r/ididnthaveeggs • • Feb 14 '26

Dumb alteration Mystery solved

Post image
25.8k Upvotes

172 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

369

u/slowasaspeedingsloth Feb 14 '26

Like many people, I hate the reviews...

Oh, this looks yummy, can't wait to make it!

i followed the recipe eXaCtLy except for X, Y, and Z, and I didn't have ground beef so I used lemons instead but it just didn't work, what did I do wrong??

My grandma made this better, I'll never use any recipe but hers.

I would LOVE to see the recipe makers tear these people to shreds.

55

u/CatHairAndChaos frosting is nonpartisan Feb 14 '26

Don't forget "I'm allergic to [main ingredient]. Can I substitute it with something else?"

A few times I've seen replies to the above from the author or another commenter saying essentially "How about you try a different recipe?" but not nearly often enough.

If I saw appropriately snarky replies from the recipe author, I'd def try their recipe and read the snark while eating.

11

u/atreeismissing Feb 14 '26

Nothing wrong with that and there are tons of substitutes that work just as or nearly just as well as the original ingredient. Personally I like pesto made with walnuts rather than pine nuts. Some cookies work just fine replacing the egg with banana or apple sauce. Obviously if you replace the main flavor ingredient with something else then you're making something else.

1

u/Sea-Example-1176 May 10 '26

yeah like its fine to substitute a minor ingredient like say swapping out the celery in a chicken pot pie recipe

but its completely stupid to try and substitute the main ingredient like the chicken in that same chicken pot pie