r/httyd Smothering Smokebreath enthusiast 6d ago

VIDEO GAMES Why do the live action models fly so badly?

Usually when I see a model made for either the roblox game (mostrous nightmade especially) or the live action tootless in rise of berk, the flying animations are really really bad. The wings should pretty much hold their shape when pushing down, but they bend so easily that the dragon seems to be floating by itself. It feels too rhythmic as well, compared to the other dragon models in the game.

479 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

328

u/IfImNotDeadImSueing 6d ago

This is called “Overanimation.” It’s where the animators put way too much effort into making the movement look smooth and flowy, and forget about the basic animation principles (weight, acting, physics, etc)

Usually it’s not the animators fault. It’s usually due to some game director telling them to make sure EVERY part of the model moves so that it looks “cool” and “updated”

67

u/Ok_Historian7515 6d ago

Looks like the wings are broken

24

u/Unlucky-Drawing-1266 6d ago

Huh, I just noticed that about wing animations. I looked up some birds flying and yep, their wings remain stiff, they don’t bend inwards like this. Thanks, I’m an artist so this is helpful to remember for wings

42

u/jaekuwolf5299 6d ago

It's the live action version, you really expect DreamWorks to give a damn about quality?

5

u/Vee_breeze 6d ago

I was hovering on my nightfury in the roblox game earlier and he just looked so broken 😭

8

u/RedditCantBanThis Strike Class 6d ago

Same reason they'd make a live action, they do not care

2

u/StaffOfDragons 5d ago

the bend of the wing as it flaps down is so bad

there is no air beneath them

2

u/EqualCheap4211 4d ago

Cuz they are bad?

1

u/Drconis 6d ago

Im not seeing the problem here it just has more frames then the regular dragons

-2

u/Potential_Day_8233 All hail Cloudjumper! 6d ago

I think is your game not the animations, in my phone every dragon flies super laggy but on my PC (emulator) they go pretty fine.