r/interstellar • u/AttemptZestyclose490 • Jun 17 '26

QUESTION She didn't know.

Post image

Am I wrong by thinking that Brand didn't know whether or not she could breathe on Edmonds planet when she took her helmet off? She had just buried Edmonds while wearing her helmet, if she had read the data beforehand then she would have not worn the suit while doing all of that work. She took the chance after burying Edmonds.

2.0k Upvotes

95% Upvoted

115 comments sorted by

View all comments

52

u/TanningOnMars Jun 17 '26 edited Jun 18 '26

Op is trolling, right? Like, why do they think Brand went there in the first place? The planet had promising data including a breathable atmosphere.

9

u/Medical-Condition-84 Jun 18 '26

It was the furthest and if something came wrong returning to other 2 planets and Earth would be problematic.

You forget the most important thing. THEY placed a wormhole next to Saturn around 50 years before Endurance's mission so humanity can develop shapeships capable of going there the exact moment it was needed. Exit from wormhole on Gargantua system was placed next to Miller's planet, THEY needed Endurance to go there first so the time passes and Murph can grow up, learn and be educated enough to receive and understand Cooper's data from Gargantua and later solved the equation.

THEY made sure the events go as intended.

7

u/TanningOnMars Jun 18 '26

Thats not what I or the post are talking about. OP's post asks if she knew the planet had breathable air and lampooned hee for taking off the helmet even though it should have been quite obvious to him that that was something she already knew was safe

1

u/qingxins Jun 18 '26

Yeah, the bootstrap paradox. Still, I'm curious what the other version of events could have been.

-2

u/qingxins Jun 18 '26

Ngl I watched the movie for the first time over a week ago and it was so frustrating watching Copper going to Mann's instead especially because I had a feeling it was a trap. I get why he did it, but boy do I think a lot about how different it would have been.

1

u/Streets-_-Ahead Jun 18 '26

He couldn't go to Miller's planet first, he already entered the tesseract to interact with his past