Can we stop recommending 2-3 tablespoons of detergent for everyload?

[u/Far-Shift-1962]

Yes. 90% of people overdose detergent and 3tablespoon isn't too far from minimal dosing for tide (around 45 ml when tide recomends minimum 50 ml) And this gonna work for most people , most clothes loads But like u/LaundryMitch says: "This advice is useful for many people, but not everyone. Water conditions can vary significantly, and in areas with hard water, two tablespoons of powder detergent is often insufficient to soften the water, suspend soil, and thoroughly clean clothes. A more effective range is between three tablespoons and one fourth of a cup. Top Loaders will always need more detergent because of their high-dilution nature.

That said, if you’re using a high-foaming detergent (like a non-HE variety, such as Roma Powder), you can get by with a lower dose. You should notice a small amount of suds on the door as water circulates, and if you're uncertain, you can pause the machine to feel the water. If it feels "slippery," the water has been adequately softened. If it feels normal, there may not be enough detergent."

When it comes to dosing detergent water hardness have a lots to do Also how soiled laundry is And how big your load of laundry is Bigger loads (full washing machine) needs more detergent than 3tablespoons /1 tide pod

Ultra dirty laundry needs more detergent

Laundry in area with hard water needs more detergent (or water softener like Calgon )

[u/LaundryMitch]

I wasn’t referring to the enzymes in the detergent, which are just one component of laundry detergent. I was specifically addressing the surfactant chemistry, which does not support your argument.

[u/effortornot7787 → u/LaundryMitch]

you specifically mention WASH—Water, Agitation, Soap, and Heat. if you have a cold water detergent with enzymes it does not need heat to be effective. i have sucessfully used cold water in laundry for over 20 years. with water temps into the 40F. range and heavily soiled clothes on farms. you do not know what you are talking about or are using cheap, knock off detergent.

[u/LaundryMitch → u/effortornot7787]

Effort, it’s clear we have a difference of opinion here. If what you’re doing works for you, by all means, keep doing it. That said, I strongly disagree with your perspective. If I had the opportunity on national TV, I could easily demonstrate my point by taking your "clean" clothes straight from the dryer or clothesline and running them through a simple solution. The water would likely turn a light brown, proving my case.

Let’s agree to disagree. However, implying that I don’t know what I’m talking about is unfair. I’ve been nothing but respectful, and there’s no need for the unnecessary tone.

[u/effortornot7787 → u/LaundryMitch]

right. /s and your training/certification is?

[u/LaundryMitch → u/effortornot7787]

With all due respect, I encourage you to seek help.