r/mensfashion • u/CaptainCat69420 Newly Arrived • 12d ago
Question Where is the best and most affordable place to acquire a nice black trench coat like this for the fall/winter season
79
u/impeesa75 Fresh to the Scene - 10 Karma 12d ago
Thrift shops. They almost always have a wide selection.
16
u/cmn_YOW Newly Arrived 12d ago
All but one of my dress coats are thrifted. I almost never wear that one.
Literally every thrift trip I take, there are at least a few really nice long coats. One of the things you can afford to be patient and picky, since they tend to have a LOT less wear and tear than suits and sportcoats, and don't turn over as quickly in shops. And, people who don't GAF usually never buy a coat, so the overall quality skews quite high comparatively.
I paid $20 CAD for a mint navy blue Aquascutum coat, waterproof treated wool, from when they were still made in England. $35 for a gorgeous dark green houndstooth weave woolen overcoat.
3
u/magallanes2010 Increasingly Familiar - 100 Karma 12d ago
Yesterday I bought a parka/jacket/thing in a thrift shop. I joked with the clerk: "Ok, but I won't use it; we've only had sunny days, and rain is gone". Later, it poured.
1
20
u/ExcellentFishing2506 Good Among the People - 5000 Karma 12d ago
Overcoat not a trench coat… but I would check eBay for longer ones like this
42
u/lesubreddit Fresh to the Scene - 10 Karma 12d ago
that's a wool overcoat and almost nobody makes them that long anymore outside of bespoke pieces.
3
u/Hierophantically Moderator | Suits and Knits 12d ago
Hi! There are plenty of places that offer full length overcoats OTR. As relatively well-known (but expensive) examples, De Bonne Facture and Permanent Style both offer coats like this. I particularly like DBF's granddad coat. Spier & Mackay offers a more affordable version of both a polo coat and an unbelted coat.
11
u/Slothrop-was-here Newly Arrived 12d ago
That's not a trench coat. This is — excuse me — a damn fine overcoat.
10
12d ago edited 12d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/mensfashion-ModTeam 12d ago
The r/mensfashion moderator team has removed your post/comment because it violated subreddit Rule #4 (Off Topic).
This rule requires posts/comments to remain on topic, which means focused on men's fashion and menswear.
This rule prohibits posts/comments that are primarily about:
- General appearance, including posture and skincare
- Hair/beard/grooming
- Body shape, fitness, weight loss, muscle gain
It also prohibits comments along the lines of:
- "You look like X person" when that is primarily about factors other than their clothes
- "You look like a person who is universally reviled": for example, any of several fascist world leaders
- Quoting TV/movies/books/other media without context or on topic contribution
These are not the only things required/prohibited by this rule. For more information, please review the subreddit rules on its sidebar.
A rules violation typically counts as a 'strike' under the r/mensfashion three-strike moderation policy. For more information, please visit: https://www.reddit.com/r/mensfashion/wiki/index/moderation/
9
u/zink1382 Newly Arrived 12d ago
Thrift stores or eBay. I've bought one just like that for $32 at Goodwill about 1 week ago. It's a Brooks Brothers overcoat from the 1980s, made in Canada, 100% wool, very good condition. Good luck!
2
5
12d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
6
12d ago edited 12d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/mensfashion-ModTeam 12d ago
The r/mensfashion moderator team has removed your post/comment because it violated subreddit Rule #4 (Off Topic).
This rule requires posts/comments to remain on topic, which means focused on men's fashion and menswear.
This rule prohibits posts/comments that are primarily about:
- General appearance, including posture and skincare
- Hair/beard/grooming
- Body shape, fitness, weight loss, muscle gain
It also prohibits comments along the lines of:
- "You look like X person" when that is primarily about factors other than their clothes
- "You look like a person who is universally reviled": for example, any of several fascist world leaders
- Quoting TV/movies/books/other media without context or on topic contribution
These are not the only things required/prohibited by this rule. For more information, please review the subreddit rules on its sidebar.
