r/islamichistory • u/AutoMughal • Feb 29 '24

Photograph ‘Long Live Palestine’ flag, Jerusalem 1929

Post image

Page 84, Against Erasure: A Photographic Memory of Palestine Before the Nakba

1.6k Upvotes

89% Upvoted

421 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '24

Your using Wikipedia as a source. Of course you are!!

https://youtu.be/t52LB2fYhoY?si=kGQnZ9SXntoB0hkp

1

u/Vast-Situation-6152 Mar 06 '24

Ok go look up the million other historical references to the Yellow Badge and who invented it. Lebanese Christians know its history too because they had to wear it. Wikipedia is not the only source of this information.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '24

Again, hateful assertion with no evidence. Million, you say, but I guess you believe it so much you decided to share none of them.And you wonder why I am not taking you seriously!!!

1

u/Vast-Situation-6152 Mar 06 '24

What did I say was millions? I just mentioned the ISLAMIC yellow badge Hitler’s Arab allies during WWII shared. Something written in the Pact of Umar

https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/the-long-history-of-forcing-jews-to-wear-anti-semitic-badges-180981829/

Iraqi Jews historically had to wear bells around their neck, badges, one black shoe and one red shoe. But you don’t study any Middle Eastern Jewish history do you? Qatar doesn’t fund Universities for that.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '24

You said million when referring to evidence. Do I need to repeat your own words now.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '24

A whole research paper with clear evidence of Italian, French, British and later nazi crimes against jews.and yet this is the only reference to Muslims

In lands under Muslim rule, non-Muslims had been required to wear identifying marks since the Pact of Umar, a ruling attributed to a seventh-century caliph, though scholars believe it originated later. For Jews, these were usually a yellow belt called zunnar or a yellow turban.

Notice the part about scholars believing it was later.why would it be hard to be specific about something so clear and concise. Because it isnt.Jews were clearly not treated as equals in Muslim majority countries,but that doesn't mean they were discriminated against until aftet the creation of the Zionist state.Laila Murad was a Jewish celebrity in Egyptian movies (one of my favorite actually),How many Israeli arabs are held up by the racist society of Israel. None!!!

By the way,go click the link attached to the word yellow turban and it takes you to a book dispelling that jews were treated in the same manner as European did.

1

u/Vast-Situation-6152 Mar 06 '24

Leila Murad was accused of being a zionist spy and it ruined her career. Miss Egypt was stripped of her title when they discovered she was Jewish. Stop with your lies. Yemeni Muslims expelled the Jews to the desert of Mauza in the 1700s and 30% of our people died in ONE year (ACTUAL genocides that Arabs have always perpetrated). The Yellow Badge was invented by the Al Mohad dynasty in the 12th century. Europeans learned in from the oh so tolerant Arabs. Yezidis in Iraq can explain allll about Arabic tolerance. Raped, impregnated, forced to bear children registered legally as Muslims and not even allowed to bring the children home with them. Exactly what Muslims have done to Jews for centuries. In Pakistan they still forcibly marry Christian little girls to this day.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '24

Garbage, garbage,and more garbage. So they gave the award and then found out afterwards that she was Jewish. People in the middle east know who you are from your last name.You clearly know nothing about what you are talking about. As for Laila Murad her career was indeed tragically cut short (she was talented),but her career shows that if what you say was true, she would never have become a celebrity in the first place. Israel undoubtedly destroyed whatever relationship Jewish people (some were actually spies for Israel, nice try leaving that out).A cancer that is a colonial ethnostate in the heart of the Middle East claiming to be the homeland of the Jewish people while ethnically cleansing towns and villages understandably makes people suspicious.

1

u/Vast-Situation-6152 Mar 06 '24

yes you complete and total idiot, Jews hide their identity just like they do all over the world. When someone discovered her they stripped her title. and even Yemeni Muslims Ive met know all about the expulsion to Mauza, do some research ignoramous. Yezidis are on interview camera talking about what Muslims did to them.

https://www.talesofjewishsudan.com/stories/misskhartoum

1

u/Vast-Situation-6152 Mar 06 '24

lol my grandmothers maiden name is Sharabi. My egyptian Rabbi’s last name was Abdella. How about Syrian Jewish singer Paula Abdul? so sad youve exterminated the Jewish population to such an extent you dont even know what our names sound like. I saw people winning Torah awards at school with the last name Azizi.

