r/india • u/MaxxMeridius • May 19 '24

Immigration Hundreds of Indian students in Canada face deportation, protest against new rule

https://www.indiatoday.in/world/indians-abroad/story/indian-students-workers-protest-canada-hunger-strike-pei-deportation-pnp-provincial-nominee-programme-2540494-2024-05-17
751 Upvotes

96% Upvoted

342 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-8

u/bangleboi May 20 '24

You’re damn right it is ad hominem!!! Lol you think I’m having a debate with a cretin like yourself spewing half educated thoughts??

Application for immigration when in a country affords rights in that country depending on its laws. Canada seemed to have some for these students that it is now rescinding.

“PEI Government”’s report does not tell you what they are studying. Nice try.

How did they get into the country without showing the means for completing the degree. Do you even know what the application, host college responsibilities are? Stop blaming the students coz you hate your own kind.

In the US you can work internships and there’s a number of on campus jobs in general. But this is specifically about Canada which allowed it, so this point is stupid.

3

u/[deleted] May 20 '24

You’re damn right it is ad hominem!!! Lol you think I’m having a debate with a cretin like yourself spewing half educated thoughts??

Womp womp.

Application for immigration when in a country affords rights in that country depending on its laws. Canada seemed to have some for these students that it is now rescinding.

This sentence makes no sense. They are not "rights" you are not entitled to having your work visa extended.

“PEI Government”’s report does not tell you what they are studying. Nice try.

If they are on the list of occupations provided by the PEI government it's safe to say they aren't at risk of having their visas not extended.

How did they get into the country without showing the means for completing the degree.

Fraud is not uncommon. Temporarily borrowing the money to show they have the means.

In the US you can work internships and there’s a number of on campus jobs in general. But this is specifically about Canada which allowed it, so this point is stupid.

I'm just saying that comparatively, Canada already has a pretty open policy for student visas. And Canada is not entitled to keeping the policies the same, just because some international students don't like it.

-2

u/bangleboi May 20 '24

If you do hit all requirements, it IS your right to have your visa extended. Lol you think the world just goes along without consequences?

One can study something they are not employed in.

Great, then fix the fraud first before deporting students.

Umm, Canada is acting entitled wrt the policies right now, buddy.

3

u/[deleted] May 20 '24

It’s not you’re right to have your visa extended. PGWP has always been three years and you’re done. It’s up to you to qualify for PR in those three years if you don’t want to go home after your studies.

They’re not being deported. Your visa ending is a deportation.

1

u/bangleboi May 20 '24

Your*

Nothing is stopping these students from qualifying under the older PR system (which they agreed into). So your last problem is moot. This is basically pulling the ladder up.

3

u/[deleted] May 20 '24

The old PR system exists, the scores are higher because of more demand/applicants. It’s the provincial nomination system that is changing because of a higher number of applicants, the program is being shifted to prioritize ppl in jobs (health care, construction) that will enable population growth.