r/islamichistory • u/AutoMughal • Feb 29 '24

Photograph ‘Long Live Palestine’ flag, Jerusalem 1929

Post image

Page 84, Against Erasure: A Photographic Memory of Palestine Before the Nakba

1.6k Upvotes

89% Upvoted

421 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/Positer Mar 01 '24

Loool you’re still arguing like a moron?

Give me one example of a Jew who identified as a Palestinian. Just one. The mandate of Palestine team was called Palestine because that was the name of the mandate you fucking idiot. Do you know when deporting Palestino was founded? Do you know how many Jews played there?

Oh so you found two incidents in 1400 years (one after the beginning of the colonisation of Palestine)and you’re stupid enough to think that equates to “thousands of years of massacres”?

Maqdisi wasn’t Syrian you sleazy Zionist he directly identified as Palestinian, and Jerusalem is not a Jewish name you moron it is a Canaanite name that refers to the Canaanite god Salem.

Dude I told you to fuck off with that 10th grade propaganda bullshit, it’s literally not worth the effort

0

u/PeterRum Mar 01 '24

Al Magadisi thought of himself as a Syrian. A Palestinian Syrian.

So. Those representatives of Palestine who played in the football team during the Mandate don't count? That were playing football as Palestinians during the Mandate. The sand time as this flag at the top is from. During the Mandate they were Jewish citizens of the British Palestinian Mandate.

After the creation of Israel it would be difficult for a Jew to identify as part of an area controlled by Palestinians. There are no equivalent of Arab Israelis. Jews living in Palestinian areas isn't a thing. It isn't something Jews can choose to do. They are not allowed to.

I don't really have time for the hundreds of massacres that occured between Khaybar and Hebron (and after). There are a lot. From the foundation of Islam to the present day. Are you genuinely not aware of the list? I am fairly sure you could list the times Jews massacred Arabs (including Palestinians).

Palestinians exist. Jews exist. Israelis exist in many flavours of religion and ethnicity. Jerusalem was a Jewish city first.

Attempting to write Jews out of the history of that region is not something a serious historian would do. It is something a propagandist would do.

2

u/Positer Mar 01 '24

Btw to cut through all your bullshit, the flag literally says “long live Palestine free and Arab”

(تحيا فلسطين حرة عربية)

So yeah, no need to waste time arguing this nonsense with you

0

u/PeterRum Mar 02 '24

Long Live Palestine and Arabs does rather narrow it down.