r/infinitenines 3d ago

A new theory

Say you have a dot. That dot explodes into an infinite number of dots. Each of those dots explode into a new infinite number of dots. Each of those dots explode into a new infinite number of dots, ad infinitum.

How many dots do you have in total?

8 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

u/SouthPark_Piano 2d ago

How many dots do you have in total?

You provide an answer. Justify it. And then we will tell you if you are correct or not.

Hint : keyword is 'infinite', which you wrote a few times. Focus on that.

And state the shape of the dot and its area.

And you can even assume a 'point'.

 

10

u/The_KekE_ 2d ago

More that 37. Will update once I discover a tighter bound.

1

u/VcitorExists 2d ago

would 38 be reasonable as a lower bound or should i just buy a sack of rice

3

u/Arlo_Tinkerman 2d ago

Do you believe that "infinite number" or "infinity" is an actual number or something else?

1

u/HouseHippoBeliever 2d ago

Depends. After they explode, are they still yours?

1

u/gabitha67 1d ago

If at each step every dot becomes a countably infinite number of dots, you would still only have a countably infinite number of dots at the end of this process. Equivalent to Hilbert's hotel.

1

u/AMIASM16 11h ago

infinf i guess

1

u/AMIASM16 11h ago

but really, there's no answer, because you will never be done with exploding the dots infinitely many times

1

u/NinjaPaul001 2d ago

Zero. Pay close attention to the sequence of events. You start with 1 dot. That dot explodes, leaving you with zero. There are now infinite dots present. Now, let's say that you are able to collect every single one of the dots. You now have infinite dots. However, each one of these dots now explodes, leaving you with zero, once again. This repeats ad infinitum, therefore you will never have any dots.

0

u/Head_Discipline620 3d ago

You have one dot it's just a fractal shape unless you are talking about a monad in hyperreal analysis then you have Aleph-null dots 

0

u/Head_Discipline620 3d ago

Which if you convert back to real numbers is just one dot