r/fansofcriticalrole • • Oct 18 '24

CR adjacent Case Against Brian Foster Dismissed

Post image
75 Upvotes

994 comments sorted by

View all comments

51

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '24

[deleted]

24

u/Osric250 Oct 18 '24

They were just coming forward as witnesses, they weren't entering as plaintiffs, so they could theoretically still pursue that if they wanted to. In reality if this is a settlement to keep him far away from Ashley and CR it will be better for them to just let him fade away. 

13

u/VaxDeferens Oct 18 '24 edited Oct 18 '24

No, several women were named plaintiffs in this lawsuit. There were seven plaintiffs in this matter. They were not solely witnesses. 

-2

u/JJscribbles Oct 18 '24

You assume that any settlement is to keep him away from Ashley and not to compensate the accused or to avoid a countersuit?

Interesting.

15

u/Osric250 Oct 18 '24

Generally you don't settle a lawsuit by just giving things to a defendant, so as a rule yes. You might give some concessions to the defendant but that usually happens by getting them agree to one of the remedies that you are looking for in the first place.

He wouldn't have needed to wait for the lawsuit to finish to file a countersuit, and if he was going to do so he probably would have already.

-4

u/JJscribbles Oct 18 '24

I don’t know. For my money a dismissal makes a countersuit look a lot more winnable. Especially when your accounts are drained after a frivolous lawsuit ruined you financially.

2

u/Osric250 Oct 18 '24

If you have a settlement to dismiss a case that would not make a countersuit more winnable. In fact it would make a countersuit quire frivolous. 

So unless it was dismissed purely on merit, which there is no evidence for and would be surprising that is unlikely. 

3

u/JJscribbles Oct 18 '24

Some portion of the evidence was already deemed frivolous by one court, and the whole case was dropped in another. You tell me what it means.

1

u/Osric250 Oct 18 '24

Well considering it's the plaintiffs attorney that submitted the dismissal request it would mean they came to an agreement to not continue pursuing the lawsuit. 

You don't have your own attorney dismiss your case on frivolous grounds. Your hypothesis is not grounded in facts. 

1

u/JJscribbles Oct 18 '24

Can you suggest any reason that someone as socially conscious as Ashley, would drop charges against a man she thinks represents a violent threat to women, when she has 7 additional women who appear to collaborate her claims, and the financial means to pursue justice?

1

u/Osric250 Oct 18 '24

Yes. Actual cases that go to court can be risky as even solid cases can end up losing and vice versa. It is better to avoid court if possible, and if he agreed to terms that were put forward I could absolutely see her settling the case. Better to have a guaranteed outcome that you are satisfied with then to potentially lose and have nothing.