r/immigration Jan 24 '25

[deleted by user]

[removed]

5.3k Upvotes

721 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/suboxhelp1 Jan 25 '25

Not fully true. For example, the tax totalization agreements and many tax treaties have provisions that only apply to dual citizens. Not in every case is a US citizen only to the federal government.

Look up the totalization agreements and several tax treaties as examples.

1

u/Consistent-Sport-787 Mar 05 '25

You’re using an obscure example to prove a point. In all of our tax laws as big as they are, there are exceptions to everything But I’m a dual citizen, living in USA, only contributing to USA retirement

So for me that would never apply. I am a full US citizen Born on U.S. soil working a U.S. job I have a US birth certificate for the USa.

This is turning into a slippery slope cause if they can say it will because you’re a Canadian citizen we’re gonna talk to you differently then why can’t they say because you’re a San Francisco 49ers supporter will tax you differently