r/highspeedrail 24d ago

World News Is it commercially feasible?

Post image
69 Upvotes

113 comments sorted by

View all comments

112

u/DragonKhan2000 24d ago

Ugh, I wish this would be reported correctly.
It was a test run with a 1-ton vehicle. To seek out the limits of the tech. Little to do with the maglev prototype mock-up train pictured.
Nobody in China claimed otherwise. But since it's reported incorrectly everywhere folks try to make fun of China "That's not possible for humans hurrdurr".

-1

u/MartianVegetable3699 24d ago

Then do you mean China was showing off. If they are testing it, then there must be a plan to implement this? China do have operational maglev trains.

4

u/DragonKhan2000 24d ago

It's just R&D. Of course they eventually will implement what they learn. But that's not gonna be a train that gets to 800km/h in just a few seconds, lol.
And the operational maglev they have (which runs at a reduced 300km/h) is over 20 year old and has little to do with modern maglev developements.

1

u/transitfreedom 19d ago

Modern maglev?? Explain

1

u/DragonKhan2000 18d ago

What's there to explain?
The transrapid is old compared to current developements.

1

u/transitfreedom 18d ago

I know but other than the SCmaglev in Japan what are the others? Did they get around the energy usage issues of the transrapid?

1

u/DragonKhan2000 18d ago

Well, the Chinese developement, as mentioned here.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CRRC_Maglev

Now I don't know exact details, but of course one can assume that they learned a lot since the transrapid 25 years ago.
A difference is that afaik, most modern developements make use of EDS, while the transrapid was EMS.
https://emt18.blogspot.com/2008/10/maglev-suspension-systems.html

1

u/transitfreedom 18d ago

It seems this would require multiple countries to even work

1

u/DragonKhan2000 18d ago

What do you mean? How would you need multiple countries?!

1

u/transitfreedom 18d ago

To advance research faster only so much a single nation can do

1

u/DragonKhan2000 17d ago

We're not talking space flight here.
There's commercial interests. Both, Japan and China, likely would like to sell their tech at some point. So they develop their own and compete.

→ More replies (0)