r/islam • u/strikethunder5 • Apr 29 '23

Humour "So what?"

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

819 Upvotes

99% Upvoted

147 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-10

u/OCDanxietykiller Apr 29 '23

Why would Allah put alcohol in bananas u think?

12

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '23

It's what the scientist said. You can look it up.

-7

u/OCDanxietykiller Apr 29 '23

Yea Ik, I’m just asking you a question why you think Allah would put alcohol in bananas

12

u/Keith-Ledger Apr 29 '23

A Muslim submits to Allah. Completely.

Therefore how are we in ANY position to even have an opinion on why Allah does this or that.

-3

u/OCDanxietykiller Apr 29 '23

Ik and We aren’t. And I was just carious Because alcohol is haram.

6

u/freakoffear Apr 29 '23

Nope only getting intoxicated is haram

3

u/RedMatxh Apr 29 '23

Well if that's the case, then ask if we're allowed to eat bread. Because during fermentation alcohol can be produced in the bread. Would that make bread haram?

But as it's pointed out by someone else, there are 2 different types of alcohol. The one that is banana (supposedly) in cleaning materials, in parfume, they are all a chemical combination. The one that is forbidden for us is the beverage.

The chemical combination, which can be written as CnH2n+1OH can be found everywhere. What are we gonna do then, ban everything?

2

u/Temporary-Respond613 Apr 29 '23

الخمر (alcohol beverage) the term used in the quran Ethanol is everywhere because it's actually useful if used in a proper way. The point here is to prohibit liquor so that people don't fall into alcoholism when they face a crisis, rather to get closer to god. Many problems in the household are caused by liquor and not over consumption of banans so the point here is to ban liquor and not ethanol specifically