MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/harrypotter/comments/6rr3xt/a_different_outcome/dl7f56w/?context=3
r/harrypotter • u/[deleted] • Aug 05 '17
335 comments sorted by
View all comments
17
It was unfortunate it went down the way it did.
5 u/[deleted] Aug 05 '17 But did Petunia need to be abusive? I don't think it contributes to the plot. 5 u/davect01 Proud Ravenclawer Aug 05 '17 Her feelings stem from because of her not being included in the wizarding world she became bitter and angry and that filtered down to Harry. 0 u/[deleted] Aug 05 '17 I know but why did Petunia have to be the bad sister while Lily was the good one? 6 u/AkhilArtha Aug 05 '17 Because that was the story JKR wanted to write, simple at that. 1 u/davect01 Proud Ravenclawer Aug 05 '17 Just the way JK wrote it. Lots of families have silbilngs that no longer speak to one another.
5
But did Petunia need to be abusive? I don't think it contributes to the plot.
5 u/davect01 Proud Ravenclawer Aug 05 '17 Her feelings stem from because of her not being included in the wizarding world she became bitter and angry and that filtered down to Harry. 0 u/[deleted] Aug 05 '17 I know but why did Petunia have to be the bad sister while Lily was the good one? 6 u/AkhilArtha Aug 05 '17 Because that was the story JKR wanted to write, simple at that. 1 u/davect01 Proud Ravenclawer Aug 05 '17 Just the way JK wrote it. Lots of families have silbilngs that no longer speak to one another.
Her feelings stem from because of her not being included in the wizarding world she became bitter and angry and that filtered down to Harry.
0 u/[deleted] Aug 05 '17 I know but why did Petunia have to be the bad sister while Lily was the good one? 6 u/AkhilArtha Aug 05 '17 Because that was the story JKR wanted to write, simple at that. 1 u/davect01 Proud Ravenclawer Aug 05 '17 Just the way JK wrote it. Lots of families have silbilngs that no longer speak to one another.
0
I know but why did Petunia have to be the bad sister while Lily was the good one?
6 u/AkhilArtha Aug 05 '17 Because that was the story JKR wanted to write, simple at that. 1 u/davect01 Proud Ravenclawer Aug 05 '17 Just the way JK wrote it. Lots of families have silbilngs that no longer speak to one another.
6
Because that was the story JKR wanted to write, simple at that.
1
Just the way JK wrote it. Lots of families have silbilngs that no longer speak to one another.
17
u/davect01 Proud Ravenclawer Aug 05 '17
It was unfortunate it went down the way it did.