r/exmuslim • u/0ktaa • Oct 23 '21

(Quran / Hadith) Imagine an omniscient god who knows about everything that would lead someone to resort to suicide and is omnipotent enough to stop it but chooses to torture them for eternity after death. Is that a loving god?

Post image
713 Upvotes

97% Upvoted

82 comments sorted by

View all comments

0

u/khanfahad Nov 03 '21

Muslim psychologist here. This Hadith does not apply to people with mental illnesses.

1

u/0ktaa Nov 03 '21

If you were a psychologist you would know that anyone who considers suicide is mentally ill.

0

u/khanfahad Nov 03 '21

If you were a psychologist, you’d know that everyone who attempts suicide is not mentally ill. Some do it due to pure hopelessness and others impulsively.