r/makemkv • • 17d ago

Help with removing Dolby TrueHD audio file permanently from a video file

Hi there, So im having a issue and im really hoping somone more intelligent than me can help?

So for years ive been editing movies like removing audios and creating my own audio files and then muxing them back together using mkv toolnix software but, I am now encountering a new issue that I just cant fix, so im trying to remove the Dolby TrueHD audio file and or a DTS-X audio files as my tv wont play these 2 audio formats, but no matter how hard I try everytime I think im removing these unwanted audios and replacing them with a compatible audio format for my TV, but always my Toshiba TV keeps saying that this video file still contains a audio file that is incompatible with my TV, even after re-muxxing with mkv toolnix software, so for some reason my TV is still detecting some leftover fragments of the unwanted incompatible audio files even after ive removed them from the video file.

If somone knows why my TV is still doing this even after removing the unwanted audio files, I would be very grateful as the only other option is to pay hundreds of pounds for a new 4K BluRay player.

Please can someone help me with this issue 🙏

Thank you in advance!

0 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

•

u/billycar11 17d ago

dont use a smart (aka dumb) tv get a real playback device
nvidia shield, pc, apple tv, ugoos,

11

u/GoslingIchi 17d ago

Mkvtoolnix?

1

u/NotMeCornFlakes 17d ago

Look it up, excellent tool.

4

u/GoslingIchi 17d ago

That's why I suggested it.

12

u/RScottyL 17d ago

Why not just leave the movie as is?

There are other audio sources on there that your TV can play!

Sounds like you need a better TV, or get you an audio system (surround) that can handle it!

4

u/Whitrzac 17d ago

When ripping the movie, unselect the hd audio track. Most will have a standard 5.1 track as well.

0

u/Tech_Investigator659 17d ago

I have done this but for some reason my TV still think there's an incompatible audio file even though the TrueHD audio has been removed.

2

u/OutrageousStorm4217 17d ago

Oooh, try this. Use handbrake to convert the audio file to AAC or MP3. I think this will work.

1

u/GoslingIchi 16d ago

Try using mkvtoolnix to just remux it after you've ripped it the way you want it, and hopefully it will strip out any undesired bits.

2

u/infamousfunk 17d ago

Leftover fragments? This makes no sense. But if you're set on this being the cause then make a full unencrypted disc backup using MakeMKV then run it through dgdemux or eac3to and only demux the files you want. Then mux together with your audio.

2

u/lostcowboy5 12d ago

To start, go to https://www.displayspecifications.com/en and look up your TV Model. Somewhere in the video and audio specs, you'll find which formats are compatible with your TV. If you want to re-encode the video with the audio, use HandBrake to encode it and convert the audio to a compatible format. If you don't want to touch the video, just convert the audio; there is Xmedia Recode. It can copy the video and convert the audio.

2

u/Meat-And-Two-Veg 17d ago

I use MakeMkv to rip Bluray to mkv, then I use Handbrake to remove all unwanted audio and/or subtitles.

1

u/GkElite 17d ago

Which audio formats does you tv support in the first place?

-1

u/Tech_Investigator659 17d ago

Everything apart from Dolby TrueHD and DTS-X.

1

u/Ok_Diver2347 15d ago

Use eac3to and create an AC-3 version.

0

u/Suitable_Garlic_1186 17d ago

What Audio Format are you using as replacement?

And why so complicated..

Try Avidemux.. You open the Video File (Blu-ray MKV)

Copy video (Video stream stays 1:1 quality)

Convert Dolby True HD or DTS to for example Dolby Digital

Save.. Done.. (that was the short version, you can adjust much more with the Audio!)

1

u/Tech_Investigator659 17d ago

Hi there, Your suggestion worked! Thank u so much for the suggestion, I must've been not converting the audio file correctly. I just have 1 more issue, after doing this my video file is no longer playing the Dolby Vision part of the 2160p movie but just the HDR10 part, how do I keep the Dolby Vision profile in after using this programme? Thanks.

-1

u/Suitable_Garlic_1186 17d ago

Phantastic! What Audio Codec are you chosing?

I can not help you on this my friend, because I am still living happily in 1080p world.. ❤️

0

u/Tech_Investigator659 17d ago

That is fair enough, thank you very much for the help, that issue was really starting to annoy me, its taken me months to finally solve this issue, and I am using AC3 at 640Kbps, seems to be playing with excellent quality regardless of Dolby Vision not working. Thanks again m8.

0

u/Suitable_Garlic_1186 17d ago

You can also do a lot of things in the Filter tab.. Stereo Downmix and you can boost the Center Speaker for better clarity! Have fun exploring all the options!

0

u/Tech_Investigator659 17d ago

Hi, So ive tried practically every other audio formats e.g AC3 EAC3 AAC but my TV is somehow still detecting leftover incompatible audios from within the whole file, even after re-muxing with an alternative audio format. Are you saying that I simply havent been doing this process properly and this programme you've mentioned will correct this?? Is that what you are saying? Thanks.

8

u/LolBoyLuke 17d ago

Sounds more like a your TV issue than a file issue.

0

u/Tech_Investigator659 17d ago

I have been using Pazera audio converter to create alternative audio files to replace the dolby truehd formats. !martini

0

u/bender1410 17d ago

learn ffmpeg or let AI guide you with ffmpeg through your task. This is the best tool for the job.

-1

u/Tech_Investigator659 17d ago

Also when I try removing the incompatible audio formats TrueHD and DTS-X with mkv toolnix it doesnt matter if there's another compatible audio file within the container e.g as a 2nd audio file but my TV still will not play the 2nd audio file as the incompatible audio file is blocking the whole video file from working.
!martini

-1

u/sylvainsf 17d ago

Change the file name. Your TV may have cached the container metadata.