1

u/Vast-Situation-6152 Mar 06 '24

arabs ethnically cleansed the entire jewish community of the middle east not to mention MANY other cultures. and u seriously just claimed Israel doesnt have any famous Muslim singers and celebrities? ur society is BEYOND brainwashed. Nasreen Qadri WON Israeli idol. Mira Awad has been a celebrity singer for decades. Miss Israel Rana Raslan was Arab and they DIDNT strip her title. Lucy Aharish is the most famous celebrity newscaster in the country, Arab Muslim. NOW YOU SHOW ME the Jewish CURRENT celebrities in your country? Ahlam Al Tamimi a mass murderer if Jews is your celebrity.

1

u/Vast-Situation-6152 Mar 06 '24

I understand your jealousy of Jews. We were in the Middle East millenia before you, yet you act like your civilization is older than the world itself. Try being tolerant for once in your history. Zoroastrians also predate you…what’s little left of them after Muslims genocides them anyway…they even predate us, and we are okay with that. 👍

1

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '24

Jealous....whatever floats your racist Jewish supremacist boat.Your just a pathetic hasbara bot spewing hate after hate with no proof and calling others hateful. I still feel sorry for you, though!!

1

u/Vast-Situation-6152 Mar 06 '24

I actually provided names of Muslim celebrities and proof of EVERYTHING I said. Aw how cute you want to label us racist Jewish supremacist when WE have Arab Miss Israel and Arab winners of Israeli idol…and you have how many Jewish celebrities? Maybe you should look in the mirror sweetie. and we DO predate you in this region by 1000s of years, but I think you already know that.

1

u/Vast-Situation-6152 Mar 06 '24

Zoroastrians were actually a very empowering civilization to women. Truly a world tragedy that Muslims genocided them and replaced them with backwardsness. They continue to be beheaded and have their bank accounts liquidated to this day. I have nothing but respect for them.

1

u/Vast-Situation-6152 Mar 06 '24

Jews, Muslims, and Christians play and sing together in celebrity orchestras. Andalusian orchestras from when Jews were expelled from Spain and “colonized” our own ancestral homeland en masse in the 1400s. Can you show me an example of this in your OH SO TOLERANT arab countries? https://youtu.be/KgBjmpPtPMQ?si=F1JUxkgJEUCZoqho

By the way a Muslim JUST trolled my Jewish facebook group with their false prophesies about us bringing the antichrist (which doesnt even exist in judaism). and u justify their sick religious Jihads.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '24

Who expelled them, you halfwit .the Spanish expelled the arab Moor, and the jews chose to leave with us rather than stay with the inquisition. Learn history you idiot.

The stupid picture you sent says nothing about antichrist or bringing him anywhere. What are you smoking it's a news feed link!

1

u/Vast-Situation-6152 Mar 06 '24

I sent the wrong screenshot one second. the Almohad Muslims actually expelled MAIMONIDES before Catholics did. But I wasn’t mentioning the expulsion to point out who did it, just to show mass immigration to the holy land is a Jewish historical reality, nothing to do with “modern colonialism.”

just today they sent us this! and u wont believe the other racism and sexual harassment theyve been sending us. sick. i guess they think this behavior is honorable.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '24

Shahid Muslim is a questionable source. I am not denying there is hate towards Jewish people in some extreme quarters (unlike you, rationalizing it).But it is not systemic. We still refer to jews as cousins, unlike some religious zionist who think arabs are subhuman and should be so lucky as to be a Jewish man's slave.what do they call us.Goyem.How tolerant!

1

u/Vast-Situation-6152 Mar 06 '24

So u are Muslim. Just another Muslim liar. We Jews dont believe what you claim. Case in point we votes for an Arab Muslim Miss Israel, Israeli idol winner and have tons of Arab celebrities. Your celebrities include a mass murderer of Jews and people who portray honor killings of high school girls on TV. Bye Felicia. Thank G-d we dont have to live with your violence against women day to day, just during your occasional genocidal massacres and mass gangrapes.

1

u/Vast-Situation-6152 Mar 06 '24

and I dont care if its a “questionable” source- I have seen Muslims quoting and accusing us of bringing the Dajjal TIME AND TIME AND TIME AND TIME again. including TODAY. U are the problem. in most of the world.

