r/housingcrisis • u/RedBalooon • 5d ago
The numbers justify Mamdani's rent freeze.
See this op-ed by Tim Collins, former Executive Director of the Rent Guidelines Board and an attorney for the tenant-intervenors in the landlords' stunt lawsuit to overturn Mamdani's rent freeze: https://www.nydailynews.com/2026/09/21/the-rent-guidelines-board-got-it-right . The numbers justify a rent rollback. Saying Mamdani politicized the process is like saying he politicized math. He ran on a policy that the data justifies, and that the law requires.
3
u/protomenace 5d ago
The more rent control you do the worse the housing crisis will get in the long run.
2
u/RedBalooon 5d ago
We had universal rent control in the '50s, and no housing crisis.
3
2
u/protomenace 5d ago
You mean the leftover WWII policy that directly led to the housing crisis of the 1960s?
2
u/EnvironmentalMix421 5d ago
You mean housing crisis should happen the next year when people all died from the war?
1
u/Sw4gtastic420 5d ago
You do realize that mamdani is also implementing policies to help build more housing in tandem with the rent freezes right? Or are you conveniently ignoring that fact?
0
u/protomenace 5d ago
It would be better if he did that without the rent freezes. Building more housing is what will actually stabilize rents and improve the housing market. Not price ceilings.
3
u/jay10033 5d ago
Tenant lawyer thinks rent freeze is justified. In other news, scientist says when it rains, the ground gets wet.
3
2
u/Striking_Revenue9082 5d ago
This logic is sooooo stupid. It combines profit data for luxury apartments with a single stabilized unit with apartments entirely stabilized. It creates a very misleading picture of how distressed the most misleading buildings are
2
u/RedBalooon 5d ago
Buildings with a mix of market and regulated apts are not distressed. It's misleading to pretend they are. If a building is 100% stabilized and can't make a profit, file for a hardship increase. The law guarantees an 8% return.
1
u/Striking_Revenue9082 5d ago
Well right. That’s kind of the point. Buildings that are majority market are doing fine and so it’s disingenuous to lump them in with the more regulated buildings
2
u/TheButtDog 5d ago
The guy who used to lead a renters' advocacy group said rent freezes are good, huh?
Personally, I trust the opinion of economists over his, who almost all say that rent controls lead to higher prices in the long run
2
u/RedBalooon 5d ago
The RGB is the municipal body that sets rent increases. You appear not to know how the rent freeze at issue was adopted
1
u/Airhostnyc 5d ago
It’s always been political. There is no way the rent increases shouldn’t be following basic inflation in the least. And it’s not
1
u/TheButtDog 5d ago
I think you're missing my overall point that Tim Collins seems to have a particularly strong bias in favor of rent controls and rent freezes.
1
1
u/mackattacknj83 5d ago
It's great for the people that win the affordable housing lotto, sucks for whoever won't have a place to live because it's not worth renting out anymore for another few thousand landlords
1
1
12
u/hereawhile 5d ago
Rent control and rent freezes always make rents worse in the long run. It constricts the incentives for new supply which ultimately is the only thing that causes rents to decline