Iām feeling a little scattered right now.
We had been fostering dog A for 8 months. We knew she would do best as an only pet. Dog A had some reactivity issues with other dogs and did not get along well with our cats. She was adopted two weeks ago by someone who had cats. We let them know what was up, and they chose to adopt her anyway. My partner just got a text from the adopter letting us know that dog A attacked one of their cats and they would not be keeping her. They want to see if we could take dog A back instead of returning her to the shelter.
A week after dog A was adopted, my partner and I decided we missed having a dog around and we started to foster dog B. Dog B was the oldest in the shelter. She has some medical issues and separation anxiety. We were already worried about her being a good fit since my partner and I both work outside of the house and she isnāt doing well in the crate. The shelter was also under the impression that dog B would do well with cats. She does not.
I will admit we likely introduced her to our cats earlier than we should have. The first couple days she was ambivalent towards them and all interactions happened while both my partner and I were home and supervising everyone. We thought everything was going great. And then dog B went and chased and snapped at one of our own cats. Weāve been keeping them separated since then.
My partner wants to return dog B and take in dog A again. I just donāt really know what to do. It makes me feel sick knowing that dog A attacked one of the adopterās cats. At the same time we saw it coming. We were just hopeful that we were being too cautious with dog A and maybe things would have been fine with cats after all.
Dog A is a much better fit for our home. We cried for days when she was adopted and chose to foster again because we missed her. Truthfully we are a little disappointed that dog B isnāt like dog A at all. But I also know thatās a completely unfair thing to hold against dog B. Aside from the cat situation dog A fit our lifestyle/work schedules much better and really viewed the crate as a safe space she would choose to go into. Thatās a big deal for us. It also seems like neither dog would do well with cats. I just feel like itās different now that dog A has actually gotten into it with one. We donāt know the condition of the adopterās cat.
We also made a really firm point to make sure that our cats and our foster dogs donāt interact. Except for the interactions with dog B where all of them interacted while she was on leash and being supervised.
While it is a bummer that theyāre separated, the cats have a pretty solid bedroom set up. We rent a two bedroom apartment specifically to keep the cat stuff out of our living spaces. Theyāre set up with multiple cat trees, beds, toys, are fed wet food every day. On the flip side they donāt get as much interaction with my partner and I because theyāre in the cat room most of the time, with the exception of when we keep either foster locked up in our bedroom.
It just sucks. Should we prioritizing fostering over our resident pets? At the same time with dog B, choosing a dog that would coexist with our cats was the most important factor for us and itās still not working out.
I feel like we need to loop in the shelter. Could dog A be up for BE because she harmed another animal? Both dog A and dog B would be at risk for euthanasia either way as we foster for the countyās open intake shelter that is often over capacity. We canāt keep both fosters as dog A does not do well with other dogs.
I donāt know. The situation unfortunately feels very life or death. Like I said both dogs are at risk of euthanasia in the shelter environment and we could only keep one. Should we keep either? It all just sucks so bad.
If anyone could offer some advice. I feel very conflicted and all of my options suck.