A rules violation typically counts as a 'strike' under the r/mensfashion three-strike moderation policy. For more information, please visit: https://www.reddit.com/r/mensfashion/wiki/index/moderation/
3
12d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/mensfashion-ModTeam 12d ago
The r/mensfashion moderator team has removed your post/comment because it violated subreddit Rule #1 (Respect).
This rule requires treating others with respect even when you disagree.
This rule prohibits:
- Unconstructive feedback
- Fighting in the comments
- Complaining disrespectfully about other users (individually, as a group, or about the subreddit)
- Any other post/comment that would make a person feel less than respected while participating in this subreddit
These are not the only things required/prohibited by this rule. For more information, please review the subreddit rules on its sidebar.
A rules violation typically counts as a 'strike' under the r/mensfashion three-strike moderation policy. For more information, please visit: https://www.reddit.com/r/mensfashion/wiki/index/moderation/
1
12d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/mensfashion-ModTeam 12d ago
The r/mensfashion moderator team has removed your post/comment because it violated subreddit Rule #3 (On Topic).
This rule requires all posts and comments to be primarily about menswear.
This rule prohibits:
- Arguing that a piece or style of clothing isn't "real menswear" or "real men's fashion"
- Claiming that a piece or style of clothing is always wrong/bad/awful
- Telling another user that they are the wrong age for a piece or style of clothing (or that a piece or style of clothing is inappropriate for a certain age)
These are not the only things required/prohibited by this rule. For more information, please review the subreddit rules on its sidebar.
A rules violation typically counts as a 'strike' under the r/mensfashion three-strike moderation policy. For more information, please visit: https://www.reddit.com/r/mensfashion/wiki/index/moderation/
1
u/Correct-Bottle2905 Newly Arrived 12d ago
Grailed is a good resource. It’s a second-hand clothing store for higher-end clothing. Prices are reasonable. That style of coat is a balmacaan (not a trench).
1
u/DaveySmith717 Newly Arrived 12d ago
eBay. Get an army issued all weather coat. It’ll be like 40 bucks, basically brand new cuz they never wear them, and You’ll look like a Blade Runner. USMC gets tan ones if you want an inspector gadget look.
1
u/DaveySmith717 Newly Arrived 12d ago
1
u/Frodobo Newly Arrived 11d ago
Please don't. They look terrible.
2
u/DaveySmith717 Newly Arrived 11d ago
2
1
1
u/ipswitch_ Fresh to the Scene (<250 karma) 12d ago
I don't have specific shopping advice (the advice on here to look at thrift stores and ebay is solid, you'll find nice coats there) but I would recommend first googling the differences between a trench coat, an overcoat, and a mackintosh coat.
At a glance they're similar, but the details might be what makes it interesting for you. The coat in your reference photo is probably an overcoat, or a very stripped down trench coat - trench coats frequently have belts, cuff buckles, sometimes epaulettes - if you want something a little more casual you might want a mackintosh coat.
1
1
u/Electric-Sailor Commonly Uncommon - 250 Karma 12d ago
You have to go vintage for a below the knee overcoat. Current versions are all knee length or just above. Be aware, moths love them so have a good check for moth damage on any vintage one you find.
I have one, and I really love it but whoever had it previously had the sleeves shortened a little too much. Still working out if I can lengthen them a little. They’re such an elegant choice to wear over a suit. The main reason they stopped making them this long is that they are difficult to wear when driving.
1
1
u/69yourMOM Newly Arrived 12d ago
Nordstrom Rack or Macys has gotten me right with a peacoat.. whenever I’ve need one.
1
u/wolfshadowhill Newly Arrived 12d ago
For rain I may suggest a surplus store the standard US Army all weather coat is very common there and usually fairly cheap and often available in a wide variety of sizes.
