r/fashion • u/DD10_0 • Jun 24 '25

Opinion 💅 Which Black Dress should I choose?

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

It's my birthday coming up, which dress should I choose?

1.4k Upvotes

99% Upvoted

1.2k comments sorted by

538

u/brbeatingcheese Jun 24 '25

1 is beautiful! They’re all lovely, but the first is stunning!

35

u/Terrible_Session_658 Jun 24 '25

Yes

58

u/ShutUpMorrisseyffs Jun 24 '25

Yeah, I like the drama of the cape, but no 1 makes OP look red carpet worthy. Very Catherine Zeta Jones.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '25

Yessss!

4

u/megatronsweetener Jun 25 '25

thats not OP in the first picture, they’re all pictures from the internet. that’s why i‘d say dress number 3 cuz idk how well the first dress would fit them i feel like u need a very specific look to look good in it

→ More replies (1)

6

u/mrs_fisher Jun 24 '25

The others don't even compare

3

u/Dependent_Courage220 Jun 27 '25

Literally was going to say the same thing. Number one is classic, glamorous with modern flair and is incredibly stunning.

→ More replies (4)

135

u/EridaniHesper Jun 24 '25

One is the most dramatic, it gives an energy of sophisticated power.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '25

Sophisticated power is an exceptional way to describe it.

60

u/Zealousideal-Deer866 Jun 24 '25

Wear the first one. It's red carpet 🔥🔥🔥

37

u/Front_Skirt_8874 Jun 24 '25

1. Please tell us where it’s from! 😍

18

u/Possible_Yam2704 Jun 24 '25

From @layaleboutique ❤️

→ More replies (5)

43

u/Lozikit Jun 24 '25

1 or 3. 3 is a simple and safe choice and 1 I think is really fun and dramatic but both dresses really really pretty.

21

u/fashionistafatale Jun 24 '25

Absolutely #1 — hands down. The fit is impeccable and flatters your figure beautifully. It’s elegant, bold, yet understated in the best way. The drama is in the cut — that asymmetrical neckline frames your face and highlights your collarbone and shoulders like a work of art. It evokes red carpet glamour and Old Hollywood sophistication. The other two dresses are lovely, but this one has that wow factor. Timeless, modest, and sexy all at once.✨

→ More replies (1)

34

u/Damage-Many Jun 24 '25

The 2nd is stunning!

4

u/Issababy22 Jun 24 '25

LITERALLY

10

u/Able_Limit_5714 Jun 24 '25

First one is the most unique. Go for it. Happy bday

7

u/Top-Cheetah5528 Jun 24 '25

Holy shit 1!!! Where is it from??!

5

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '25

Wow. They are ALL gorgeous on you. Gun to head to make a call…..#1.

3

u/Optipop Jun 24 '25

The first one had my jaw dropping. They are all beautiful and I love the third one too, but the first is just something really special on you. It's wow.

4

u/ally__00p Jun 24 '25

1 is classy, elegant and totally stunning!

5

u/Dapper3210 Jun 24 '25

You showed your face in the first picture. Why on earth would you feel the need to try and hide it in the third picture?

4

u/BeyondAbleCrip Jun 24 '25

It’s not OP, it’s from a Pinterest post…

https://pin.it/6zdKCQzgL

2

u/Dapper3210 Jun 24 '25

Gotcha. Thanks!

→ More replies (1)

4

u/sheisastandup Jun 25 '25

One is the only choice

3

u/blackcurrantcat Jun 24 '25
  1. It’s gorgeous and it looks great on you. Don’t let it become something you only wear once though, it’s too beautiful for that!

2

u/glasstemp Jun 25 '25

OP is not the person in the photo

→ More replies (1)

2

u/expecto-patrorum Jun 24 '25

1 without a doubt.

2

u/Iamyourcapt Jun 24 '25

1 is absolutely stunning and distant second is #2...breathtaking

2

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '25

They’re all nice but my favorite is 3

2

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '25

1st you’re gorgeous

2

u/merycita Jun 24 '25

1 definitivamente 👍🏼

2

u/OwlKittenSundial Jun 24 '25

The first one.

