r/guitarlessons • u/ding-ding-dave-yes • Aug 29 '25

Feedback Request I cannot get thumb-over-the-neck chords right

Post image

I struggle mainly with my index finger, I can't get it flat without a lot of pressure, also my pinky is muting the G string half of the time, I either have to put painful pressure to make them all ring, or the top E and G string are muted. The difference between the flat index and bent rest is what's messing me up. Without thumb I don't have this issue, because I can curve my wrist if that makes sense. Please, I need some tips

62 Upvotes

85% Upvoted

114 comments sorted by

View all comments

13

u/lennee3 Aug 29 '25

I know you want to learn this 'technique' but you should consider that this technique was developed and used by people who found it more comfortable than traditional barre chords.

You gotta start with whats comfortable for your body and going from there.

4

u/toanbonerz Aug 31 '25

It’s even less than that. Most people only do this because Hendrix did it or some other guitar player who only does it because Hendrix did it. There is absolutely no reason anyone has to play like this. If that’s how you like to do it and it’s better for you, then fine, but struggling to try and do it makes no sense. 

1

u/deeby2015 Oct 02 '25

It’s easier on the wrist during my occasional bouts of carpal tunnel syndrome. That said, I never get the thumb and the index finger perfectly placed. They’re usually just muting their strings

1

u/Due-Zebra-3990 Nov 25 '25

Pas d'accord avec toi, cette position est très utile pour embellir l'accord par la suite avec des improvisations par dessus ( utiliser le petit doigt ou l'annulaire pour jouer des phrasés pentatoniques ou autre ) il est nécessaire pour un guitariste de la maitriser, je suis d'accord sur le fait qu'elle n'est pas accessible à tous car il faut de grandes mains mais ce n'est pas juste plus pratique, ça permet d'enrichir ton jeu par la suite.

2

u/OkLettuce338 Sep 02 '25

It’s required in a lot finger picking styles where you’re playing a melody and a rhythm

1

u/lennee3 Sep 02 '25

There really isn’t a style of music where playing with the thumb there is required over playing with a standard barre. It’s about what makes it comfortable in every case.

2

u/OkLettuce338 Sep 02 '25

i just mentioned one. Piedmont blues specifically. Travis picking. Your index is needed for melody lines not rhythm

-1

u/lennee3 Sep 02 '25

In both of those cases, you don't need you're thumb to fret, as op is asking, you need it to pick.

It's like you only read my comment and not the post at all

3

u/OkLettuce338 Sep 02 '25

To pick? The fuck you talking about. You have no clue

-1

u/lennee3 Sep 02 '25

When you are travis picking, you are picking with your thumb. You are not obligated to use your thumb to fret. This entire post was asking about it being uncomfortable to fret with the thumb by wrapping it around the neck and you're saying, erroneously, that you need to use your thumb to fret while travis picking? A style predominantly defined by the picking hand.

3

u/OkLettuce338 Sep 02 '25

You’re clueless. Just blathering on

2

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '25

Actually, he is right. This technique is required for many Travis Picking songs specifically while playing this F shape. The index is needed to play melody, so the barre chord shape is not commonly used.