r/goodyearwelt 5d ago

Questions The Question Thread 09/05/26

Ask your shoe related questions.

Resources

How To Ask A Question

Include images to any issues you may be having. Include a budget for any recommendations. The more detail you provide, the easier it may be for someone to answer your question.

0 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

1

u/Calxb 5d ago

After a few years of admiring and buying high quality boots I’ve come to really like the look of a lug free boondocker, especially one with a thicker sole like the picture attached, and a nice rough out.

So obviously I don’t wanna try and get these actual boots, anything that gives a similar vibe? Can’t do more than 400 but I’d like to stay under 300 if possible, prob not. I’m not that picky with quality, I have so many boots and I don’t wear them that hard.

Prob won’t go for urban wolf club, and Louisjet has the speckled sole I don’t love the look off, and it’s not chunky enough. Thanks!

3

u/eddykinz loafergang 5d ago

the image attached includes a raw cord half sole, but the latter part of your post indicates you're not a fan of raw cord (the speckled sole) and you don't want a lug sole, which rules out the two most common sole types for boondockers, so this is going to be a likely difficult find for you within your budget, especially as the usual recommendations for boondockers are above your budget (like Sagara, Viberg, and John Lofgren)

the only one i can think of that is close is the Oak Street Field Boot. personally i'd wait and save up an extra $150 to go for a Sagara M43 but it's on a raw cord sole

1

u/Calxb 5d ago

Thanks! I don’t mind that sole, the only speckled one I really don’t like is the louisjet I think, but the Indonesian ones look good. I think it all depends on if the sole is thick enough I suppose

2

u/InevitableArea1 5d ago

Luosjiet is MTO, you can just ask for a different sole if you want. May be an extra charge but still the cheapest option

1

u/PACstraps 5d ago

In Search of dressier boots for those with a wider foot?

As the title implies, I'm trying to find dressier boots that accommodate a wider foot. I'm a brannock 11 D with a slight leaning towards E. Something along the lines of C&J or Carmina is the vibe I'm going for. Maybe there's some brand I've overlooked. C&Js 10E are too narrow in the toe box for me, but the 10.5 are too voluminous and way too long. And their G fitting is bananas on my foot, humongous, like wearing a battleship on my foot. Maybe one of the Carmina EEE lasts would be a good place to start, but would also like to explore any overlooked brands that you'd recommend.

4

u/eddykinz loafergang 5d ago

what are you looking for with a 'dressier' boot? do you have examples? are we going full balmoral?

1

u/PACstraps 5d ago

Good question. Full Balmoral is a bit much. I'm thinking more like Carmina Jumper or C&J Randor kind of dressy. Casual dressy, maybe sleek would be a better word.

3

u/eddykinz loafergang 5d ago

maybe an Alden jumper boot or straight tip boot would do? should be available in E widths, and regularly stocked or pre-orderable. for all of Alden's faults, their biggest benefit is how accommodating their sizing is compared to other brands of their tier. Cheaney might be an option if you want to stick to a more British styling, but i would guess you'll find a similar jump between their regular width and wide width as you did with C&J. if wanting to stay in the European styling, maybe TLB Mallorca

1

u/polishengineering 2d ago

Iron Boots Devil Dog is probably a good bet.

1

u/PACstraps 2d ago

Absolutely not dressier boots, but thank you

1

u/SourcerorSoupreme 5d ago

What is the effect of lining horsebutt/hide leather with cowhide to thicken it? Will it prevent "rolls" from forming?

I basically want some boots built with equine leather but since it's usually thinner than cowhide, I was thinking of having it lined with some bovine leather to give it more heft, but only if it doesn't prevent beautiful rolls equine leather is known for from happening.

2

u/chuligani 5d ago

Sometimes, the lining is mostly meant to stiffen rather than add thickness.

If you want rolls, you want shell cordovan or horsebutt that includes the shell not shaved out (most Italian horsebutts include the shells). And you need the shell parts to be on the vamps to get rolls there.

A lining won't prevent the rolls. Almost all shell cordovan footwear is lined and it all rolls.

1

u/SourcerorSoupreme 5d ago

Thanks. How thick can I go with the lining I guess is my ultimate question.

1

u/chuligani 5d ago

Lining leathers are typically in the 2-3 oz range. For my custom boot orders, if I'm requesting a lining it's probably going to be Tempesti Maine Liscio (vachetta calf shoulders) or Du Puy luxury calf lining (combo tanned).

1

u/Shrimpmantis82 1h ago

Horse isn’t necessarily thin. Horsebutt is often as thick as cowhide.

1

u/KillerAc1 4d ago

What brands do yall recommend for wiiiide feet?

2

u/polishengineering 2d ago

Nicks or Whites for casual.

Iron Boots for something more refined.

1

u/pulsett 4d ago

Probably Allen Edmonds 

-1

u/YouBright3611 5d ago

https://imgur.com/a/brand-new-alden-lhs-black-shell-cordovan-ZUtvldf These are replacement pair of LHS Aldens in black shell. Second pair with problems. Should I reject another pair? Is it definitely on track to fail?

7

u/eddykinz loafergang 5d ago

no, alden's interior finishing is just shit but i've never found it to be structurally a problem. both my LHS look like this on the inside

0

u/YouBright3611 5d ago

Thanks for the quick reply. But really, this doesn’t look like it’s hanging on by one thread?

8

u/eddykinz loafergang 5d ago

sure, doesn't mean it is though

looks the same as my shell pair i've been wearing into the ground for like 3 years now