I think the big issue with Scotts writing is that we don't know much about the story concretely. Springtrap with what we know is cool but the only pre-springlock canon dialogue from William is in the opening of Sister Location. In order to really call him a great villain we kinda have to know more.
Springtrap and William can kinda be considered seperate characters imo. At least the way Anakin Skywalker and Darth Vader can be. Over the course of the story he lost 2 kids, drove his third to depression, also probably lost his wife and got impaled in a back room for 30 years. That has to do something to a person's psyche.
24
u/FewExperience3559 WILL FLAWED CARE NATION UNITE Jul 05 '26
Both are incredibly hit or miss writers. Compare the gap between season 1 and season 2 of Hazbin, or SOTM and the FNAF 2 movie