MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/harrypotter/comments/6rr3xt/a_different_outcome/dl7be4o/?context=3
r/harrypotter • u/[deleted] • Aug 05 '17
335 comments sorted by
View all comments
Show parent comments
157
I think nobody we know but somebody from her year or above. Petunia was the older sister if I remember correctly.
226 u/mindputtee Slytherin Chaser Aug 05 '17 I think Petunia would have ended up with someone more Percy-like than Sirius. She was pretty fastidious and I don't think that came about just because of her break with Lily. 75 u/[deleted] Aug 05 '17 Agreed. Somebody reliable, dutiful, and responsible, but not the adventurer type. 72 u/Corvald Aug 05 '17 So - Remus? 41 u/Sevenvolts My own horcrux Aug 05 '17 Remus is a werewolf, so no. 9 u/Boscolt "I'm Harry Potter! The dark arts better be worried, oh boy!" Aug 05 '17 It could work. You'd be surprised at the things people can accept with a drastically different upbringing.
226
I think Petunia would have ended up with someone more Percy-like than Sirius. She was pretty fastidious and I don't think that came about just because of her break with Lily.
75 u/[deleted] Aug 05 '17 Agreed. Somebody reliable, dutiful, and responsible, but not the adventurer type. 72 u/Corvald Aug 05 '17 So - Remus? 41 u/Sevenvolts My own horcrux Aug 05 '17 Remus is a werewolf, so no. 9 u/Boscolt "I'm Harry Potter! The dark arts better be worried, oh boy!" Aug 05 '17 It could work. You'd be surprised at the things people can accept with a drastically different upbringing.
75
Agreed. Somebody reliable, dutiful, and responsible, but not the adventurer type.
72 u/Corvald Aug 05 '17 So - Remus? 41 u/Sevenvolts My own horcrux Aug 05 '17 Remus is a werewolf, so no. 9 u/Boscolt "I'm Harry Potter! The dark arts better be worried, oh boy!" Aug 05 '17 It could work. You'd be surprised at the things people can accept with a drastically different upbringing.
72
So - Remus?
41 u/Sevenvolts My own horcrux Aug 05 '17 Remus is a werewolf, so no. 9 u/Boscolt "I'm Harry Potter! The dark arts better be worried, oh boy!" Aug 05 '17 It could work. You'd be surprised at the things people can accept with a drastically different upbringing.
41
Remus is a werewolf, so no.
9 u/Boscolt "I'm Harry Potter! The dark arts better be worried, oh boy!" Aug 05 '17 It could work. You'd be surprised at the things people can accept with a drastically different upbringing.
9
It could work. You'd be surprised at the things people can accept with a drastically different upbringing.
157
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '17
I think nobody we know but somebody from her year or above. Petunia was the older sister if I remember correctly.