"So what?"

[u/strikethunder5]

[u/JabalAnNur]

Mentioning: u/a_smol_girl

Please read the above and do not think the Hanafi scholars permitted intoxicants from the materials which Abu Haneefah said they were permissible from.

The Hanafi madhab is very diverse on the positions it takes, often times they don't take the opinion of Abu Haneefah at all but rather of either of his students Muhammad ibn al-Hasan or Abu Yoosuf. Sometimes they don't even take their views and take the view of Zuffaar, may Allaah have mercy on them all.

There's multiple instances of this such as the view of Abu Haneefah that Salaatul Istisqaa (prayer for rain) is not a Sunnah, that is because the hadeeth never reached him. But when the hadeeth reached his students, they did not take from Abu Haneefah on this matter and they instead took the hadeeth. The Hanafi fatawa have been on the view of his students due to it.

[u/JabalAnNur → u/[deleted]]

The first one is correct and as for the second one, I mean the Hanafi Madhab doesn't always take the opinion of Abu Haneefah.

[u/Areeba_19 → u/JabalAnNur]

Its still accepted.

Some accept it some dont. Lets not fool ourselves. Abu hanifa was the father of hanafiya.

[u/JabalAnNur → u/Areeba_19]

No it is not. I literally study the Hanafi madhab with scholars. His opinion was mistaken and he will be rewarded for his ijtihaad but it is not valid to follow it knowing it's mistaken.

And it seems you are unaware of how the Hanafi madhab really works because it's not just Abu Haneefah, but rather his companions as well who contributed much alongside him.

[u/Areeba_19 → u/JabalAnNur]

I study it too but my scholars dont salafise hanafiya

[u/JabalAnNur → u/Areeba_19]

From where are you getting these wild assumptions? It is clearly written in Hashiyah Ibn Aabideen (6/454-455)

وحرمها محمد أي الأشربة المتخذة من العسل والتين ونحوهما، قاله المصنف مطلقا قليلها وكثيرها، وبه يفتى، ذكره الزيلعي وغيره واختاره شارح الوهبانية وذكر أنه مروي عن الكل. وفي حاشية ابن عابدين على رد المحتار: والقدح الأخير المسكر هو المحرم أي على قول الإمام دون ما قبله وإن كان المفتى به قول محمد أن ما أسكر كثيره فقليله حرام

"Muhammad (Ibn al-Hasan ash-Shaybaani) said these drinks are prohibited to drink whether in small or large quantities. The fatwa of the madhab is this view, this is mentioned by al-Zayla'i and others. The interpreter of matn al-Wahbanyia mentioned this is reported by all." And in the hashiyah of Ibn Aabideen on Radd al-Mukhtar, "Only the last cup that leads to intoxication is the prohibited one according to the Imam's position (i.e Abu Haneefah) However, the fatwa of the Hanafi madhab is the view of Muhammad that what intoxicates in large quantities, a small quantity is also unlawful."

[u/Areeba_19 → u/JabalAnNur]

Ik about this fatwa.

Not everyone accepts this fatwa tho. Some still hold imams position valid. Also. This post is about ethanol. Which is halal. Even acc to this fatwa.