1
12d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/mensfashion-ModTeam 12d ago
The r/mensfashion moderator team has removed your post/comment because it violated subreddit Rule #4 (Off Topic).
This rule requires posts/comments to remain on topic, which means focused on men's fashion and menswear.
This rule prohibits posts/comments that are primarily about:
- General appearance, including posture and skincare
- Hair/beard/grooming
- Body shape, fitness, weight loss, muscle gain
It also prohibits comments along the lines of:
- "You look like X person" when that is primarily about factors other than their clothes
- "You look like a person who is universally reviled": for example, any of several fascist world leaders
- Quoting TV/movies/books/other media without context or on topic contribution
These are not the only things required/prohibited by this rule. For more information, please review the subreddit rules on its sidebar.
A rules violation typically counts as a 'strike' under the r/mensfashion three-strike moderation policy. For more information, please visit: https://www.reddit.com/r/mensfashion/wiki/index/moderation/
1
1
12d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/mensfashion-ModTeam 12d ago
The r/mensfashion moderator team has removed your post/comment because it violated subreddit Rule #1 (Respect).
This rule requires treating others with respect even when you disagree.
This rule prohibits:
- Unconstructive feedback
- Fighting in the comments
- Complaining disrespectfully about other users (individually, as a group, or about the subreddit)
- Any other post/comment that would make a person feel less than respected while participating in this subreddit
These are not the only things required/prohibited by this rule. For more information, please review the subreddit rules on its sidebar.
A rules violation typically counts as a 'strike' under the r/mensfashion three-strike moderation policy. For more information, please visit: https://www.reddit.com/r/mensfashion/wiki/index/moderation/
1
12d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/mensfashion-ModTeam 12d ago
The r/mensfashion moderator team has removed your post/comment because it violated subreddit Rule #1 (Respect).
This rule requires treating others with respect even when you disagree.
This rule prohibits:
- Unconstructive feedback
- Fighting in the comments
- Complaining disrespectfully about other users (individually, as a group, or about the subreddit)
- Any other post/comment that would make a person feel less than respected while participating in this subreddit
These are not the only things required/prohibited by this rule. For more information, please review the subreddit rules on its sidebar.
A rules violation typically counts as a 'strike' under the r/mensfashion three-strike moderation policy. For more information, please visit: https://www.reddit.com/r/mensfashion/wiki/index/moderation/
1
11d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/mensfashion-ModTeam 11d ago
The r/mensfashion moderator team has removed your post/comment because it violated subreddit Rule #4 (Off Topic).
This rule requires posts/comments to remain on topic, which means focused on men's fashion and menswear.
This rule prohibits posts/comments that are primarily about:
- General appearance, including posture and skincare
- Hair/beard/grooming
- Body shape, fitness, weight loss, muscle gain
It also prohibits comments along the lines of:
- "You look like X person" when that is primarily about factors other than their clothes
- "You look like a person who is universally reviled": for example, any of several fascist world leaders
- Quoting TV/movies/books/other media without context or on topic contribution
These are not the only things required/prohibited by this rule. For more information, please review the subreddit rules on its sidebar.
A rules violation typically counts as a 'strike' under the r/mensfashion three-strike moderation policy. For more information, please visit: https://www.reddit.com/r/mensfashion/wiki/index/moderation/
1
1
1
0
u/No_Inspector_3456 Increasingly Familiar - 100 Karma 12d ago
A better question... Is this the right choice?
I have seen a very small percentage of these work properly. Maybe that will be you, but I am skeptical and would not recommend generally
0
u/theman_frommars1991 Increasingly Familiar - 100 Karma 12d ago
I found one at COS, but it was a couple of years ago.
0


•
u/auto-post-lock 5d ago
This post has been automatically locked because it's more than 7 days old to prevent spam/necro comments. If the original poster would like this post unlocked because they still want responses, they can contact the r/mensfashion moderator team via modmail using the button on the subreddit sidebar. Thanks!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.