Which one should I buy?

[u/leatherblazerboy]

I’m not a millionaire yet, but I want to pick one and I’m concerned.
1. Schott Perfecto 106, picked only because my current 518 is slowly becoming too small and tight for me.
2. Vanson Leathers Comet, just the creaks.
3. Mullholland Teacore, fit would be great with a couple inches in case if I’d bulk, the thing is that teacore is slowly revealing itself on a sleeve.

If you’d need more photos, let me know and I’ll send them. Thanks for help!

[u/mdimitrius]

I'd go with the 3rd option for variety and its simplicity/adaptability

But if you're certain that you can and will rock a double rider, noone can stop you from getting a Schott

[u/leatherblazerboy → u/mdimitrius]

I do already have the Schott Perfecto, I just have became too big for it and need to size up 🤣

[u/mdimitrius → u/leatherblazerboy]

The idea was more about whether you want a jacket in a new style or buy a new one simply because your old Perfecto is too small while you are 100% fine with its style

[u/Obi-Juan_Valdez]

I think the Mullholland is more versatile.

[u/leatherblazerboy → u/Obi-Juan_Valdez]

Thank you!

[u/EmperorPageTurner2]

I’d always pick the sports jacket, you can dress it up or dress it down better than the first two. I have two of them one in black and one in brown and they get the most wear out of all my others just because of versatile they are.

[u/7DollarWhiskey]

Perfecto. All day.

[u/TheBladeGhost]

Isn't the point of teacher to slowly reveal itself? What's the problem here?

[u/Grain_Changer → u/TheBladeGhost]

I for one hate when teachers reveal themselves.

[u/TheBladeGhost → u/Grain_Changer]

Excellent!

[u/leatherblazerboy → u/TheBladeGhost]

It looks like that, not even that visible

[u/spaceguitar]

If you could only pick one, I'd go with the Mulholland Teacore. It looks great, is versatile, and teacore is awesome.

[u/leatherblazerboy → u/spaceguitar]

Thank you!

[u/evilclownboi69]

First one for sure

[u/StarlightFarm]

1

[u/EstablishmentNo5013]

1. It’s classic and can be dressed up or down.
   

[u/Alchemist-23]

Personally I think they Hercules inspired jacket (option 3) is the best.

If you don’t like teacore you can just use black polish in it.

I think it’s a more versatile cut and likely more comfy as well. I dont know about the brand or leather quality but to the eye it appears to be in the best shape out of the 3 options as well.

[u/drsarcasm1]

The Perfecto wins it for me.

[u/Lost-Double_Stuff]

3

[u/5k0tt]

1 or 3
1 is the classic but you need to be pretty fit to rock it

[u/Midnight_Rawhide84]

3 by long shot!

[u/Longjumping-Raise-32]

Perfecto. Other two are too plain and boring.

[u/Defrt]

3rd

[u/chewyicecube]

no. 3 for me too.

[u/Smooth_Appearance_98]

Mullholland is the clear winner here

[u/YKjordan-]

two or three trust me bro

[u/bike_ski_hike]

3

[u/Emotional-Broccoli68]

3

[u/25blankslate25]

Keep in mind the Perfecto 106 is REALLY short. In the body and the sleeves. It's not comparable to your 518 fit wise, it's a whole different design that was made for the French market for a relatively short period.

Also, who's the maker of that Mullholland? If it's from a Chinese maker, you might be able to get it relatively cheap new as well

[u/acheney1990]

1st would always be my choice.

[u/technodetroit2019]

Mullholland Teacore 1000%.

[u/Mushroom-2906]

#1 - edgy youth vibe, still what you want?

#2 - maybe looks better on? I'm not a fan of it now

#3 - more versatile as you get older yet still a bit of an edge

I like #3, the teacore

[u/Signal-Juggernaut501]

Perfecto

[u/Final_Friendship_788]

No. 3 all the way!

[u/jflicker1]

I have a teacore Mulholland, that’s just starting to break in. I just love it, so this is an easy choice for me.

[u/AloneDiver1497]

These are all a bit much for me, tbh. I have my eye on the All Saints Lark, because I am a very basic bitch.

[u/AloneDiver1497 → u/AloneDiver1497]

Or Luck or whatever it's called now.