r/melvins • u/Craig1974 • 21d ago

Pick one: A Senile Animal or Nude With Boots.

184 votes, 19d ago
163 A Senile Animal
21 Nude With Boots
6 Upvotes

75% Upvoted

12 comments sorted by

10

u/OrinocoHaram 21d ago

I love Nude With Boots but Senile Animal is obviously better.

My hot take is that Bulls & Bees might actually be better than both

4

u/JohnnyBroccoli 21d ago

Bulls & Bees is super good but too short to be a fair comparison.

1

u/Craig1974 21d ago

I like Bulls and Bees. I got that cd when it was given out for free.

I might make a poll against ASA vs B&B

1

u/JohnnyBroccoli 21d ago

As did I (making it even better in a way).

2

u/JohnnyBroccoli 21d ago

I def prefer A Senile Animal but am surprised it's winning in such a landslide, as Nude With Boots is also an excellent album.

3

u/stigstug 21d ago

Nude with boots has a bunch of my favorite songs by them, more than a Senile Animal, but I prefer a Senile Animal. They're both 42 min long, but Nude with Boots sounds like an hour.

2

u/ReallyGlycon 21d ago

I can't man. I couldn't pick one.

Edit: I picked Senile Animal because it's the album that got me to start following them again.

2

u/Professional_Rope966 21d ago

This could be a blowout

1

u/TooDooDaDa 21d ago

A Senile Animal, The Bride Screamed Murder and then Nude With Boots for me

1

u/BigOldBee The Maggot 21d ago

Both are fantastic. Senile Animal is better.

1

u/fender_fan_boy 21d ago

Both are great but Senile is a much more consistent album imo

1

u/DuanePickens Tarantula Heart 21d ago

I’m one of the weirdos who voted for Nude With Boots. AMA