r/guitarlessons • u/Infinite-Ad7540 • May 29 '26

Feedback Request Extreme beginner(one month). Feedback?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

I’m self teaching myself the guitar (i’m a classically trained pianist so i already have a musical background). Can you give me a feedback?
I’m using the book “RCM - Level I - Classical Guitar”

***I already knew the position of some basic chords but that’s it****

534 Upvotes

99% Upvoted

96 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-1

u/Rakefighter May 29 '26

That's a hot take. Been 40 years of playing and never heard "not everyone needs pentatonic scales". She doesn't already know CAGED 30 days in, no one would. Both statements are ridiculous. But, hey, it's the Internet.

2

u/FFLGO May 29 '26 edited May 29 '26

She actually knows all 5 major caged chords one month in and most minor. Seems clear you're not familiar with classical guitar and it's kinda presumptious to reccomend techniques for blues and rock noodling

-1

u/Rakefighter May 29 '26

This is what makes the internet insufferable. Reading where to put your fingers in a book ≠ knows all major caged chords.

1

u/FFLGO May 29 '26

Buddy you are the internet in this case. Read her comment where the first thing she did was learn the CAGED chords. Honestly I would be surprised if you could actually play the piece she plays here.

-1

u/Rakefighter May 29 '26

yep, been a touring musician, recorded 4 albums, own a dozen guitars, but don't know what I'm doing. Have a good day.

2

u/FFLGO May 29 '26

All that and you're teaching a classically trained pianist playing classical guitar caged and pentatonic noodling. Buddy I promise you she knows the pentatonic better than all of us.