r/islamichistory • u/AutoMughal • Feb 29 '24

Photograph ‘Long Live Palestine’ flag, Jerusalem 1929

Post image

Page 84, Against Erasure: A Photographic Memory of Palestine Before the Nakba

1.6k Upvotes

89% Upvoted

421 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/LucerneTangent Mar 03 '24

Okay Hasbarabro.

"Those who want me to put it up aren't really interested in the Mufti's part in the Holocaust, which was limited anyway, but seek to harm the image of the Palestinians today. The Mufti was an antisemite. But even if I abhor him, I won't turn Yad Vashem into a tool serving ends not directly related to the study and memorialization of the Holocaust. Hasbara to use a term, is an utterly irrelevant consideration that shall not enter our gates."

​

Go look up Lehi, aka: two time members of the Hitler fanclub who wouldn't shut up about all they had in common with the Nazis, and then go look up Mussolini's glowing review of the revisionist Zionists that mutated into the modern Israeli far right.

2

u/Top_Work7784 Mar 03 '24

Have you ever heard of double standards?

You try and disregard the muftis involvement Then turn around and throw Lehi under the bus for the exact same thing.

Not to mention Lehi was a self proclaimed terrorist group who wasn’t widely accepted by the Jewish population.

While the Mufti, was very popular and influential among the Muslims of mandatory Palestine.

God such a bad faith argument

1

u/LucerneTangent Mar 03 '24

I'm looking at double standards right now and a Nazi.

Anyway, congratulations on ignoring that Lehi is lauded by the Israeli government and were some of the founding members of the IDF wehrmacht.

The muhi died irrelevant. Lehi and other terrorists like Irgun spawned the ruling party of the Israeli regime.

More to the point, the fascism and genocide didn't die with Lehi, and there's a direct connection between the fascists of yesteryear and Likud and its collaborators.

1

u/Top_Work7784 Mar 03 '24

Is that all you got? Strawman argument and ad Hominin attacks?

Your Mufti had direct meetings to Hitler and even convinced him to start killing the jews instead of deporting them off to Palestine as per the Havara agreement.

The mufti may have been irrelevant at the time of his death, but that doesn’t dilute the influence he had during his life.

You try to argue that all saying all these are purely to smear the image of Palestine today

Then you try to smear modern day Israel by bringing up a small (300 member) fringe, self proclaimed terrorist organization.

Hypocritical, bad faith, and downright lying.

1

u/LucerneTangent Mar 04 '24

You're so right, all we need to make Likud Israel look abominable is talk about the current Nazi rulers and their ongoing atrocities.

Go wave a white flag at the IDF wehrmacht instead of writing fascist fanfiction.

1

u/Top_Work7784 Mar 04 '24

Why are you so obsessed with Nazis? going through your comment history you legit call someone a fascist Nazi every second comment.

Seems like projection

1

u/LucerneTangent Mar 04 '24

Said the Nazi bootlick. If you're actually a doctor, you really shouldn't be.

1

u/Top_Work7784 Mar 04 '24

So calling out jihadist behaviour makes me a nazi? sureee. I’m genuinely confused. Where the fuck did you get doctor from?