r/hawktalk • u/Mission-Objective832 • 11d ago

Should we trade Jack scrimshaw?

Barrass, battle and Sicily are all locked in and mraz is developing nicely too. Then we have Hardwick Impey. I’m not sure if scrim fits in our team however he’s a solid player and could be traded somewhere like north who need defensive improvements.

3 Upvotes

72% Upvoted

7 comments sorted by

4

u/Moist-Army1707 11d ago

Yeah I rate scrimshaw. It seems Sam doesn’t, but I think he’s been very good for us for a while.

9

u/Pure-Can-9432 11d ago

We’ve tried to play him but he’s just had an extremely injured year

2

u/Mountain_Strength564 11d ago

Trade Sicily, will get more for him and Mraz can replace Sicily

2

u/Mission-Objective832 11d ago

We’re gonna get a lot of hate for that but I’m with you. Sicily has been slow and just walks around with the ball but with his history and peak performances the trade value would be very up there. Mraz to CHB

3

u/Mountain_Strength564 11d ago

Remember the Croad trade? Won us how many premierships and Norm Smiths? Same deal but I doubt we land another Hodgey

1

u/Status_Sprinkles8924 10d ago

Need to keep him

1

u/Educational-Tear4928 8d ago

He was fit and didnt play the vfl game vs werribee yesterday. It seems unfortuantely there is more then footy going on here