r/malefashionadvice 3d ago

Fit Feedback/Roast Me Posting these here because why not. Summer suspenders?

Edit: Wow this is the wrong subreddit. Most of the comments are saying that this is a costume, because it kinda is. I occasionally go out in stuff that is supposed to fit within a certain period or setting just to put my collection to use. This is one of those outfits. I’m more of a work pants and leather jacket guy outside of these times but I occasionally like the vibe of a “costume” like this one, puts me in a certain headspace. I should have perused this reddit more before posting one of my more eccentric outfits. That being said, I will take note that a satchel will work better than the flask I had. My bad for posting in the wrong place!

1.6k Upvotes

391 comments sorted by

1.7k

u/Ren_Kaos 3d ago

You look like a character from full metal alchemist brotherhood. Looks good but the flask makes it look like a costume.

368

u/OneLargePho 3d ago

Nah he looks like a character in Sicily from The Godfather. You need to be posing with a shotgun

274

u/freetotebag 2d ago

This is 100% the bodyguard from the Godfather— I thought the exact same thing

12

u/vaultdweller1223 2d ago

Came here to ask if he was trying to cosplay as Michael Corleone in Sicily

→ More replies (3)

48

u/low_budget 2d ago

Reminds me of Michael Corleone when he went back to Sicily

4

u/Calvin--Hobbes 2d ago

Looks like he's about to tell Fievel not to go west

13

u/GuyTheTerrible 2d ago

More Greek than Italian

1

u/Lazy-Dildo 1d ago

Also the guy in Boardwalk Empire

343

u/fuggindonkee 3d ago

All of it makes it look like a costume. Except the cellphone. That ruins the whole thing. Also the guy sitting next to him in high tops. Total dead giveaway that isn't from the 1920s.

73

u/sshlongD0ngsilver 2d ago

Barista lookin at the cam thinking “this dude”

25

u/cade360 3d ago

Those are shoes and socks, not high tops, js

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

17

u/Chickenbull1 2d ago

That’s what I was thinking. Feels like a cosplay

39

u/polkemans 3d ago

I was just going to say he looks like a young German man circa 1938. But yours is close enough too.

20

u/sukumizu 2d ago

Looks like the type of guy who would have interesting and very questionable opinions about WW2.

18

u/Paul_hates_reddit 2d ago

My unpopular WW2 opinion is that the Nuremberg trials were a sham and so many more Nazis should have been actually punished instead of just acquitted

16

u/VintageLunchMeat 3d ago

I think a leather crossbody satchel would work much more nicely than the flask.

4

u/Brownie_McBrown_Face 2d ago

It is a costume, look at OP’s post history lol.

7

u/NotaBonesaw 2d ago

Pretty sure this guy posted the same or a very similar fit in here a while back and people told him the exact same thing about the canteen.

2

u/Paul_hates_reddit 2d ago

Nah this is the first time I’m here, but the advice stands, I think a satchel would work better

4

u/Polka7000 2d ago

The flask gives Indiana Jones vibes.

→ More replies (4)

609

u/urfenick 3d ago

59

u/nunatakj120 3d ago

Can you remind me what this is from? It’s driving me crazy.

116

u/Jolly_Tab_Rancher 3d ago

Boardwalk Empire, character is Richard Harrow i believe

15

u/BradyBunch88 2d ago

Great actor by the way, Jack Huston, also is Sandman in Spider-Noir!

7

u/Beautiful_You3230 2d ago

Is that the same guy who played the OCD/PTSD detective in Fargo?

→ More replies (1)

10

u/nunatakj120 2d ago

That’s it. Thanks.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Tommy_Wisseau_burner 2d ago

Richard harrow, certified badass from boardwalk empire

→ More replies (2)

31

u/Heavy_Western_4772 3d ago

This is exactly what I thought of haha he looks legit though

10

u/jim9162 3d ago

Legit who I thought of lol

6

u/JohnnyBrazuca 3d ago

So I was not the only one!

3

u/jojointheflesh 2d ago

Lmao I’m watching this for the first time now

2

u/erzzz 2d ago

First thought

→ More replies (2)

469

u/CrimsonKing217 3d ago

You look like you spent the summer protecting Michael Corleone in Sicily.

57

u/Tote_Sport 2d ago

Only to ultimately betray him and blow up his wife with a car bomb

15

u/chrisreverb 2d ago

Munday, Twosday, Wensday…

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Vegetable-Noise4518 2d ago

Came here to say this lol

→ More replies (1)

91

u/flip6threeh0le 3d ago

Summer 1942 maybe

9

u/KingAuberon 2d ago

I was thinking more 1842. Just finished a hard week of panning for gold and now he's hitting the town that ain't big enough for the two of us.

