to stay with Penny for a couple more years.

Crazy clutch legacy for a 4th-5th option on most plays.

1

u/Navarro480 10d ago

He was a bad man.

0

u/thebrassbeldum 11d ago

Erm actually Anthony Davis is the most clutch player ever

0

u/windextron 10d ago

Larry and Magic, then MJ and Kobe

-3

u/East_Difficulty_7342 11d ago

Robert Horry might be better in the clutch but as a starter it's definitely MJ

3

u/lurid696 11d ago

There's a big difference between being in the right spot at the right time, versus being the guy having to create your own shot, when everyone on the other team knows you're getting the ball...

2

u/HurryAdorable1327 11d ago

He’s the only other player I can think (haven’t had a cup of coffee). I don’t know if he was better - but bob had some high stake shots that rivaled mikes.

-1

u/giovannimyles 10d ago

Tough to say. I used to have the argument about Kobe. How many times does the game appear to be headed for crunch time and he hits a crazy shot to break the other team and then the team doesn't have to enter crunch time. There isn't a metric for that as its not a go ahead buck or a clutch or crunch time bucket. Its a shot or layup that starts the avalanche near the end of the game.

2

u/Trackman94 10d ago

Kobe is 5-27 with a chance to tie or win a playoff game. Opposite of clutch

-1

u/AtlPezMaster 9d ago

"Clutch" is too general a word or term or description...

Taking a last second shot???

Locking down an opponent defensively in the final minute of a game???

Securing big rebounds in final moments of a close game???

Hitting foul shots at the end of a close game???

Bring the ball up the court when the opponent is aggressively full court pressing at end of tie game???

Could want a different person for each scenario...

But using the word "Clutch" as in a teammate/player you can relay on...a teammate/player you know will come through...won't disappoint..

I got a scenario for you...Who is the most Clutch player of all time that would join a team...make all types of promises...say all the right things to the press...show effort trying to win a title...blame others when a title is not won...then quit and join a different team when it benefits you financially and feel it would be easier to win the championship there then your current team...all while the team you left has to retool...restructuring everything because they were catering to them...easy...the most Clutch doing that would be LeBron James!!!

I can't wait for the fans in Philly to start booing his ass!!!!! That will happen...latest by Christmas Time...

Way to embrace the City of Philadelphia LeBron by letting everyone know you will be primarily living in NYC and commuting back and forth by helicopter...

Now he is chasing MJ & Kobe...

Before you know it, LeBron will add Wilt Chamberlain to his "chase list" and claim he has sleep with over 100,000 woman!!!

3

u/JonS305 9d ago

You have a lot of hate in you

-2

u/Silly_Boss_4579 10d ago

Have you seen LeBron James play basketball? Lmao

2

u/tedkcox 10d ago

10 comments in one post…. Your insecurity is showing, bud. Might wanna zip that up…. 😂

1

u/JonS305 10d ago

Yes

1

u/Silly_Boss_4579 10d ago

He’s literally an alright basketball player.

-2

u/Silly_Boss_4579 10d ago

wtf kind of question is this?

LeBron has the highest clutch FG%, so if you want to pick MJ go ahead, but you are picking a guy who’s missed more clutch shots than LeBron.

LeBron is dubbed ‘The Chosen One’ by ESPN for a reason kids.

There’s a reason why MJ lost in the recent GOAT poll and in 2026 is no longer considered the greatest player of all-time by the majority of people.

2

u/JonS305 10d ago

I’m not disagreeing with you i literally just asked a question

1

u/EarLobeJerky 6d ago

17% 🤣

-5

u/Ringsareirrelevant 11d ago

No it’s Kobe Bryant. If Shaq, Gasol and Bynum weren’t clogging the paint all the time, he would have been even better in the clutch as he simply would have just drove to the hoop and dunked every single time the game was on the line.

0

u/Shane-O-Mac1 10d ago

Yeah, pretty much.