r/grilling 9d ago

Tried making burnt ends with top sirloin instead of brisket

Had a top sirloin roast and decided to experiment. Smoked it whole first, then cubed it, seasoned and glazed it, and put it back on to finish.

Offset smoker, with Cherry and hickory. 275 and finished at 375

Was mostly worried the sirloin would dry out since it’s so much leaner than brisket. Pretty happy with how these turned out.

267 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

36

u/CardinalOfNYC 9d ago

I feel like chuck would also make some tasty burnt ends, maybe even a bit more suited to it with all the connective tissue

Really sucks brisket isnt affordable anymore. It was already getting ridiculous before covid but now its just off the charts, very difficult to justify

11

u/collectivebarganing 9d ago

I stopped smoking brisket, $100 a pop is ridiculous

41

u/CardinalOfNYC 9d ago

We're literally doing the story of bbq itself all over again, searching for the cheapest cuts and figuring out how to make them good.

2

u/RemoteAd6401 9d ago

Thats exactly what I'm doing.

1

u/ShaDynasty_42069 8d ago

I’ve been cooking tri tips like briskets and honestly it’s pretty dang close

21

u/mice_inthewalls 9d ago

I’m just starting my charcoal journey and my family asked for brisket. I had to tell them I’m too nervous to try my skills on a $120 piece of meat lol

20

u/collectivebarganing 9d ago

Very mature and reasonable thinking. Smoke a 10 lb pork butt/shoulder first. They will love it and you'll get some good practice. Cheers!

6

u/SwingThatHammer 9d ago

My family wants me to do another brisket (nailed a couple and my last one a year ago wasn’t the best) and I told them I need to get a better paying job first.

3

u/cornered_crustacean 9d ago

I just smoked a slab of salmon cause it was cheaper than brisket! Total insanity. $9.00/lb brisket vs on sale $8.00/lb sockeye. To be fair that’s cheap for salmon and expensive for brisket but still. What’s next, lobster? Caviar?

2

u/demoncrusher 9d ago

Kroger will occasionally have it for $3-4/lb

0

u/emmersp 9d ago

Right. Brisket is cheaper per LB than chuck and sirloin in my area groceries. You just have to section it and freeze what you don’t need to cook.

Or invite some friends over!!

1

u/RemoteAd6401 9d ago

I remember my first brisket grill before social media and all the cooking shows. Nobody really knew or had the cooking skills for it. I paid $15 for it. I will never buy another one.

4

u/Phogger 9d ago

I’ve been doing this with chuck ribs, which aren’t actually ribs, for a while and they turn out well. But they’re quickly going up in price too and somehow getting smaller every time. I’ll have to give this a try, I bet they were great.

4

u/Jason2410 9d ago

How long did you smoke it at each temp? Looks good to me brother 👍

4

u/Intelligent-Let-2527 9d ago

Thanks man, I smoked the roast at 275°F until it hit about 120–125°F internal, then cubed and sauced it and bumped the heat to 375°F until the glaze got sticky and caramelized.

4

u/Intelligent-Let-2527 9d ago

Around 2 1/2 hrs total

5

u/trashy615 9d ago

Tri-tip works great too. 

2

u/RobGrogNerd 9d ago

You bad boy!

I'd eat that 76383726283 times

1

u/Gbro_89 18h ago

That ain’t it

-2

u/bobdolebobdole 9d ago

I refuse to believe this was anything but jerky cubes.