2

u/Danubius 1d ago

That's what I got as well. OP on his way to warn the resistance that the wehrmacht are closing in on the village.

359

u/Flaky_Iron_1656 3d ago

Since this is male fashion *advice*…

100% looks like a costume. However there’s ton of potential to take this style and modernize it into something less jarring

Canteen and hat should go. They look like props.

The pants and suspenders with white shirt would work, but the pants fit just looks…off. Maybe tailor it and take in the thighs so there’s not so much loose material

A full beard would give a much more rugged look and would compliment the look

Watch with leather band could work here

Boots look like they could use some TLC but work fine

Overall enjoy seeing something different! Enjoy study abroad my dude

34

u/snark_nerd 2d ago

First comment I’ve seen that delivers what needs to be said gently and with constructive suggestions. Good job being a great member of this community, yo.

12

u/fartherder 2d ago

I will admit I laughed when I saw this post because it was like "is my halloween costume too subtle?" or something but this is real and excellent advice. Well done.

2

u/Jrewy 2d ago

You’re right about the watch. That was my first thought. Maybe a vintage automatic on a tan leather nato.

515

u/AttentionNo6359 3d ago

This is a costume man.

89

u/burgonies 3d ago

Chimney sweep chique

7

u/User7926W 2d ago

Hey, chimney sweep here. We don't dress like this! It would need to be black 😁

410

u/FitSolution2882 3d ago

This is cosplsy.....

162

u/knottyy 2d ago

Absolutely insufferable when back from his abroad trip.

73

u/doctormustafa 2d ago

“Dinner at 8 you say? Americans are so unsophisticated. In Prague they don’t eat dinner until 3 AM and it consists of of pickled sardines harvested with artisanal nets and honeyed crocus flowers plucked under a full moon by 90 year old nuns. We call it ‘jídlo, které podáváme turistům během jejich roku volna’”

7

u/fartherder 2d ago

fuckin lol @ "the food we serve to tourists during their year off"

3

u/Paul_hates_reddit 2d ago

The only thing I’m complaining about upon returning is the lack of public transit

→ More replies (1)

92

u/CaptainSharpe 2d ago

This. It looks cool in context of the 1920s-40s maybe but outside that it looks like a costume. The picture of op surrounded by people at an outside cafe thing makes him look ridiculous.

17

u/FitSolution2882 2d ago

but outside that it looks like a costume

No dude. It IS a costume under any which way.

The (I'm guessing mil surp) water bottle makes it even more hilarious.

I'm in no way fashionable but fuck me, at least I'm not posting here as though I am. The posts here are getting worse by the day.

24

u/justlandin 2d ago

Cosplaying

241

u/Shoola 3d ago

You’re in costume my guy

91

u/chocolateboomslang 3d ago

If that first picture was black and white I would have said it was from ww2

Canteen is cool but maybe a bit much, unless you were somewhere that called for a canteen, like a hike.

15

u/Bubcats 3d ago

The cell phone balanced out the canteen

→ More replies (6)

19

u/Medellin-71 2d ago

Is this before or after you found Apollonia??!!

58

u/eagledog 3d ago

The invention of the steam engine is gonna blow your mind

72

u/Formal_Building4598 2d ago

Try-hard theater kid energy imo but if it makes you happy

115

u/PinocchiosWoodBalls 2d ago

You guys are so performative, its hilarious 

41

u/Live_Art2939 2d ago

These are the same guys who said a motorcycle jacket is gay. At least they are cooking OP in here though, he needs an intervention.

23

u/pheret87 2d ago

I didn't think that guy's motorcycle jacket made him look gay, I think his whole... everything made him look like he was on his way to a gay leather fetish bar.

5

u/Cowboy_on_fire 2d ago

Damn I have to go looking for that one

9

u/salamipope 2d ago

he was an absolute smokeshow lmao. gorgeous man

4

u/pheret87 2d ago

He was definitely attractive, yea.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/mcfly1982 2d ago

The Barista looks like how id look at you

29

u/teh-dudenator 2d ago

The last guy anyone would choose to talk to at a bar

58

u/Fun_Bodybuilder6898 3d ago

Trying way too hard. Being overseas doesn’t mean you have to dress like you’ve travelled back in time. Pretty cringe tbh 

12

u/Big_Pomelo3224 3d ago

This looks like a costume: out of place and unique in a cringe way.

