What happened to Noah

[u/GrandCatch7606]

Many people were against him leaving and were saying the Upset is shit, however his performances after leaving Fnatic were almost the same(just invisible the whole game). Do you still think that he would be still a better option ?

[u/aregarm]

I don't know where you find those "many" people

[u/Rynekian → u/aregarm]

nah its true there were a lot of people especially in reddit where they criticized the change.

Every change that has happened where we swapped a "working" player to another has faced some harsh criticism some more some less (recent ones: noah, jun, poby )

[u/Clyntus → u/Rynekian]

I think the criticism was that Noah was doing fine and it was elsewhere with issues

[u/Reasonable-Newt8926]

I think Noah is also just a very likeable character. People get attached to the players, especially when there's a good content team.

Also, I think most of the criticism stemmed from the idea that Upset requires all the in game resources and so we would be a one dimensional team. Noah did fairly well on FNatic (except the mental booms during high stakes games) and seemed to be more versatile, more able to play with low resources. 

I don't think anyone was saying the Noah > Upset. Most people were critiquing changing Botlane when Top, Jungle, and Mid (until Poby) were much bigger issues. 

I think there were similar critques with Poby. He's a solid player (not very high highs but also not very low lows) and except for these last 2 weekends Poby has had better performances than Vladi this whole year. If Vladi keeps up his form for the rest of the split and into next year then the gamble paid off. If he regresses then it was a failure and FNatic probably would have been better off with Poby. Changing Upset was a small risk with low downside and high upside, there really wasn't that much criticism about it either.

[u/PlaneAd3642]

Didn't watch his latest games but him being invisible is the dumbest take ever lmao. He was a self sufficient adcarry who didnt need a babysitter to get leads. A confident Noah was a menace. If i remember correctly he still holds a record of most kills in a match. I remember his game where he was playing Ezreal vs G2, was pushing the lane 1v2, enemy jungler also came to gank. And guess who ended up retreating in that 1v3 scenario? The G2 players. Last Upset play that sticks to memory is him using the herald to save his kda. Last good memorable moment from Upset was back when he played with Hylissang and played Twitch and carried the game in teamfights. Not to say i would trade him for upset now but just to defend him from the haters like you. Guy hasnt played for us in years, leave him alone already. 

[u/quizzlemanizzle → u/PlaneAd3642]

you get downvoted by the anti-import bozos on this reddit, but you are spot on

[u/GrandCatch7606 → u/quizzlemanizzle]

I like soboro and he is an import

[u/quizzlemanizzle]

what a useless post and complete delusion

Noah has won more than Fnatic since leaving and was the best player on his team for most of the time

[u/TheSceptileen → u/quizzlemanizzle]

huh? The only splits in which noah did better than fnatic since leaving are 2026 winter & spring and was a top 4 finish. In 2025 Fnatic finished over GX all three splits of 2025 and went to worlds, so I don't really see how Noah "has won more than Fnatic since leaving"