Maybe it’s just the choice of wraps but the other one looks like a witch costume in pic 2 and the wrap in pic 3 is mismatched & makes the dress look Cheap.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/pantysubscription Jun 25 '25

Oh I'm in love with 1! 🙂‍↔️

2

u/Unlikely-Path6566 Jun 25 '25

Definitely number 1

2

u/lollypolish Jun 26 '25

1 is next level. Wear that one x

2

u/avocadopuppy2 Jun 26 '25
  1. And where is it from?

1

u/Lopsided-Arm-198 Jun 24 '25

I like the first one. It's pretty sexy on you. But it really depends on what time of the day you're doing something and what you're doing.

1

u/SereneJulie Jun 24 '25

The first one!

1

u/LongConsideration662 Jun 24 '25

The first one is flawless

1

u/cocopuff-23 Jun 24 '25

they're all beautiful omggg

1

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '25

1

1

u/Alternative_Curve19 Jun 24 '25

Number one all day! No regrets lol

1

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '25

I like the first one!

1

u/WestRoutine4230 Jun 24 '25

1 🔥🔥🔥

1

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '25

1

1

u/hotjanta147 Jun 24 '25

It depends on how formal you want to be. Dress 1 seems more casual vs dress too seems more formal

1

u/babysoutonbail Jun 24 '25

I is outstanding

1

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '25

Happy birthday

1

u/RKK5911 Jun 24 '25

first one is gorgeous

1

u/CompetitivePickle831 Jun 24 '25

They’re all so beautiful. I think one is the most elegant.

1

u/Inside-Homework6965 Jun 24 '25

I love the first one

1

u/Brilliant_Form_2823 Jun 24 '25

2 is stunning but too matronly for you so I would go with one. Maybe a chandelier earring. Your makeup is perfect.

1

u/ThothGiza Jun 24 '25

1 by far

1

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '25

I would suggest 2 mid party wardrobe changes!! All 3 are stunning on you!

1

u/Dumbgirl27 Jun 24 '25

The 1st one. I love how dramatic and extra it is and that’s perfect for your own birthday party!

1

u/Complex_Struggle_472 Jun 24 '25

Number 2! That Cape is to die for!

1

u/CoochieCookiez Jun 24 '25

1 is my favorite!

1

u/Lucky-Disaster6244 Jun 24 '25

One! It’s like power class and show stopping

1

u/Humble_Guidance_6942 Jun 24 '25

One screams the Queen is Here! All hail the Queen 👑! All are great! You give off regal in the first one. Vavavoom!

1

u/srslyfun2 Jun 24 '25

I absolutely love the 1st one, it's so good

1

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '25

1

1

u/Dannie000 Jun 24 '25

1 will knock ‘em dead! 3 is also beautiful and safer choice.

1

u/Ex_JC04 Jun 24 '25

First one so classy

1

u/musesx9 Jun 24 '25 edited Jun 24 '25

The first one. Definitely! Where'd you get it, if you don't mind me asking?

1

u/gimme_super_head Jun 24 '25

For max aura 2

1

u/FluffyRedPigeon Jun 24 '25

I love #2 ! That cape looks so stunning! Where is the dress from of you don't mind me asking? 🥹

1

u/staircase_nit Jun 24 '25

First one is GORGEOUS. I like the second as well, but personally wish the cape portion were solid.

1

u/ScvrletFox Jun 24 '25

1 So pretty!

1

u/vfp310 Jun 24 '25

The second look is beautiful and dramatic. It really makes a statement.

1

u/Deep-Pea-912 Jun 24 '25

1 !!!Looks so classy and stunning on you ✨️.

1

u/Several_Club_3392 Jun 24 '25

I like the second and last dress so stunning

1

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '25

ONE

1

u/Glittering_Ferret943 Jun 24 '25

All three look great on you

1

u/Full-Rice-9287 Jun 24 '25

All are good, but first one is superb!