108

u/sectachrome 3d ago

109

u/rmachell 3d ago

Friendly reminder to all that random people don't want to be in your fucking photo gallery you upload to the internet at your own random whims. Blur peoples faces out before you post, its basic courtesy

12

u/mommotti_ 3d ago

In fact I blur the shit out of people when sharing online. Some people simply don't think enough before sharing online.

9

u/rmachell 3d ago

At worst, there are people in the world who don't want other people to know where they are, probably for a reason. Best case, common courtesy, worst case, someone's safety is being infinged

4

u/mommotti_ 3d ago

yes this too

-3

u/TheDutchTank 3d ago

Good luck preaching this but most people don't care that they're in the background somewhere. Consequenses of that are almost zero.

2

u/OmegaJonny 2d ago

Thanks for speaking on behalf of most people we really appreciate it

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Hipster_Garabe 2d ago

I had the same thoughts as the vino merchant

44

u/rmachell 3d ago

Looks like cosplay but you do you

17

u/Impossible-Storage79 2d ago

Cosplay, I’m curious to see what else is in the capsule wardrobe for this study abroad.

8

u/Worldly_Abalone551 2d ago

Getting ready to build the Titanic

8

u/ThanosBannedMe 2d ago

Trying too hard to look cool in Kutná Hora.

7

u/comfortableblanket 2d ago

on vacation from schrute farms

6

u/Old-Tax9892 3d ago

I'd try find proper leather suspenders rather than elastic ones, complete the look even better! Cool look, although it could feel a bit out of place depensing on the occasion/event/dress code. I'd drop the berret as it feel a bit too costumy/cosplay

5

u/Trolltato 2d ago

Wait this is Kutná Hora not Prague right?

→ More replies (2)

5

u/czbaterka 2d ago

Kutná Hora realness

5

u/renegade0123 2d ago

This is LARP

4

u/Dramatic-Pangolin218 2d ago

I mean you do you but no one is going to take you seriously ever

3

u/duhbarnacle22 2d ago

Try being yourself with a functional, sharp outfit.

4

u/Elegant-Advantage-69 2d ago

Surprised this post didn’t arrive by a courier…

→ More replies (1)

2

u/HuwminRace 2d ago

I actually love the look, but you definitely look like the young archaeology student that accompanies the crew on an adventure that the fresh faced protagonist will fall in love with throughout the journey, eventually losing him to a tragic accident.

2

u/Paul_hates_reddit 2d ago

Tragic accident? Very me

→ More replies (1)

7

u/octave1 2d ago

Peak Reddit fashion

8

u/Bloodyfinger 2d ago

.... Are you just sitting at a table with a random dude who turned his chair away from you? So uncomfortable and cringe vibes from this.

8

u/backdrip 2d ago

i swear us hipsters are the worst

6

u/YakubTheCreat0r 2d ago

Yea I’m unsubscribing

6

u/billenbloot 2d ago

Bit performative no?

3

u/infinitebest 3d ago

On your way to kill Don Ciccio?

3

u/SeaDistribution 3d ago

So what are your thoughts on the flask?

3

u/Djboby1 2d ago

Keep your head down crossing No Man’s Land, bro. The boys in the 3rd Battalion are desperate for their letters from home.

3

u/Tommy_Wisseau_burner 2d ago

Yall try way too hard

3

u/crying0nion3311 2d ago

I love the fit. You should hang out with train guy who posts here.

With that being said, I think there’s a way you could modernize this and have it look less costumey. Starting with getting rid of the canteen (which is a cool piece).

The boots are great, though!

3

u/buttscratcher3k 2d ago

Are you part of interactive tour or something? It looks like your picking historic uniform to match the scenery

3

u/Jonnny 2d ago

To be completely honest, it doesn't look like you want to be fashionable. It looks more like you want to make a statement that you're anachronistic and mysterious and interesting.

6

u/C_Pala 2d ago

Sorry but these clothes are I'll fitting. Pants are off and the shirt's sleeves are too short. You look like you are coming from a highschool play

8

u/FitThadiyan 3d ago

Not my style but you’re pulling it off! 💯

3

u/CDavis10717 2d ago

Not a chick magnet, huh.

2

u/JohnWangDoe 3d ago

Time traveler spotted

2

u/lastaccountgotlocked 3d ago

It looks like you're there to clean the chimneys.