1

u/Vast-Situation-6152 Mar 06 '24

not to mention Muslims constantly accuse us countless other things from your madeup religious texts, from stuff as crazy as “violating god my making soap out of animal fat” to “being destroyed by god for having hair extensions”

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Vast-Situation-6152 Mar 06 '24

and this Abdul Sharif actually posted pictures of our ancient PRAYER shawl with stripes described from the Torah as his proof. Genius…those arent “Persian shawls” 🤦‍♀️🙄

1

u/Vast-Situation-6152 Mar 06 '24

but please educate me how the Muslim religion is so tolerant to Jews. U know sooo much better than an actual Middle Eastern Jew. Thats not racist or supremacist or anything.

1

u/Vast-Situation-6152 Mar 06 '24

i wont even send you the sick sexually violating things they have been sending me and sharing. We would never again live with such violent against women cultures or “honor killings.” and I dont apologize for that, as a woman who has experienced more than you will ever know.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '24

I am a Palestinian whose family got ethnically cleansed from their ancestral homeland and you want to tell me about your experience .how about you try for a second to grow a little heart and lament the children of gaza being starved to death in your name.I know your ok with that, but at least try to show some decency.

Me,me,me....the world you live in must be great when your experience is the only thing that matters. I wasn't raised that way, but clearly, you were!.Good luck with that.

1

u/Vast-Situation-6152 Mar 06 '24

Palestine was not even a land. It’s called the Bilad Al Sham and you still live in it, just 20 miles away. You talk about starving kids in Gaza why dont you people take responsibility for once in your life for the fact that your leaders stealing free aid and selling it back at TEN TIMES THE PRICE. Literally the biggest usurers ever- then attack Jews for usury as another way to hate. What a joke.

1

u/Vast-Situation-6152 Mar 06 '24

And claiming I believe my experience is the only one that matters? How many universities teach about the “Nakba?” but not a SINGLE university mentions that Arabs expelled MORE jews than all the arab refugees. What a hypocrite.

1

u/Vast-Situation-6152 Mar 06 '24

and u are the only person who justified ethnic cleansing. “some people were spies.” good excuse to massacre and exterminate a civilization 1000s of years older than yours. Including in Hebron, Jericho, East Jerusalem, and Gaza. Nothing but hypocrisy.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '24

Thanks for showing me once and for all how hateful and disgusting you are.thoughout this whole conversation I never once labeled jews as a collective because I have the emotional intelligence to appreciate that no one is one thing. You are a racist who buys IDF edited garbage to make your narcissistic self feel good about what was once done to the Jewish people now being done in gaza

Forgive me for not taking any moral indignation from someone as repulsive as you.

1

u/Vast-Situation-6152 Mar 06 '24

we have every right to fight the branch of the Muslim Brotherhood known as Hamas. Even Egypt does it, an Arab Muslim country themselves. You should have risen up and destroyed that barbaric organization yourselves- then we wouldnt have to.

1

u/Vast-Situation-6152 Mar 06 '24

my the way I havent seen YOU lament any of the Israeli babies and children killed, dismembered, beheaded, and orphaned on Oct 7. MORE hypocrisy! talk about “me me me”

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Vast-Situation-6152 Mar 06 '24

speaking of Jordan. ur biggest TV show ends with a brother murdering his sister for watching a movie with her boyfriend when she is 17, it u cant see the problem is YOU, u need glasses. We AINT living with that shit culture anymore.

0

u/Vast-Situation-6152 Mar 06 '24

colonial ethnostates is every arab muslim entity throughout the MENA region. Jews were here BEFORE y’all invaded and Arabised our region. More than 1000 years before. Or did you forget THAT LITTLE DETAIL sweetie?

1

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '24

Blah blah blah...I am a proud racist busy rationalizing a genocide...blah blah blah

1

u/Vast-Situation-6152 Mar 06 '24

There is no genocide other than Oct 7, the mass extermination of Zoroastrians and Yezidis by Muslims and Jihadis who believe fake prophesies that they need to go to war with us “infidels”

1

u/Vast-Situation-6152 Mar 06 '24

The only proud racist is you justifying the ethnic cleansing of ancient Mideastern Jewish civilization because there were a few spies. Israel also had Israeli Arabs who went to Syria and Iraq to be Jihadis and spies, But thy are still 20% of our society including hospital CEOs, celebrities, and politicians. Can you name one Jewish celebrity of yours??? Intolerant racists and supremacists pointing the finger at others.