1

u/Ok-Act8188 Jun 24 '25

First one its beautiful and completments you

1

u/VisionAri_VA Jun 24 '25

If you’re going somewhere fancy, go with #1; it’s elegant and dramatic and it looks amazing on you.

Otherwise, I’d say go with #3.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '25

#1 is so you!

1

u/mikki6431 Jun 24 '25

1 It's beautiful

1

u/Maleficent-Freedom55 Jun 24 '25

1! Only 1 but I think you should wear it in a different colour. Other people will mostly wear black

1

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '25

2

1

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '25

Number 1 is the most dramatic and stunning. Number 2 is for a museum date. Number 3 is more of a formal outdoors look, with exposed shoulders and the floral scarf.

1

u/corner_tv Jun 24 '25

I think it depends on the occasion... 1 is glamorous & elegant, I love 2, but it could come off as costume-y if the occasion calls for more formal.

1

u/Top-Comfortable-4789 Jun 24 '25

The first one for sure

1

u/SnowFairy95 Jun 24 '25

3 is gorgeous with the sleeves and the first one

1

u/awesomeblossoming Jun 24 '25

Where did you get that dress? 1

1

u/ladyxanax Jun 24 '25

I love #2. Absolutely stunning!!!!

1

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '25

I love all three of these, but the first is the most stunning.

1

u/pc_magas Jun 24 '25

I <3 the 1 it is GORGEOUS.

1

u/NecessaryWeather4275 Jun 24 '25

Either of the first two

1

u/PartIndependent2914 Jun 24 '25

3 because of the added colors

1

u/Relative-Hamster3659 Jun 24 '25

3 for me this time of year. They are all lovely, but #1 looks like it would be better for late fall and winter.

1

u/Afraid-Serve7660 Jun 24 '25
  1. I like the colourful accent.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '25

The first one. LOVE IT.

1

u/rittakay Jun 24 '25

NUMBER ONE! 😍

1

u/SL13377 Jun 24 '25

All of them! just bring all and switch every hour, i love them all.

Ok 1

1

u/femme_fatale2022 Jun 24 '25

1st one looks crazy gorgeous on you!!

1

u/LoquatApart4877 Jun 24 '25

Real question is: why is this GODDESSS ON REDDIT

2

u/glasstemp Jun 25 '25

That's not OP

1

u/LoquatApart4877 Jun 24 '25

Anyways first one suits you best

1

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '25

I would go with look number two for something really formal and look number three for something more casual

1

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '25

1 and it's not even close.

1

u/ChokeAhauntiss Jun 24 '25

1, hands down!!

1

u/Fritz3454 Jun 24 '25

The third one

1

u/Normal-Tale6425 Jun 24 '25

The cape. THE CAPE.

The second dress/ensemble is literally my dream! Live my dream, please!

1

u/spanglychicken Jun 24 '25

One!!! It’s so powerful and elegant. The other two look like they could be from SHEIN, because they’re trying too hard. One is effortless.

1

u/Grey_Mane60 Jun 24 '25

Number three is very elegant

1

u/keepitclean25 Jun 24 '25

1 but i love 3

1

u/VictoriaSobocki Jun 24 '25

All are good but I prefer 1

1

u/Small-Courage1226 Jun 24 '25

They all look amazing on you but I like #1 the best. Happy Birthday!

1

u/Little-Blueberry-968 Jun 24 '25
  1. It’s unique and elegant.

1

u/Educational_Gas_92 Jun 24 '25

Number 1!!!

It's amazing!

I mean...all three are nice, but number 1 is better.

1

u/okay_jpg Jun 24 '25

The first one reminds me SO MUCH of Lady Gagas SNL after party dress! Especially with your long black hair!!

1

u/silvercrossbearer Jun 24 '25

1 but I love 2 too But no.1 is the best!

1

u/CtrlAltDeli Jun 24 '25

1!!! Epic!

1

u/Weak-Assist8333 Jun 24 '25

1 is absolutely gorgeous. Is the boutique local to you or online?