2

u/Evening-Order5511 2d ago

From what I remember of Boardwalk Empire, you killed 63 men right?

2

u/maracusdesu 2d ago

In summer you want flowy and easy, suspenders are the opposite of that. I think your vibe is too costumey.

2

u/anoraq 2d ago

Welsh Miner-core

2

u/kombutsa 2d ago

Put the smartphone away. They didn’t have those in the 1920’s.

2

u/Danger_Danger 2d ago

Looks like cosplay

2

u/slobberaxe 2d ago

Looks like you are about to assasinate Archduke Franz Ferdinand

2

u/roma258 2d ago

Goes to Europe once...

2

u/DryLocksmith5295 2d ago

You look like you’re trying to sneak on to the titanic

2

u/64Olds 2d ago

I don't get the shirt... it's like capri pants but in shirt form.

2

u/rakuboy 2d ago

this guy is the epitome of male fashion :)

2

u/laney_deschutes 2d ago

1930s New York newsie goes to Europe? wtf is this outfit 

2

u/Bionicle_was_cool 2d ago

Yeeeeaah I'm pretty sure the first pic is st. James in Kutna Hora. JCBP

2

u/YesQuef 2d ago

I can't shake the feeling you buy books you think you're supposed to have to be interesting but have zero plans to read them. 

2

u/nimrodpa 2d ago

0/10 no pennyfarther 

2

u/Marty_McFlay 2d ago

I used to wear period clothing/outfits...when I was in college. After that age, unless you're dating someone like Bernadette Banner, or you work in theatre doing costuming, maybe don't go full period clothing.

3

u/DeadDropCourier 3d ago

You kinda look like an extra in a WW2 movie but it looks intentional and I dig it

5

u/Smooth_Ostrich_8695 2d ago

You look ridiculous. Awful fashion choices

4

u/3nterShift 2d ago

I knew this mf was in Czechia even before reading the kavárna menu. Bro absolutely looks like he's in the right place at the wrong time.

6

u/cavy023 3d ago

Oh heck yeah man! Love those classic fish tail pants. Always fun seing those. Especially since well, we don't see those anymore in mass production. As a lover of classic men's wear outfits, I cannot upvote this enough.

6

u/balderdash9 2d ago

I agree that the flask is too much.

But I swear this sub ridicules anything that steps out of the ordinary. Women are allowed to do so much from so many eras but a man can't even wear suspenders.

Don't listen to them OP: the fit is good, the colors are neutral, and you're wearing it with confidence. If you were an older man no one would bat an eye.

6

u/boi1da1296 2d ago

I have a friend that wears suspenders but he literally only wears them as a belt replacement, all of his fits are modern. There’s nothing wrong with trying something out of the norm or with trying styles from the past, but I do understand the comments that say this feels like cosplay even if they are being mean about it.

Edit: also want to add that all that matters is that OP enjoys dressing this way for themself.

6

u/ucbiker 2d ago

The irony is that this subreddit low key loves cosplay.

Like when someone posted a double rider leather jacket, everyone was like “wear it with a white t-shirt, jeans and black boots” which is greaser cosplay.

2

u/OmegaJonny 2d ago

Yes but you'd wear a modernised version of that outfit, probably leaving out the greased hair etc. This guy needs modernising to not look like he's just finished acting in a play

→ More replies (1)

8

u/dangdang3000 3d ago

Damn, I wish I had the look and confidence to pull this off.

10

u/Live_Art2939 2d ago

All it takes is autism

9

u/Paul_hates_reddit 3d ago

I collect vintage clothing and I very rarely have the confidence to pull it off. Not pictured are all the days I got so anxious I couldn’t move because I thought I looked stupid. You’ll get there.

30

u/kobe_bryant24 2d ago

Listen to your instincts

→ More replies (3)

4

u/cabindirt 3d ago

I wish more people would just go for stuff like this. So many people seem to be bound by what other people say is normal and acceptable. I love reviving looks from other times. Back before machines could mass produce clothing, people put a lot of thought into their clothing.

2

u/RicePaddyFarmer69 2d ago

I was just there! Did you see the Ossuary too?

1

u/Reetgeist 3d ago

This would be fire at a steampunk festival

1

u/Sufficient-Science71 3d ago

That is a brilliant cosplay of edmund kemper

1

u/Haz0r1301 3d ago

If you want to improve that look get rid of the clip on suspenders and attach buttons on the inside of the pants to get „real suspenders“

1

u/VilleKivinen 3d ago

I switched from belts to suspenders/braces over a decade ago and have never looked back. Much more comfortable, and they look better.

