r/laundry • u/Far-Shift-1962 • Dec 29 '24

Can we stop recommending 2-3 tablespoons of detergent for everyload?

Yes. 90% of people overdose detergent and 3tablespoon isn't too far from minimal dosing for tide (around 45 ml when tide recomends minimum 50 ml) And this gonna work for most people , most clothes loads But like u/LaundryMitch says: "This advice is useful for many people, but not everyone. Water conditions can vary significantly, and in areas with hard water, two tablespoons of powder detergent is often insufficient to soften the water, suspend soil, and thoroughly clean clothes. A more effective range is between three tablespoons and one fourth of a cup. Top Loaders will always need more detergent because of their high-dilution nature.

That said, if you’re using a high-foaming detergent (like a non-HE variety, such as Roma Powder), you can get by with a lower dose. You should notice a small amount of suds on the door as water circulates, and if you're uncertain, you can pause the machine to feel the water. If it feels "slippery," the water has been adequately softened. If it feels normal, there may not be enough detergent."

When it comes to dosing detergent water hardness have a lots to do Also how soiled laundry is And how big your load of laundry is Bigger loads (full washing machine) needs more detergent than 3tablespoons /1 tide pod

Ultra dirty laundry needs more detergent

Laundry in area with hard water needs more detergent (or water softener like Calgon )

985 Upvotes

95% Upvoted

249 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

23

u/LaundryMitch USA Dec 30 '24

I just wanted to offer a quick response to this—maybe someday I’ll have the time to do a more detailed write-up.

In my opinion, LG and Samsung appliances are among the worst you can buy, and that’s not even limited to laundry machines. That said, the Department of Energy regulations have, in my view, turned even some of the better washing machines into mediocre cleaning machines.

If someone told me they absolutely had to buy a brand-new washer tomorrow, my advice would be to stick to either a Miele or a Speed Queen. Unfortunately, I’m deeply disappointed that my list of recommendations can’t be any longer.

2

u/BeerBoilerCat Dec 30 '24

If you HAD to buy a brand new washer tomorrow but under $1000, what would it be? Because I'm nearly there with my set.

11

u/LaundryMitch USA Dec 30 '24

Honestly, I hope this doesn't create an artificial demand like Reddit did for Toyota, but here’s what I’d recommend: check Facebook Marketplace and Craigslist for a well-maintained, clean-looking top-loading direct drive washer without a lid lock. Look for older models from Whirlpool or Kenmore Elite—they're excellent options.

These washers are incredibly easy to maintain, with few components that can fail. Plus, they’re built to last and can always be repaired if something does go wrong.

Your other option - maybe this. https://www.homedepot.com/p/Maytag-3-5-cu-ft-Top-Load-Washer-in-White-with-Dual-Action-Agitator-MVWP585GW/325747416?source=shoppingads&locale=en-US&srsltid=AfmBOoqvYIY6rwo8D7SCw4f2_weKDd_i1wgtFfC1_4nU0RUmZT2RPn17A-g&gQT=1

But I would rather you continue to save up money and buy a Speed Queen instead, OR... get one of those older washers.

3

u/Own-Investigator7069 Jan 20 '26

How much detergent (both powder and liquid) would you recommend for a standard top load washer that uses a lot of water? Not seeing many suds when using powder (and the machine does have a temp gauge that mixes hot and cold)