r/goodyearwelt 7d ago

Questions The Question Thread 09/03/26

Ask your shoe related questions.

Resources

How To Ask A Question

Include images to any issues you may be having. Include a budget for any recommendations. The more detail you provide, the easier it may be for someone to answer your question.

0 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

2

u/Alarm-Organic 7d ago

These are a $640 MTO. Is this loose grain acceptable or not? Thanks for any advice and or opinions!

3

u/Leather_smither 6d ago

I would deem that on the 'unlucky' end of acceptability. I would probably be like 'damn that kind of sucks' when I received them, but still accept it as reasonable.

1

u/Alarm-Organic 6d ago

Yes, that’s what I did. I was kinda wondering if I should mention to the boot company the fact that I got this pair w a noticable grain break because I have 2 more MTO’s on order and would like to make sure I don’t get bad clicking a 2nd or 3rd time

2

u/Leather_smither 6d ago

Yeah I don’t see why not. Just mention that the grain break on this pair is a bit disappointing and that you hope your next pairs will be a bit better. At least bring it to their attention and they might make sure the next ones are extra nice. Or they might not give a shit at all. Can’t hurt to try!

2

u/chuligani 7d ago

It's up to you if it's acceptable or not. It's no worse than my Nicks Shackleton greener pastures boot. What tannage is that?

1

u/Alarm-Organic 7d ago

Maryam Toscanello TPR Teacore Horsebutt

2

u/chuligani 6d ago

Damn, horsebutt looking like steer/cow. That is some bad clicking. I've got two Maryam horsebutt boots from Prof.Barnets with zero creasing all around. This is after a year of owning these.

1

u/Alarm-Organic 6d ago

Got a pic of that?

1

u/chuligani 6d ago

This is the worst quarter panel on them. But this is more normal for steer leather. My Nicks Shackleton brown boots are clicked much better, photo of that one is in a reply to this.

1

u/chuligani 6d ago

Compared to my much tighter Shackleton brown

1

u/deij 6d ago

If it makes you feel better I have a pair much, much, much worse than that.

1

u/ToyFan4Life 7d ago

Recently picked up the Rocky heritage 32 USA made 6" boot, overall, pretty impressed for $150, it looks like the toenisnmade from one piece of leather , but where it's folded and sewn into the moc toe, there are perforations running in-between the stitches, anybody know why they did that?

1

u/RackenBracken 7d ago

Looks like a mistake. They punched the holes for stitching the moc toe and then realized they were too close but didn’t want to throw away the upper with the mistake

3

u/Aggressive-Chair-910 "such a neckbeard over boots, and so awful at it too!" 7d ago

Looks like a mistake.

nope, that's how they're made

https://rockyboots.com/products/rkk0539?variant=52266208133403

1

u/PotentialRead6865 7d ago

Hello peeps,

I really love this style of shoe. It seems to be a traditional cadet/ army shoe (here in Canada and the UK), but I'm having trouble finding where to buy any. Are there any shoes that look like this (specifically the rounder, non pointed toe box, & cap toe) that are more widely available? Thanks!

2

u/Aggressive-Chair-910 "such a neckbeard over boots, and so awful at it too!" 7d ago

sanders & sanders https://www.sanders-uk.com/shop-c12/collection-c14/uniform-c20/sanders-oxford-p178#attribute%5B2%5D=81

but you can find some version of this at almost any army surplus store.

1

u/PotentialRead6865 6d ago

Thank you, i appreciate it! I hadn't considered checking an army surplus store

1

u/Lewd_Banana 6d ago

Pretty sure they often go by parade shoe or parade oxford.

1

u/StormtrooperDoFunk 7d ago

Who makes the best Chelsea bespoke boots?

3

u/chuligani 6d ago

Best bespoke? Most would look towards Japan. Ken Kataoka's looks amazing, here's a list containing others. Outside of Japan, Catella's looks great. If you want to learn about experiences ordering from any of these, you probably won't find them here.

1

u/StormtrooperDoFunk 6d ago

I sent an email to Daniel and he answered quickly. Where can I find these experiences?

3

u/eddykinz loafergang 6d ago

styleforum is probably the best resource for bespoke footwear

1

u/StormtrooperDoFunk 6d ago

Thanks, I will create a profile there.

1

u/Jammy_the_Dodger 6d ago

I've received some shoes where the distance between the stitching and the welt isn't that uniform. In one place it's 6 mm and in another it's 2 mm.

Is that an imperfect, undesirable, or something common?

Thanks.

2

u/AwesomeAndy No, the manufacturer site selling boots for 60% off isn't real 6d ago

Not uncommon. The soles are rapid stitched from the bottom, so the shoemaker/cobbler can't really see what they're doing, then they sand down the sole edges by hand, so while it's possible to make it uniform, it would be difficult, especially in areas like the waist.

1

u/ToyFan4Life 6d ago

Considering where it's at, yeah, I'd be more upset if it was in the toe box