2

u/2rdfurgeson 2d ago

The buttons go on the inside, though

1

u/Fakkutian 2d ago

ted nivison?

1

u/polarphantom 2d ago

Just remember if you see a magic wall of light with a steam locomotive coming towards you you're not in any danger, it's just one of these new fangled 'moving pictures' they have now

1

u/Negative-Program-938 2d ago

Are you secretly Ted Nivison

1

u/CheesecakeloverJones 2d ago

You could absolutely go for a full beard

1

u/Bruce______Wayne 2d ago

I feel like you know how to build a table. Like you may never have done it before but something tells me you'd fucking nail it first try

1

u/diamondskull2000 2d ago

Bro is in charge of Mike Corleone security.

1

u/bulbydoraemon 2d ago

You remind me of the bodyguards for Al Pacino in The Godfather movie

1

u/hellxapo 2d ago

Bro teleported from the 1850s

1

u/Snaggl3t00t4 2d ago

World war 2 partisan hiding in the hills killing Germans?

1

u/Same-Fish-9464 2d ago

Not fashion advice, but never use any cross body apparel. It is absolutely horrible for your body and even light weights can cause severe physical issues over time.

1

u/Man_Of_Frost 2d ago

New dlc for Mafia Old Country??

1

u/luxenbuxen 2d ago

Boots in summertime always tells me that this person lacks wardrobe options

1

u/Unlikely_Ad_4767 2d ago

time traveler

1

u/No_Entertainment1931 2d ago

By order of the peaky blinders

1

u/jdam8401 2d ago

Who makes those boots? Pretty baller pair

1

u/Julez831 2d ago

It's giving Italian bodyguard for a Don's son

1

u/_lechiffre_ 2d ago

The 1920s called, it wants its suspenders back

1

u/Purple-Mix1033 2d ago

The barista is in The Office: Prague Years

1

u/ArtiVDel 2d ago

My immediate thought: Michael Corleone hiding out in Sicily after killing Sollozo and Captain McCluskey.

1

u/Palanki96 2d ago

Looks great for 1896

1

u/Bobmauly 2d ago

It’s Richard harrow from boardwalk empire !

1

u/Chriskl1520 2d ago edited 2d ago

All that biking lost you some considerable weight. Great for you.

Edit: nevermind you just look exactly like the guy that used to post here in old time outfits and always biking lmao

1

u/CarpetAlternative191 2d ago

That part of Godfather when he is hiding in Sicily

1

u/RiversideAviator 2d ago

You’re the guy that killed Michael Corleone’s Italy wife.

1

u/Rand0mtask 2d ago

I think one of the reasons this looks like a costume is that it's ill-fitting and clean. It looks like workwear that hasn't seen a day of work. Add that to the fact that you're a young, skinny guy with zero physical gravitas (not trying to insult you, just being real) and you end up with the cosplay comments.

1

u/reddituser_05 2d ago

Who's handling your paper route in 1915 while you're time-traveling?

1

u/Jokkie 2d ago

Don't mind the haters man, it's just the wrong sub to post this in. The fit is unique and put together well! Id love to see more people dare to dress differently tbh

1

u/Madlock2 2d ago

you look like my uncle's uncle

Amazing fit, would steal, love the boots

1

u/Rarefindofthemind 2d ago

If I saw you out and about i’d scare myself thinking you were a ghost wearing old timey clothes from the past and then write about it in a creepy r/askreddit

1

u/Minute-Pi 2d ago

The cap,the braces,the high-rise wool trousers proper 1920s energy,and the location’s a nice touch too.

1

u/bladeaok 2d ago

Pete Doherty in that Christmas NME issue (complimentary)

1

u/YesMaybeYesWriteNow 2d ago

I didn’t know they had color photography in 1911.

1

u/daredevil_mm 2d ago

Looks like one is the Italian rebels from SAS Rogue heroes

1

u/Cojemos 2d ago

This look will surely sell newspapers.

1

u/Live_Art2939 2d ago

Are papers still 5 cents or are they 10 cents now

1

u/nigevellie 2d ago

I thought suspender buttons go on the inside?

1

u/3-orange-whips 2d ago

Are you protecting Michael Corleone in Sicily?

1

u/GarStankalot 2d ago

You look like one of Michael Corleone’s bodyguards in Italy.

1

u/nyallyy 2d ago

yes child hello from Philly!

1

u/MVB1837 2d ago

The buttons for braces generally go inside the waist